5 ms·
Although interesting, this is overshadowed by the growing politicisation of the internet. ICANN seems to have a representative multi-government structure that
by roenxi 6y ago
Although interesting, this is overshadowed by the growing politicisation of the internet.
ICANN seems to have a representative multi-government structure that is robust against any particular government having unreasonable influence. If a few Sundes get crushed in the gears so be it.
The US tech giants are beholden to themselves and control a scary fraction of the internet's infrastructure. They are starting to flex their muscles in regard to what should and should not appear on the internet. As far as political threats go, that is where they will materialise. Or in governments copying China's strategy for engaging with technology.
- TrispusAttucks 6y agoJust because some other internet giant is screwing free speech harder doesn't make this any less wrong. Battles can be fought on multiple fronts if necessary. This isn't the first corruption coming from ICANN.
- fredgrott 6y agoit's not FREE SPEECH, it's FREE POLITICAL SPEECH which is in fact an oxymoron as that cannot ever exist in an efficient society even if we want it to
- galangalalgol 6y agoThe US first amendment protects all speech, not just political speech. Most particularly it protects offensive speech because that is the only kind that needs protecting. We endure many inefficiencies for the freedoms we allow, the idea is that those freedoms are worth the cost.
- davrosthedalek 6y agoThe US first amendment protects (almost) all speech, but only from prosecution by the government, not by companies.
- toyg 6y agoYes, and this really highlight the problem with ICANN: it's de-facto (global) government, except legally it isn't.
- galangalalgol 6y agoIndeed, if the drafters had forseen corporatism many things might have been different. And then there is the organized persecution of peers for their horribly offensive (read differing) opinions that is allowed by our modern communication tools. Is freedom of speech freedom to persecute? Maybe having really bad ideas should become a protected class? I say that only half jokingly, I have no answers.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe drafters didn't foresee protected classes (in the legal sense you're using the term, if I understand correctly); in fact, several of those protected classes simply weren't granted the rights granted to white male landowners by the Constitution the drafters framed. I don't know how much guidance we can take from the original drafters on the novel problems of the modern era.
- davrosthedalek 6y agoGood question. And there is also the freedom of (dis)association.
- FpUser 6y agoWell some companies are starting to look more and more like the government. Besides corporations are protected by the government from certain things. The populace should be protected from their actions as well. Existence of big corporation always affects life of many people so it is only fair that those corps should be restricted in what their can do. For one thing those corps main duty is to make money. If they engage in morality setting instead they should have their business license revoked.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoSo we don't have rights, but privileges.
- worldofmatthew 6y agoCorruption from ICANN is 100x worse than big tech. ICANN can just tell DNS servers not to route anything to do with you and threaten others to do the same.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agocough Is this the same ICANT that we all know and love :-)
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoSorry forgot the <sarcasm> tag
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoWhy do you believe ICANN’s multi-government structure is somehow robust against any one government or small consortium of governments having too much power?
- narag 6y agoThe strategy is different, and clear though. First monopolize contents, then censor. It seemed impossible to do in the web when it bloomed. Compared with tv, it was a difficult beast to tame. But free resources, convenience and having all your contacts captive work as a charm.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]