5 ms·
> Multiplication has nothing to do with addition and at some point we have to stop teaching students that it's related. I just finished studying Galois Fields,
by dragontamer 6y ago
> Multiplication has nothing to do with addition and at some point we have to stop teaching students that it's related.
I just finished studying Galois Fields, which LITERALLY redefines multiplication and addition operators to study new forms of math (IE fields in particular)
In all fields and rings, multiplication and addition are related by the distributive property.
A(b + c) is equal to Ab + Ac, in literally every form of math you can every think of. A and b could be matrices, vectors, polynomials, prime numbers, integers, rational, complex, real, or Galois polynomials over a weird modulus ring thingy inside of a vector inside of a matrix. Doesn't matter, addition and multiplication are and always defined in that manner.
- pdonis 6y ago> In all fields and rings, multiplication and addition are related by the distributive property. That's a necessary condition for "repeated addition" to work for multiplication, but not a sufficient one. Try plugging in A = pi to the distributive formula and see how well "repeated addition" works.
- dragontamer 6y agopi(3 + 5) == 3pi + 5pi == (Pi + Pi + Pi) + (Pi + Pi + Pi + Pi + Pi) == 8-pi. Am I missing something here? -------- This "multiplication is repeated addition through the distributed property" thing works on freaking __matricies__. They don't even have to be numbers or even related. Pi * ([ 1 0 ; + [ 1 0 ; 0 1 ] 2 1 ]) Pi * [ 1 0 ; + Pi * [ 1 0 ; 0 1 ] 2 1 ] [ Pi 0 ; + [ Pi 0 ; 0 Pi ] 2Pi Pi ] [ 2Pi 0 ; 2Pi 2Pi ] You can even "break up" the two matricies into its component parts: Pi * ( 1 0 + 0 0 + 1 0 + 0 0 + 0 0 ) 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 0 0 1 And you'll still get the correct answer: multiplication is repeated addition. Even with matricies. Even with vectors. Even in Galois Fields. Even with rational numbers. Even with real numbers. Even with Complex numbers. This property holds through all forms of math that I'm aware of.
- iio8999 6y agoI think the issue is more about: 3 * pi = pi + pi + pi but how do you represent the other distribution, where 3 is added together pi times?
- dragontamer 6y agoBreak-up pi in whatever means you think is reasonable. 3 * (3 + 0.1 + 0.04 + 0.001 + 0.0005...) Aka: 9.4245... You know, how we've been multiplying 3 * pi for our whole lives. We split pi up into an infinite sum of component numbers (3, 1, 4, 1, 5, 9, 2, 6...) and then combine them together by individually multiplying the parts (3 * 3 + 3 * 0.1 + 3 * 0.04...)
- pdonis 6y ago> Break-up pi in whatever means you think is reasonable. You can't. Pi is irrational.
- dragontamer 6y ago> You can't. Pi is irrational. You just need to break it up infinitely times. We usually call the sequence 31415926...
- pdonis 6y ago> You just need to break it up infinitely times. I've responded to this elsewhere in the thread: I don't think adopting increasingly perverse interpretations of "repeated addition" as you try to include more and more numbers is a useful way to teach multiplication.
- beaconstudios 6y agowhat they described is identical to long multiplication. That's not perverse, it's how most people multiply numbers.
- Gibbon1 6y agopi isn't a counting number like you teach to children.
- mnl 6y agoYes, they are two binary operations and depending on the sets you consider and which properties you impose for those operations you have different algebraic structures. (This used to be taught at school before "modern mathematics" were considered harmful, maybe they were but at least they were correct). The thing is that as you can write m (let it be a positive integer) as m=1+...+1 (m-times), you can write n·m=n·(1+...+1), invoke the distributive property for · wrt + and express it as: n·m=n+...+n (m-times), so it looks like "repeated addition" for integers in this case. But it's not a good idea to let ourselves get carried away, we still have two binary operations going on. At any rate we have to impose that n·0=0, which can't be writen cleverly as "repeated addition" and worked up backwards.
- dragontamer 6y ago> At any rate we have to impose that n·0=0, which can't be writen cleverly as "repeated addition" and worked up backwards. n * 0 = n * (1 + (-1)) = n + (-n) = 0. ----- The 0-element in a Galois Field works identically btw. In GF(5), the 0 element is 5 (5 mod 5 == 0). n * (5) == n * 0 == n * (1 + (-1)) == n * (1 + 4) == 0 mod5. For example, if we take "n" == 2, 2 * 5 == 10 mod 5 == 0. 2 * (1 + 4) == 2 + 8 == 2 + 3 (mod 5) == 5 mod 5 == 0. Etc. etc. ------- This property literally holds in all fields and rings (but not groups).
- mnl 6y agoRepeated addition that ain't... It boggles my mind that you've been studying Galois theory yet somehow try to reduce the algebraic structures associated to two binary operations to playing with one of them.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe algebraic structures multiplication brings is different from the algebraic structures from addition. That's the point of rings (as opposed to groups). Nonetheless, in a ring (and all fields are rings), multiplication must and always is related to addition, through the distributed property (which I argue, the distributed property IS the mathematical term for "repeated addition"). Without the distributed property, you have no ring. You at best only have a group. Therefore, all multiplication operators ever defined (or more precisely, all rings) must have multiplication related to addition: (A * (B+C) == AB+AC)