5 ms·
Even if they stay with cohorts, I assume people will be members of a variety of them. New parent. Lives in Springfield. Works at a power plant. Drives a car
by sandworm101 6y ago
Even if they stay with cohorts, I assume people will be members of a variety of them.
New parent. Lives in Springfield. Works at a power plant. Drives a car. Owns house. Horrible credit rating. Married with 2+ kids. Voted in last election. Ex military. Ex astronaut. Once purchased an effective baldness cure. How many seemingly large cohorts does it take before you are really talking about one clearly identifiable person?
- laurent92 6y ago> How many large cohorts does it take before identifying a person It takes 33 “perfect” yes/no questions to identify uniquely anyone on earth. It is seemingly large since each question splits the world in two. Of course this is in a perfect world, but I remember seeing quizzes which would guess any object given a few yes/no question. Or perhaps it was people.
- sandworm101 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guess_Who%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guess_Who%3F "Each player starts the game with a board that includes cartoon image of 24 people [...] Players alternate asking various yes or no questions to eliminate candidates."
- retzkek 6y ago> Of course this is in a perfect world, but I remember seeing quizzes which would guess any object given a few yes/no question. Or perhaps it was people. https://en.akinator.com/ https://en.akinator.com/
- laurent92 6y agoThis game is incredible. The question always seem to be unrelated to the person to guess, and suddenly it guessed perfectly.
- williamscales 6y agoOn the other hand, I tried to get it to guess Mia Dolan and it took 36 questions, two of which involved Five Nights at Freddies
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoVery easy to break if you guess real-world people not famous for acting, sports or politics.
- oblio 6y agoIt doesn't load the CSS for me, Android/Firefox :-(
- bostik 6y agoCouldn't get to Dianne Morgan in 40 guesses. The closest it got was to ask in sequence whether the character was British, blonde, an actor and a comedian. Not many probably know the person in question with her real name - but almost everyone who's ever watched Charlie Brooker's productions should recognise her as Philomena Cunk.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoDoes your person have glasses? Is your person male? Does he have facial hair? At that point the kids usually go for broke and ask me if my player is Susan.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vineyardmike 6y agoWhile I completely agree with your point, and the number required is probably pretty low, the point of FLOC is that no one will need to identify a real person for any “proper” reason. Advertising rarely is about targeting “John doe” but usually about targeting “[men] && [in Springfield] && [searching for a baldness cures]”. (I still will do everything in my technical power to disable floc, and still will never trust google). But I do think the implementation removes most of the advertising incentive to track on an individual person level.
- sandworm101 6y agoLegitimate advertising. What about the other stuff? What about advertisers who want to swing very specific voters? What about nefarious people who want to put a malware link in front of a specific person. [active military]&&[over 55]&&[lives beside base X]&&[awake before 6am]&&[college education]&&[searched for "retirement planning"] will probably get you the most senior officer at a base/unit. Same too with senior politicians.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vineyardmike 6y ago> Legitimate advertising. > What about the other stuff? Thats what makes FLOC tolerable. The legit stuff is enabled, and it makes it harder to get the other stuff (not impossible of course). > What about nefarious people who want to put a malware link in front of a specific person. It'll at least be harder than pre-floc (ideally). The point is to remove the incentives to collect as much data about an individual (you don't need full profiles of someone) by creating even easier ways to get useful targeting without the direct individual identification. --- (also, i'm broadly against tracking in general, just to be clear. The point you raised is very valid - esp with existing methods).
- jefftk 6y ago> Even if they stay with cohorts, I assume people will be members of a variety of them. No, users are only in a single cohort: "cohort = await document.interestCohort()" -- https://github.com/WICG/floc https://github.com/WICG/floc (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)
- rattray 6y agoErr, what? So there would be one cohort of "new-parent-lives-in-springfield-works-in-power-plant-etc-etc" (combining multiple unrelated interests), it just has to have thousands of people in it? Do cohorts allow advertisers to say, "Show this ad to anyone in a cohort with an affinity for 'new-parent' over threshold X?" is that so? Do they let advertisers say, "here are the cohorts of our best 1000 customers, please show ads to anyone else in those cohorts?" Would people in "my cohort" be the 1000-10000 people most like me in browsing habits in the world? (Disclaimer, have tried to buy limited quantities of ads in the past, interested in some part as an advertiser)
- jefftk 6y ago> Would people in "my cohort" be the 1000-10000 people most like me in browsing habits in the world? Yes: "a browser can group together people with similar browsing habits, so that ad tech companies can observe the habits of large groups instead of the activity of individuals. Ad targeting could then be partly based on what group the person falls into." > there would be one cohort of "new-parent-lives-in-springfield-works-in-power-plant-etc-etc" (combining multiple unrelated interests), it just has to have thousands of people in it? I mean, there aren't thousands of new parents who live in Springfield and work in a power plant? You would be in a cohort like "43A7". > Do cohorts allow advertisers to say, "Show this ad to anyone in a cohort with an affinity for 'new-parent' over threshold X?" is that so? Not really? An advertiser or (ad tech company) might learn, over time, that people in cohort "43A7" are very likely to be interested in baby clothes while people in cohort "5B7E" are more likely than average but not by that much. So they might be willing to bid more to show baby clothes to someone in 43A7 than in 5B7E, and not bid at all for most other cohorts. But the browser API just gives you an opaque cohort identifier. > Do they let advertisers say, "here are the cohorts of our best 1000 customers, please show ads to anyone else in those cohorts?" From my reading of the spec, that seems like it would work well.