3 ms·
On the one hand, I absolutely agree with you. I tremendously lament the fact that outline, color, and shading have been thrown out so now we're trying to deciph
by crazygringo 6y ago
On the one hand, I absolutely agree with you. I tremendously lament the fact that outline, color, and shading have been thrown out so now we're trying to decipher little rounded-box hieroglyphics based on lines being subtly different.
But on the other hand, the problem is that icons took so much work to create before, and also because they had such a recognizable identity/brand they weren't easy to reuse. Now the icons are so generic that they might as well be letters of the alphabet. They kinda are. A right-arrow is just a right-arrow -- it's not a Microsoft Office style right-arrow, or Windows 95 style right-arrow, or Mac Aqua style right-arrow, etc.
These icon fonts make sense for when the icon is meant to be essentially decorative typography -- e.g. a share icon next to the word "share" or an "opens in new tab" link arrow. They work very well for websites.
However, I hate these icon fonts when they're used without a text label besides them -- specifically in toolbars. That's where I wish desperately we could go back to colorful textured icons that were easy to tell apart. Even after years, I still find Gmail's toolbar of monochrome blob icons to be entirely unusable for this reason.
- bckygldstn 6y agoFYI there is a setting in gmail that turns the mystery icons into text labels: https://support.google.com/mail/answer/2473038?hl=en-GB https://support.google.com/mail/answer/2473038?hl=en-GB
- micdr0p 6y agoThank you for this!
- crazygringo 6y agoWow it never even occurred to me there would be a setting for that. Thanks!!
- vintagedave 6y agoBizarrely, it changes the buttons to text _only_. Not a glyph plus caption. A glyph plus text is more recognisable and explanatory than either.
- systemvoltage 6y agoYes, it attaches a particular theme/brand/aesthetic to iconography. I think we should push designers to do the due diligence and not just get something from material.io and dump it in the app. It won't happen because $$$, ship ship ship and MVP culture, agile, etc. Careful, meticulous, rigorous, disciplined, thoughtful work is old fashioned. We produce broken, shitty apps because early feedback culture, not finishing things, market validation, the entire startup culture, etc. I see benefits in this but also negatives. Remember when SEGA games were shipped 100% complete and almost bug free? That's unheard of these days. They had no way to know if the game is going to be successful. No early access. They took risks.
- brudgers 6y agoMost designers can create a good icon. Or two. But a cohesive set of one fifty is going to have a few that are not so good. And some that are outright crap. If a designer is designing icons, the designer is probably solving the wrong problem. Either because the "client" doesn't know what the right problem is. Or because designing icons is more for the designer than solving the right problem. Icons are hard because...well, all the reasons a floppy disk is the standard save icon. What I mean is that designers will default to their own experience and a floppy disk was it when the first sticky save icon was designed. Now it means save. A designer who wants to change the floppy disk is solving the wrong problem.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI discussed this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26332553 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26332553 I agree with you. We should take advantage of existing historical context such as the floppy save icon. This is what the Fam Fam Fam icon set does. The main issue is not to redesign them, but to design them in such a way that it is recognizeable. You can design floppy disk in many ways to fit your design aesthetic. Just that it should not be confused with 10 other icons. If you use monochrome line graphics, its hard to tell instantly.