7 ms·
As noted in other comments here, an "auto tax" service only really works on the happy path. There are parts of the tax code which are highly subjective in more
by bob1029 6y ago
As noted in other comments here, an "auto tax" service only really works on the happy path. There are parts of the tax code which are highly subjective in more complex situations and require explicit elections on part of the filing party. These elections can have consequences far beyond the immediate tax filing transaction.
- astura 6y agoNo, it can work with the complicated path too, they present you with what they already know about you and give you the opportunity to add more information that they don't yet know. They then calculate what you owe and tell you. At some point they are going to calculate what you owe based on what you provide them and what is reported to them, no matter what. Laws that authorize "auto tax" can also come with extra reporting requirements.
- dave5104 6y agoNot to mention, I'm sure the "happy path" will accommodate a significant number of tax payers.
- robert_foss 6y agoThis is how it is done in Sweden. And after having lived in 2 other countries it is clearly the way to go. The tax authority sends you a summary and you just approve it.
- sfteus 6y agoThis always made the most sense to me. You get your return and review it; sign off if it's good, modify and return it if you have more claims, something is wrong / missing. I'd wager the majority of people wouldn't have a reason to submit a revised return. And if the federal government generated your return, hopefully that would give them reason to automatically exclude you from audit, (ideally) reducing the burden of auditors.
- dtech 6y agoWorks this way in the Netherlands too, you login on a website and just click through the information they have pre-filled in normal cases.
- vinkelhake 6y agoAs a Swedish expat in California I cringe everytime tax season comes. Both because of how annoying it is, and because I know how simple it can be.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 6y agoThere is a much greater depth of detail that I provide to my tax preparer than I'd be willing to share with the IRS. I tell my tax preparer everything and have perfect confidence that my taxes will be prepared correctly and in accordance with the tax code and that nothing which is not required to be disclosed will be disclosed. Much of what I provide to my preparer is irrelevant to my tax obligations and anything that's irrelevant I would prefer not be disclosed. I'm mostly a W-2 schmo without any particularly complex business arrangements and with a spouse who employs themself in a consulting capacity, puts the statutory maximum into tax-deferred accounts every year, and we have minor kids who are required to file returns due to kiddie tax laws. I can imagine many people would rather pay a high three or low four-figure per year bill for tax prep and representation rather than give the IRS full access to their financial lives. I do support (and strongly so) the idea that the IRS could provide simple, default tax prep based on the information they receive. Where I break is what escalation path should exist; I think there must remain an effective and private escalation path for more complex scenarios. (In many ways, that makes it even easier to implement. Make the simple case automated-by-default. Punt all the complex cases to the current system.)
- harperlee 6y agoMay I ask examples of things that you are not confident sharing with the IRS, that you do not have the obligation to share with the IRS, and that can affect the taxes you owe? In my (foreign) mind, whatever might affect your obligation final number you are legally required to do so (either preemptively or when asked), so I don't fully understand.
- sokoloff 6y agoMany things that I tell my preparer are needed later, but not now. (Tax basis for RSUs that vested. Value of capital improvements to my property.) Other things are needed only if we elect to method A of calculation, but not if we use method B of calculation. So I give him all the data; he computes my obligations using method A and method B, chooses the better option, and reports only the data needed to support that method's calculations. I pay my preparer to be an expert in tax code, to represent me in any audits, and incidentally to prepare my return correctly. Part of that expertise is that I don't have to be an expert, so I tell him everything and he politely rolls his eyes and smiles when I dump irrelevant things on his desk.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- civilized 6y agoThere is a big gap between what tax software companies charge $$$ for and what is actually complex and subjective. Like, if you have an HSA, that instantly boots you into the Deluxe Edition of H&R Block (about $100 federal+state), even if your HSA situation is very straightforward. Tax prep software is worth every penny IMO, but they do nickel-and-dime you for many pretty simple situations.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoMost folks don't have taxes that are that complicated: most of those are businesses. Most people file somewhat simple returns. We can get most people using "Auto-tax", where basically the IRS sends you some information to check over, including what you are going to get back or owe. We can do this for all of the commonly used forms, not just the EZ forms. Most folks aren't subject to "subjective" taxes. Other places do it, after all. The IRS has the information. And it would probably increase tax revenue since it is easier to collect taxes that are easy to pay. (Sales tax is collected at purchase since few people self-report: Sales tax is even easier on the average person if included in price instead of added at the register). You can require that the IRS err on behalf of the taxpayer and require it to give the maximum refund (or pay the least tax). And it isn't like the auto-file would be final: You still get the option for corrections (because mistakes happen) and can still self file.