15 ms·
He has been punished for his wrong doing, which had nothing to do with DNS. The least ICANN could do it tell Sunde exactly what they are affaird he’ll do to mis
by mrweasel 6y ago
He has been punished for his wrong doing, which had nothing to do with DNS. The least ICANN could do it tell Sunde exactly what they are affaird he’ll do to misuse an accreditation. Some one with an accreditation sold Sunde and team piratebay.org, so they can’t be worried that he’ll register a ton of pirate domains, he can easily get those elsewhere.
People shouldn’t be punished for life, especially not by excluding them from areas that are completely unrelated.
- nabla9 6y ago> People shouldn’t be punished for life, You don't want to allow convicted people operate domain registrars. You don't want to give banking license to a convicted felon. It's very common practice to deny convicted people access to positions that require some amount of trust for the rest of their life.
- hvdijk 6y agoIn the country I grew up in, the Netherlands, not only is that not common practice, it cannot happen at all. What we have is people can ask the Ministry of Justice for a "Verklaring Omtrent het Gedrag (VOG)", a declaration by the ministerial department that there are no relevant convictions that would get in the way of the job or role they are applying for. If you have no convictions, you get your VOG. If you have convictions but they are not relevant to the job or role you are applying for, you get the exact same VOG that you would if you have no convictions, so that there is no way for employers to know the difference. Your employer is not allowed to ask you directly about a criminal history (at least not in a job interview), they are only allowed to ask for a VOG. Yes, that means you can get a banking license with a criminal history, if the Ministry has decided that that criminal history is irrelevant. With a conviction for fraud, you won't get that license. With a conviction for assault, you might. That seems like a much fairer system to me and I wish more countries would adopt it.
- duckfang 6y agoI think the system in the Netherlands uses a lot more secrecy surrounding the courts systems. In those cases, secrecy is default.. SO having a bureaucratic branch dedicated to determining relevant convictions makes sense. In the USA, came from the UK which was known (in the 1700's) for having secret trials, secret evidence, secret witnesses, and secret punishments. So the founders built this system to be transparent in many ways. And that meant public recording of crimes. Fast forward a few hundred years, and this computing thing takes off, and records everywhere are put in a system and easily searchable. Having the secret system in place in the Netherlands and the transparent/easily searchable system in the USA don't really mix all to well. (Admittedly, much of the courts systems are still opaque as mud, but some important parts are constitutional - like seeing/questioning witnesses, jury of your peers, etc)
- crumbshot 6y agoThough in this case the transparency is one-sided: ICANN can gather all manner of information on Sunde, but Sunde is denied any detailed explanation from ICANN on exactly why his application was denied. Just this rather opaque reason of them being "not comfortable" with him operating a domain registrar.
- hvdijk 6y agoNote that there is no secrecy during court proceedings in the Netherlands: court proceedings are ordinarily open to the public. There are exceptions for family affairs (such as divorces), tax affairs, and criminal cases against minors, but otherwise you are free to watch a court proceeding if you like. Source, in Dutch: https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/rechtspraak-en-geschiloplossing/vraag-en-antwoord/kan-ik-een-zitting-van-de-rechtbank-bijwonen https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/rechtspraak-en-gesc... The only secrecy is after court proceedings, and even then, only as far as for the identities of the people are involved: court rulings are regularly published online at https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/ https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/, easily searchable, with just the names of people and identifying information redacted.
- chokeartist 6y ago
- consp 6y agoIn addition to that, most criminal convictions have a limitation on how long they count towards your VOG. In most cases they look back 4 years, 2 for younger people (till 23) There are exceptions like in transport (taxi/truck) and high integrity functions like lawyers and interpreters (10 years) and people convicted of sex offences (10 years or longer depending on the function).
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> In most cases they look back 4 years, 2 for younger people (till 23) So if you're 22, the crime you committed when you were 19 won't count against you, but when you turn 23, it starts counting again?
- fckthisguy 6y agoSpot the QA!
- sellyme 6y agoThere's a similar bug with the age of consent laws where I live. General gist of things is that the age of consent is 17, however if both participants are under 17 and the age gap is small (typically less than 1 year), there's an exception clause (I believe this is known as a "Romeo & Juliet" clause). This leads to the odd scenario where someone born 16y364d ago can get it on with someone born 16y363d ago, then the very next day it becomes illegal, and the day after that it becomes legal again.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoI'm reminded of the way health concerns are handled for pilots. As I understand it, you get your medical from an authorized doctor, and that certifies that in health terms you're fit for the job. Different roles require different levels of medical certificate. With that done, your employer has no business prying further regarding your health.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>people can ask the Ministry of Justice for... And what kind of results do they get? (I'm genuinely asking) Any time I hear about a "you can apply for X" series of bureaucratic hoops one can jump though I can't help but wonder if it's like getting a building permit in SF or a handgun license in NYC where only the people who've made the right donations to the right people can get what they want and everyone else gets the bureaucratic run around.
- Vinnl 6y agoAs I remember it you submit a web form, pay 25 euro, then it's sent to you or your employer. Either way everyone can get one, no special hoops or donations required.
- mcguire 6y agoHow does the Ministry of Justice go about deciding whether a conviction is relevant to the job or not? Is that process transparent?
- hvdijk 6y agoThere's a lot of information on that at https://www.justis.nl/producten/vog/beoordeling-besluit-en-bezwaar/index.aspx https://www.justis.nl/producten/vog/beoordeling-besluit-en-b..., too much to summarise here, but I'll just mention what it says at the end: if you aren't given your VOG when you believe you should be, it's possible to ask for that decision to be reviewed. If upon review you still aren't given your VOG, you can appeal that decision by taking it to court and having a judge look at it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 3np 6y agoI'm not sure if you're aware, but this is a very US thing. In Europe it's not even uncommon with laws against discriminating on these grounds as well. An entity as ICANN should not necessarily be based on US norms.
- wott 6y ago> I'm not sure if you're aware, but this is a very US thing. In Europe it's not even uncommon with laws against discriminating on these grounds as well. As (almost) always when "Europe" comes up in the comments of this site to oppose it with the USA: *Europe is not a thing* (as in: it is not an homogenous thing at all, it covers many different countries with many different situations, laws and everything). At least in France, quite many jobs require a criminal record to be presented, to check that you were not sentenced for a crime/offence deemed incompatible with the specific position. It is less invasive, and less public than in the USA, but it pretty well exists and is perfectly legal.
- 3np 6y agoThat conflation is another of my pet peeves, so thanks for clarifying.
- sellyme 6y ago> to check that you were not sentenced for a crime/offence deemed incompatible with the specific position. But we're talking about a crime that is not incompatible with the specific position.
- annazinonos 6y agoFor security related jobs you need a clean criminal record n Greece/Cyprus but if you ask my opinion a criminal knows how criminals work and think so it would be an asset to have a criminal working (with devotion, not trolling) for a security company.
- Voloskaya 6y ago> You don't want to allow [...] Yes I do. A Judge decided what was a fair punishment for the offense. They sat through an entire trial and made a decision about what was an appropriate sentencing. Once that appropriate sentence has been serve there should be no further punishment. If the Judge decides the felon should never be able to work in banking they can, in most countries, make that happen. What's the point of having a judicial system if everyone is going to take the matter in their own hands anyway?
- mordae 6y agoIn Czechia, you can ask the court to erase your criminal record. They usually comply after the same amount of years that was your original sentence. Meaning that after spending 3 years in prison, the criminal record stays with you further 3 years and after that if there is no reason to keep it and you ask for it, it gets erased. Well, erased is not really exact. It won't be accessible by anyone and you will have the right to be treated as if you were never convicted. So, Peter's original sentence was like 8 months? After so many years I believe nobody should hold his TPB involvement against him anymore.
- norenh 6y agoIn Sweden they are removed from the public records (belastningsregistret) based on various criteria. A completed prison sentence would normally be removed 10 years after the sentence has been completed. Sources (in Swedish): https://lagen.nu/1998:620#P17 https://lagen.nu/1998:620#P17 https://polisen.se/tjanster-tillstand/belastningsregistret/gallringsregler/ https://polisen.se/tjanster-tillstand/belastningsregistret/g...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoPerhaps we can make this a little easier and more obvious for people? How about when you’re convicted of an offense you have to wear a letter on your chest representing that offense? The shame and additional punishment should go on indefinitely long after the actual punishment has ended, right?
- klibertp 6y ago> It's very common practice In certain parts of the world. Meanwhile, the rest of the world doesn't try to ruin the whole lives of people who made a mistake and already paid for it by serving their time in prison (or whatever the court ruled). I find the idea that a single crime you commited makes you somehow less of a human being incredibly backwards and brutal. Plus, it seems to be not very effective. From what I read there are complex socio-economic reasons for the system to be shaped that way, but from an outsider perspective - so without caring about said reasons - it looks absolutely crazy.
- LocalH 6y agoYour mindset is part of the problem. Please look outside your box.
- andrewzah 6y agoSo serving a prison sentence is not enough in this case? If someone is convicted of things like pirating, we should punish them permanently in random domains for the rest of their life? Gee, I wonder why recidivism rates are so high...
- varajelle 6y agoThat's right. Having a criminal record will make it more difficult to get a visa, get certain types of jobs, get Security clearance, and other things. That might not be fair, but that's how it is.
- andrewzah 6y agoWhat is the point of the legal system if everyone is just going to apply extra-legal, -arbitrary- punishments on top of it? Firstly, this ignores the fact that most crime occurs due to socioeconomic reasons. So you're kicking someone in the head after they're already down and have served a punishment doled out by a judge. Secondly, obviously the -type- of crime should make things more difficult or impossible in certain cases. But arbitrarily punishing people for having any conviction at all is the opposite of what a healthy society should be doing. This thoroughly ensures that recidivism rates will remain high, because what's the point in trying to cooperate with a society that brands you as a criminal no matter what punishment you serve or what you do throughout the rest of your life? We need to focus on rehabilitation, not continuing to punish people for the rest of their lives. "That might not be fair, but that's how it is." Sorry to be blunt, but hopefully this punitive attitude will die out as older people die out. This is one American attitude that I absolutely despise.
- varajelle 6y agoI agree with you 100%. But depending on the country in which you live, the hard reality is (unfortunately) unfair.
- ByteJockey 6y ago> What is the point of the legal system if everyone is just going to apply extra-legal, -arbitrary- punishments on top of it? To control the application of violence and to make sure the preexisting rules are being followed before it is applied. If you don't have any verification that the rules are being followed, those in power tend to do pretty horrible things. At the same time, if those in power use no violence, the populace tend to resort to extra-legal violence to deliver what they see as justice, which results in a different class or horrible things happening (and threatens the government's monopoly on legitimized violence). It's basically a local maximum that still kind of sucks, but works better than anything else we've tried at scale. We've tried getting the government involved in social punishment, but it tends to work out very poorly and it seems best just to have them not enter that sphere. > what's the point in trying to cooperate with a society that brands you as a criminal no matter Potentially nothing, but that's a question for society, not for the government/legal system. Society is supposed to control the government, not the other way around (or at least that's the theory, practice is sometimes pretty spotty). It should also be noted that there's no requirement for people to add these extra punishments. So, it should be pretty easy to turn around if people ever pull their heads out of their asses.
- jrockway 6y agoYou say "you" but I have no particular complaints about letting someone who ran a Bittorrent tracker run a DNS registry. They committed a thought crime, not a murder. If their DNS registry is mismanaged, I can easily take my business elsewhere. What's next, you can't get a job because you got a parking ticket one time? Why would you let someone who can't read parking signs write software, after all? I'd prefer to get some data on what the risk is here. Among criminals, how many commit their second crime while running a DNS registry? If we don't know, I am not sure it's rational to give someone a life sentence in that domain. It's just punitive, not intelligent risk management.
- kelnos 6y ago> You don't want to give banking license to a convicted felon. Why not? "Convicted felon" encompasses a lot. Being convicted of felony drug possession when you were 19, for example, has very little to do with one's ability or trustworthiness to run a bank. Sure, maybe we don't give banking licenses to people who have committed financial crimes (though a lot of corrupt investment bank executives seem to have no problem doing business), but that's not the same thing. This idea that committing a crime should lock people out of many life activities is one of the things that leads them to committing more crimes. The punishment was a fine or jail time; let's stop punishing people for the rest of their lives.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoThis was also the ACB take on Second Amendment rights which you may remember from recent confirmation hearings: yes, we can let felons have guns, because a felony "includes everything from Kanter's offense, mail fraud, to selling pigs without a license in Massachusetts, redeeming large quantities of out-of-state bottle deposits in Michigan, and countless other state and federal offenses." Thus it's very poorly related to the risk levels involved. (DC vs Heller.) Overreliance on the category "felon" also shows up in a recent Gorsuch take on the Fourth Amendment: "We live in a world in which everything has been criminalized. And some professors have even opined that there's not an American alive who hasn't committed a felony in some—under some state law. And in a world like that, why doesn't it make sense to retreat back to the original meaning of the Fourth Amendment, which I'm going to oversimplify, but generally says that you get to go into a home without a warrant if the officer sees a violent action or something that's likely to lead to imminent violence… Why isn't that the right approach? (Lange v. California)
- kelnos 6y agoYep, if a felony wasn't violent, or perhaps not even gun-related, I don't see why felons shouldn't be able to own guns. (I mean, I'm generally against the level of private gun ownership we have in the US, but given 2A, it seems like a violation to deny anyone their constitutional rights based on a broad label like "felon".)
- inopinatus 6y agoIt’s also very common to misuse criminal justice systems to control dissidents, ethnic groups, women etc. A strategy beloved of bigots and reactionaries, authoritarians and totalitarians, from Mississippi to Moscow. Which is why this notion stinks.
- fckthisguy 6y agoIt's very uncommon in many parts of the world. In countries that aim to reform and educate criminals during their time behind bars, not giving them opportunities when they get out seems illogical.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoAh, right, ICANN is run by IP lawyers, the pirate bay is not relevant to DNS, but is relevant to those IP lawyers, that's why they don't like him: https://nitter.dark.fail/i/status/1366522131811627009 https://nitter.dark.fail/i/status/1366522131811627009 Also https://njal.la/blog/we-dont-have-enemies/ https://njal.la/blog/we-dont-have-enemies/ - another reason to dislike him.
- fckthisguy 6y agoWhat's not to like here? That blog post outlines how they're fighting for fair representation in the copyright dispute process.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoMPAA doesn't like that their requests are denied.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]