5 ms·
There is a much greater depth of detail that I provide to my tax preparer than I'd be willing to share with the IRS. I tell my tax preparer everything and have
by sokoloff 6y ago
There is a much greater depth of detail that I provide to my tax preparer than I'd be willing to share with the IRS. I tell my tax preparer everything and have perfect confidence that my taxes will be prepared correctly and in accordance with the tax code and that nothing which is not required to be disclosed will be disclosed. Much of what I provide to my preparer is irrelevant to my tax obligations and anything that's irrelevant I would prefer not be disclosed.
I'm mostly a W-2 schmo without any particularly complex business arrangements and with a spouse who employs themself in a consulting capacity, puts the statutory maximum into tax-deferred accounts every year, and we have minor kids who are required to file returns due to kiddie tax laws.
I can imagine many people would rather pay a high three or low four-figure per year bill for tax prep and representation rather than give the IRS full access to their financial lives.
I do support (and strongly so) the idea that the IRS could provide simple, default tax prep based on the information they receive. Where I break is what escalation path should exist; I think there must remain an effective and private escalation path for more complex scenarios. (In many ways, that makes it even easier to implement. Make the simple case automated-by-default. Punt all the complex cases to the current system.)
- harperlee 6y agoMay I ask examples of things that you are not confident sharing with the IRS, that you do not have the obligation to share with the IRS, and that can affect the taxes you owe? In my (foreign) mind, whatever might affect your obligation final number you are legally required to do so (either preemptively or when asked), so I don't fully understand.
- sokoloff 6y agoMany things that I tell my preparer are needed later, but not now. (Tax basis for RSUs that vested. Value of capital improvements to my property.) Other things are needed only if we elect to method A of calculation, but not if we use method B of calculation. So I give him all the data; he computes my obligations using method A and method B, chooses the better option, and reports only the data needed to support that method's calculations. I pay my preparer to be an expert in tax code, to represent me in any audits, and incidentally to prepare my return correctly. Part of that expertise is that I don't have to be an expert, so I tell him everything and he politely rolls his eyes and smiles when I dump irrelevant things on his desk.
- tomjakubowski 6y agoThen let the government distribute this hypothetical preparation software as free software. It could therefore be verified that you're not telling the state more than you want them to know.
- Larrikin 6y agoYou are making an argument for a simplified tax code and reporting system. The not needed now but maybe later financials should already be reported by the financial institution to the tax agencies. There should not exist a system where there is a method A, B or C and if you have thousands of dollars a tax accountant can find all the loop holes to make you pay the least. You should just pay what is owed, not more or less. You wouldn't pay for tax preparation if the potential savings weren't more than what you pay him. With a simplified system there also wouldn't be much need for the audit help you are usually offered when using their assistant
- maxerickson 6y agoA tax preparer could presumably still help you make the decision about what information to share with the IRS. I guess they would be something else, but you get the point.
- harperlee 6y agoBut isn’t it tax fraud if you consciously withhold information that would negatively impact on your total obligation?
- brigade 6y agoYou do realize that $1k is about 10% of the median household income tax liability? I can't imagine the majority of people happily accept a 10% (more for half of households) tax hike, when companies already CC the IRS on all the forms they're regurgitating.
- sokoloff 6y agoI'm actually fairly shocked that $10K is the median income tax liability given that a substantial percentage of households pay no net federal income tax.
- ska 6y agoIt's probably median for households that pay any tax.
- spullara 6y agoThis statistic I think is with respect to those that owe tax rather than for all households (it excludes 1/3rd of those that file returns): "The most recent IRS data revealed that Americans who filed taxable returns paid an average income tax payment of $15,322 in 2018. This number was calculated based on the returns of over 153 million American households who filed during that period, which included just over 100 million taxable returns."
- Larrikin 6y agoWhat is an example of something legal that you would be afraid of the IRS seeing? I can't imagine any scenario that most people (anywhere close to fifty percent of tax payers) would be willing to lose a significant portion to all of their refund check by needing to pay a tax preparer potentially thousands of dollars.
- sokoloff 6y agoAnswered a sibling with a similar question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26333946 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26333946
- tylerhou 6y agoI don't think anyone here is advocating for a system where you cannot prepare your tax return privately. The problem is that private tax preparation corporations have lobbied to make an IRS system illegal.
- masklinn 6y ago> There is a much greater depth of detail that I provide to my tax preparer than I'd be willing to share with the IRS. I tell my tax preparer everything and have perfect confidence that my taxes will be prepared correctly and in accordance with the tax code and that nothing which is not required to be disclosed will be disclosed. Much of what I provide to my preparer is irrelevant to my tax obligations and anything that's irrelevant I would prefer not be disclosed. Cool beans. Literally nothing preclude you using a tax prep service but using the IRS's tax declaration system, which would double up as a simple tax prep system. That's what happens just about everywhere in Europe: you log in a dedicated government service, and you do your tax declaration. All the stuff the government knows about (salary, loan deductions, dependents, …) is already input, but nothing precludes drilling down and updating details. Nothing is lost compared to a paper declaration.
- ralphc 6y agoAlso, don't forget the IRS has a quasi-adversarial relationship with you. You're trying to pay as little tax as legally allowed, they want you to pay more. They're not motivated to show you ways to pay less tax.
- gamblor956 6y agoThis is false. The IRS wants you to pay the amount calculated as due under the information they have available about your income. The IRS is not motivated to collect more income or to deprive taxpayers of refunds. They're motivated to do their jobs, whether that means issuing a notice of amount due, or paying out a refund check (which they do for millions of taxpayers without issue, every year).
- warkdarrior 6y agoIf I donate to a charity, it may reduce the tax I have to pay, especially my income is at the boundary between two tax brackets. Would IRS suggest such a donation in order to reduce the tax amount? Tax advisors do that all the time.
- loopercal 6y ago>especially my income is at the boundary between two tax brackets Wait, can you explain how tax brackets work because I think there may be a fundamental misunderstanding here. If we have two brackets, 10% for <=$100 and 90% for >$100, what do you think the tax bill would be for someone who earned $101?
- gamblor956 6y agoIt would be $10.90. $10 for the first bracket. The remaining untaxed income is $1, taxed at 90% = $0.90 tax. But the Republican Party has spent a lot of money to make people think that the tax would be $90.90 (i.e,. a flat rate), which is why so many people are opposed to increasing the tax bracket rates...even though the actual affect is marginal to most people (even those affected).