3 ms·
Cross-breeding will never bring us glow-in-the-dark tomatoes (or cats for that matter). There is some amount of difference between breeding and splicing.
by pyre 15y ago
Cross-breeding will never bring us glow-in-the-dark tomatoes (or cats for that matter). There is some amount of difference between breeding and splicing.
- zeteo 15y agoTake the tomato genome and look at any random pigmenting gene. There are a finite number of mutations (flips, insertions, deletions) to change that into a gene producing glow-in-the-dark proteins. All of those mutations can, and do, occur without human intervention. If only there was any Darwinian advantage for tomatoes to glow in the dark, they would most likely be doing so already.
- pyre 15y agoI think 'most likely' is an over-statement. Most of those mutations are based on random chance. There is nothing that states that over a certain amount of time, every possible random mutation will happen.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoBut it might bring us apricots with arsenic in the flesh (instead of just in the pit) for instance. Or berries that harbor e-coli more readily. With splicing we can examine the goals and techniques and make a reasoned conclusion. Its astonishing to me that we accept "natural" (read: unknown, random) genetic modification without a peep. And yet when an Engineer creates a deliberate breed, the level of fear jumps off the chart. Says more about the public perception of science than it does about genetics I think.