9 ms·
China's scheme to transfer Uighurs into work
- azalemeth 6y agoI somehow fear I will be downvoted for this, but the article highlights how it's very easy for these goods to end up in our supply chains without our knowledge: >The Huafu Textile Company is located on the edge of a grey industrial estate in the city of Huaibei, in China's eastern province of Anhui. > It was to this factory that Buzaynap, featured in the state-TV report, was sent > [...my own rather selective cut...] > Amazon told the BBC that it does not tolerate the use of forced labour and that where it finds products that do not meet its supply chain standards, it removes them from sale. I for one wish it were easier to not buy products from China as a whole. With some things -- food, for example -- it's very easy. With others -- electronics or consumer goods -- it is almost literally impossible. It's quite apparent that they've engaged in an ideologically driven purge of the Uighur culture (much like a concomitant "reforming" of Hong Kong's) -- there's just too much independent evidence to suppress that hypothesis. If the coronavirus pandemic has shown us anything, it's that we need to be able to be a bit more self-sufficient and (for all nations!) having a national manufacturing base able to make certain goods is a sensible idea. I know that economics ultimately stopped the Soviet state machine from rolling over the civil rights of its populace to quite the extent that it once did; I don't know what that tells us here.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoIt did not stop Stalin and his Red Terror.
- mhh__ 6y agoYou'd need to speak to a proper historian, but in my reading of sources about it it seems we already have a much better understanding of what the Chinese are doing than contemporaries of the Terror did.
- burlesona 6y agoBut it did eventually lead to the break up of the USSR - without WW3 - rather than the Soviets taking over the world.
- XorNot 6y agoThe Soviets were never in a position to overtake the world, and the idea that they were was a US misreading of the spread of communism and the influence of Soviet agitators - who showed up everywhere - as though they weren't doing exactly the same things the CIA were. The Vietnam war, for instance, was prosecuted entirely on the faulty assumption that a communist Vietnam was just going to become a subsumed extension of the Chinese government, rather then what actually happened, which was it became communist Vietnam and continued to vigorously oppose Chinese influence, as well as ultimately becoming fairly integral to the eventual downfall of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia after the war. The "domino effect" was American institutional panic that was encouraged because it led to policy decisions with favorable, easy domestic political consequences and huge handouts to business interests.
- DSingularity 6y agoJust an innocent “misreading”?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- HenryBemis 6y agoMy thoughts. China will sell. Perhaps not in USA, Edit: EU (not UA), Japan, etc. But how about India, Pakistan, all African countries, all Arab countries? They play the loooooooong game, and they are winning it. I believe that Russia's (and Russians) ideology is closed to Europe & USA's, while China is a full-on dictatorship.
- da_big_ghey 6y agoWe need a "No China" label for goods with a certifying body, just like organic, kosher, etc.
- edbob 6y ago"No Slave Labor" would be better, as China is not the only country with those particular "cultural differences".
- echelon 6y agoHow can we make sure the products we're buying are Uighur labor free? I don't want to contribute to this.
- bravo22 6y agoIf you're serious about it then assume you can't be sure and plan your purchases around that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- npteljes 6y agoI don't think you can make _sure_, so an alternative could be to donate to human rights charities.
- refenestrator 6y agoThere's no reference to forced labor anywhere in the article. It's just typical Chinese migrant labor, going from absolute 3rd world subsistence farming to a crappy, dangerous tenement factory job because that's actually an improvement. So I'm not sure boycotting their work product is necessarily the right moral call here, even if it were possible.
- edbob 6y agoLet's just ignore the copious evidence of rape, false imprisonment, enslavement, organ harvesting, mass sterilization, forcing young girls to live with abusive Han families, etc. because this one single article doesn't directly reference forced labor.
- refenestrator 6y agoI see you're acquainted with the gish gallop.
- edbob 6y ago
- refenestrator 6y ago> China's policy of transferring hundreds of thousands of Uighurs and other ethnic minorities in Xinjiang to new jobs often far from home is leading to a thinning out of their populations, according to a high-level Chinese study seen by the BBC. Funny story, this has been going on for decades as a pro-Uighur economic development campaign. Lots of migrant labor in China in general, and it's not always easy to get permission to move to where the jobs are under the hukou system. It's actually a great economic opportunity. Notice that there's no actual reference to anyone being forced to do anything. They just imply it by working in statements that are against the general concept of forced labor.
- nomdep 6y agoWe can start fighting this by purging the pro-chinese ring here in HN that downvote any comment critical to China. If beign pro-Hitler isn't allowed, why beign pro-China is?
- christophilus 6y agoChina really is more like fascism than Marxism in my opinion. I occasionally follow some communists on Twitter, and they are surprisingly pro-China even though China is a far cry from their Marxist ideals.
- fallingfrog 6y agoIt really is. I was just recently reading that the Chinese government is actually having a big problem with young people taking communism seriously and starting to ask questions about the massive sweatshops and inequality in the country, which are not things that are supposed to happen with the communist party in charge.
- gbfnbkbddf 6y agoCommunism in practice is just fascism with a Marxish State-enforced ideology
- throwaway894345 6y agoIt’s very interesting to me how often communism ends up looking like fascism, and yet many people are very open and tolerant of the former while absolutely petrified of the latter. Violent authoritarians concern me in general, and I take little comfort in them being left-wing, rather than right-wing, authoritarians. EDIT: Lots of downvotes and no rebuttals. Looks like I inadvertently struck a nerve.
- kggbcsehn 6y agoCommunism is cloaked in false promises and the US has failed to teach the youth this, so they are attracted to the lies that sell the ideology. You can also thank Bernie Sanders and AOC for repairing the brand of socialism with their incredibly harmful rhetoric
- sonicggg 6y agoChina is not innocent by any means, but I sense some hypocrisy from those that arrogantly think they have a higher moral ground here. Pretty much every country has their own "Trail of Tears", even the progressive and almighty Canada only closed their oppressive Indian Residence school systems recently. Are we supposed to boycott everyone then, and go back to hunting and gathering?
- throwaway894345 6y agoSurely you can appreciate the distinction between countries that stopped their ethnic campaigns and those that persist, right?
- cardy31 6y agoThis is such a bad take. Just because something bad happened in a countries history doesn’t mean it excludes them from speaking up about human rights atrocities for the remainder of their existence.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- christophilus 6y agoThis is a tired argument. It’s not hypocritical or unreasonable to expect better behavior out of governments around the world. And certainly in the case of China, it’s an old enough civilization that we should be able to expect its barbaric Trail of Tears days to be long past.
- powerapple 6y agoWhy 'China is not innocent'? Yes, China is not Europe, and it is not US. So is its per capital GDP. so is its business. so is it brands. so is its industry. I wouldn't trust BBC at all on these reports. Journalists could use facts but they choose to lie again and again. At the same time, the British government is playing their game. Coincidence?
- xiaolingxiao 6y ago> The Huafu Textile Company is located on the edge of a grey industrial estate in the city of Huaibei, in China's eastern province of Anhui. I more or less grew up in the states, but this is the exact town I was born in, and grey couldn't be a better description for it. It was a mining town when I was little, and I recall trainloads of coal being taken out of tunnels in the mountains, very West Virginia feel to it.
- throw373782 6y ago> “Dr Adrian Zenz, a senior fellow at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation in Washington” Adrian Zenz again. Every. Time. https://thegrayzone.com/2021/02/18/us-media-reports-chinese-genocide-relied-on-fraudulent-far-right-researcher/ https://thegrayzone.com/2021/02/18/us-media-reports-chinese-...
- Udik 6y ago> "a far-right Christian fundamentalist who has said he is “led by God” against China’s government, deplores homosexuality and gender equality, and has taught exclusively in evangelical theological institutions."
- fallingfrog 6y agoI really feel like we’re not getting objective information from either side right now. We shouldn’t have people quoting idealogues like Zenz, or taking the government’s word on things either.
- ncann 6y agoEvery single negative BBC articles about China these days reference him, it's actually rather funny considering his track record and background. I don't know why they treat him as some sort of authoritative source about China when he can't even read Chinese and has never been to China.
- fallingfrog 6y agoIs this article one of those super contentious things where people just downvote every comment even if you’re just saying innocuous things like “I wish we had objective facts”? Because I want objective facts, and the truth, in every situation including this one, is that really such a controversial take? What is going on here? Edit: yep, it’s a flame war with crazy idealogues on both sides saying things that don’t really belong on HN, I flagged it, everyone else should too. Edit 2: I learned a valuable lesson today: don’t participate in a conversation where flamewars are happening, even if you are trying to advocate some reasonable middle ground. You’re just giving oxygen to the crazies. Flag and move on. Thank you everyone for helping me learn this.
- La1n 6y ago>What is going on here? An article that is basically flamebait for nationalistic flamewars and doesn't belong on HN.
- ncann 6y agoEvery single discussion thread on this topic inevitably turns into a flame war.
- edbob 6y agoWhat specifically about this BBC report do you feel is not substantiated enough? You did not get downvoted for calling for moderation, but for making unsupported assertions that contradict the available evidence. You complained about the quoting of Zenz. Perhaps you are one of those who feel that his Christian faith disqualifies him, or perhaps it's something else. In any case, the BBC does not consider him disqualified, but they also performed many investigations of their own and have corroborated the reports of many people who are not named Zenz. The BBC has provided abundant evidence. They are widely considered to be a reliable source. If you think the BBC is lying, then say so. Otherwise, it seems like you are just throwing stones. The only way I can see your position making sense and seeming moderate to you is if you take the CCP's official propaganda as of equal weight with the BBC's reports. This seems absurd to me, but I will grant that you can choose to take this view and I do think that you make your arguments in good faith. Edit: It appears that you got downvoted for calling the ongoing genocide "soft cultural erasure". It would have been okay if you've said "cultural erasure", but the "soft" part is just wrong. There's nothing soft about concentration camps and rape.
- hnnn 6y agoDisclosure: I am a Chinese (Han) and live in China for 40 years. > A 2017 TV report from China's state broadcaster illustrates how the policy works in practice This report's major source comes from a video broadcasted by CCTV (China's stated own central TV broadcaster), which means this video could not be a video describing any bad state policy logically. And I feel it is more about how you would like to explain what you see and it is highly subjective. > The video has not featured in international reporting until now CCTV is broadcasted nation wide and it is likely many foreigners living in China watched this as well, and it is very easy to obtain such a video, so no international reporting doesn't mean anything to hide. I don't know exactly what happened there at that time but the article is far from convincing from my point of view.
- yorwba 6y agoHi, I see that this is your first comment here on HN, so let me warmly welcome you to the community. > This report's major source comes from a video broadcasted by CCTV Actually, they have a second, likely much more informative source, namely this government report: https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161938/https://ciwe.nankai.edu.cn/2019/1223/c18571a259225/page.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161938/https://ciwe.nank... They say it was intended for senior officials and accidentally posted online, which makes it sound exciting, but it looks to be full of dry descriptions and government slogans, so I wouldn't blame you for not reading it. (Personally, I added it to the pile of stuff to read later.) > which means this video could not be a video describing any bad state policy logically. And I feel it is more about how you would like to explain what you see and it is highly subjective. It only means that whoever was responsible for approving the video at CCTV didn't think it showed a bad policy. And as you say, that is a highly subjective assessment. It's not surprising that someone at the BBC might see things differently. Even when there's agreement over which outcomes are good and bad, most policies have multiple effects, and depending on how important someone thinks each effect is, they'll come to a different conclusion on the overall impact of the policy. For example: - the goal of poverty alleviation is something that both BBC and CCTV can probably agree is a good thing - the goal of assimilation is something the BBC is going to see much more critically as a loss of culture, partially as a result of backlash to Britain's own history of assimilationist policies, which led to the extinction of languages like Cornish and Manx, not to mention the colonies. - the article describes Uighurs being separated from their Han colleagues, which both contradicts the goal of assimilation and unlikely to find the BBC's approval anyway, because segregation is frowned upon as well. - ...but they might change their mind on that if they learn it's to ensure they can eat halal food. On the other hand, they'll never swallow the idea of assigning which food someone gets to eat based on their ethnicity, rather than offering multiple options and letting them choose. - pressurizing people who don't voluntarily sign up for the labor transfer program is something both BBC and CCTV would see critically, but I feel like CCTV would put the blame on the people who don't know what's good for themselves and don't sign up enthusiastically, while the BBC sees it as a sign that the policy really is bad and needs to be improved until people are willing to participate, otherwise forcing them is another point against it. > CCTV is broadcasted nation wide and it is likely many foreigners living in China watched this as well Did you watch it when it was broadcast back then? If not, you might be overestimating the audience it got. I doubt there are very many foreigners constantly watching CCTV. When I was in China, the only time I watched actual TV instead of video-on-demand was when I wanted to learn some of the local dialect, so I tuned into a local TV station. (That didn't really work, because the Mandarin subtitles frequently only loosely matched what was being said, so I barely learned a handful of words.) > it is very easy to obtain such a video, so no international reporting doesn't mean anything to hide. I don't think they're trying to imply that this was somehow hidden, but I think they're proud anyway to be the first English-speaking journalists to have paid attention while watching old CCTV recordings. (Okay, most likely they got a tip from someone else, making their job easier.) > I don't know exactly what happened there at that time but the article is far from convincing from my point of view. Well, there are many possible things here to be convinced of or not: That the government is bad, that the government's way of dealing with minorities is bad, that this specific policy is bad, that some aspects of the policy are bad, that this is worth paying attention to at all... Personally I think it's worth paying attention to, because these poverty alleviation and labor transfer programs aren't limited to Uighurs but target the rural poor more generally, which is testimony to China's reliance on the supply of cheap migrant labor to maintain growth. If those migrants feel coerced, exploited or even just treated like outsiders without hukou, who knows how they'll show their anger? Finally, if you don't mind me asking: how did you find this article? Was it linked on another site or have you been reading HN for a while and simply didn't have a reason to make an account until now?