4 ms·
I'll tell you what's wrong: the mentality of the author of this text Multiplication has started as repeated addition. That's where the idea came from. > It is
by raverbashing 6y ago
I'll tell you what's wrong: the mentality of the author of this text
Multiplication has started as repeated addition. That's where the idea came from.
> It is as if there were two types of addition: regular, random, “wild” addition and the specially-bred variety of addition to which we give the name multiplication.
Nobody. Literally nobody said that
Of course, you'll need to forget a bit the idea of repeated multiplication when you get into the rationals/reals/complex numbers, but even there it kinda makes sense
So no, I think this is the kind of teacher that makes the students even more confused and prone to hating math
- contravariant 6y agoNow that's an interesting point, did it start as repeated addition? It is just as conceivable that people were faced with a problem like 'each person needs 2 apples, we have 5 people, so we need 10 apples'? In this case repeated addition is a perfectly fine algorithm to calculate the product but the product itself is not defined as repeated addition, it's the solution to a particular type of problem.
- cyborgx7 6y agoYour problem just reinforces the notion that multiplication is repeated addition. "So we need 2 for him and 2 for her and 2 for him and 2 for him and 2 for her. 2+2+2+2+2 = 5 x 2 = 10"
- contravariant 6y agoI disagree, translating from "2 for (him + her + him + him + her)" to "2 for him + 2 for her + 2 for him + 2 for him + 2 for her" is using the distributive property of multiplication. The sentence "2 for him and 2 for her and 2 for him and 2 for him and 2 for her" is unnatural and not the way people generally think (unless they're just tallying up but then we're not even talking about multiplication anymore, a tally rarely consists of all equal numbers)