5 ms·
Coinbase Is a $100B Crypto Cult
- jgalt212 6y agoThe money the Fed printed has to go somewhere.
- devoutsalsa 6y agoI keep thinking that, too.
- jMyles 6y agoI'm interested in this take, as I'm hearing it a lot lately and it seems quite plausible. Is there evidence that the price increase of bitcoin is causally related, in any reliable way, to inflationary activity at The Fed? If so, why isn't this the headline of the past month?
- adflux 6y agoBasic economics, btc is denominated in $, if the dollar becomes worth less (increased supply), you will need more $ per coin. But that doesnt explain the 10, 20x of bitcoin by itself.
- grumple 6y agoThe biggest problem with the way we list the last price of assets is that the price listed is only the price of one unit. In reality, if all bitcoins were sold, the money recouped would be considerably less than last price * num coins. Perhaps this is already a solved problem via some metrics that I'm not familiar with. Because we only use last price to evaluate assets, small changes in demand and last price can have considerable effects on overall valuations, even though (I think) the total value of the asset is not much different. A simple example of the idea is this: I have 100 ecoins and I want to sell them. They are the only ecoins in the world. I sell the first for 100; the next, I have fewer buyers, so I settle for 99... etc all the way to 1 for the last. The initial valuation, based on last price, would have been 100*100 = 10,000. The actual cash recouped was 5,050. Obviously volume has an impact, and in reality prices are generally more stable and the whole process is much more complicated but you get the idea. But if bitcoin / gme / tesla have taught us anything, it's that price can remain irrationally high indefinitely because of the way wealth and money can be moved around and there's no urgency to use it (due to lack of taxation). Artificial inflation/manipulation of assets seems like a great argument for wealth taxation. It would discourage tying up liquidity in bad assets and encourage better investment.
- UncleMeat 6y agoIf this argument made sense then we’d see other currencies exploding too. The 10x growth is the thing to be explained, not modest growth due to devaluing the dollar.
- snicksnak 6y agoi believe the comment was an reference to coinbase $100B valuation, most of the money printed ends up in the stock market, because institutions can't do anything else with it which pumps up the prices. Global economy is tanking, stock market is up.
- wtf_is_up 6y agoStock market is forward looking. It priced in vaccines last spring. Now it is pricing in a complete economic rebound and return to normal this year. Look at commodities, yield curve steepening, flight to airlines, cruise lines, etc and away from WFH tech that got overbought post-Covid.
- ramblerman 6y agoWell I guess it's forward looking ... until it isn't.
- wtf_is_up 6y agoRight. It's forward looking, based on data available and projections. Doesn't mean it's always correct.
- wtf_is_up 6y agoIt's a theory for why many non-CPI assets are inflating in price and it has been discussed ad nauseum since March. One group (including the Fed) points at CPI and PCE and says there is no inflation, in fact they want some inflation but can't get it. The other group says there is inflation but it is 'asset inflation' causing things like real estate, healthcare, education, trading cards, classic cars, crypto, etc to sky rocket. And then you have gold bugs and contrarians like Mike Burry talking about Weimar 2.0 hyperinflation coming. You have to go to St Louis FRED data and decide for yourself. Look at M1 and M2 supply, velocity etc. Commodities have been on a tear for 6 months after a 12 year bear run. That could just be supply shock for a quickly recovering economy. And now we have an incoming 1.9T stimulus, with a lot of it going directly to consumers instead of sitting on bank balance sheets like QE. Who knows?
- 3np 6y agoI'm convinced this is part of what's driving corporates allocating parts of their treasury in BTC, as brought into mainstream consciousness by Microstrategy/Saylor and Tesla/Musk. They have certainly brought this into the consciousness of CEOs, CFOs and board as "something you can do". Debt is cheap, there is a growing concern on the ability of the USD (and others for that matter) to retain its long-term value and BTC can be used as collateral for fiat loans to gain liquidity while still being exposed to BTC. In case anyone missed it: https://www.microstrategy.com/en/resources/events/world-2021/bitcoin-summit https://www.microstrategy.com/en/resources/events/world-2021...
- retube 6y agoHave a Google on this. Its broadly accepted that stimulus measures are driving the inflation we've seen in risk asset prices over the last 12 months. This extends to retail as well. E.g there was even some research on RobinHood which showed a sharp uptick in trading the day after the stimulus checks landed.
- mberning 6y agoAnd they are likely to keep printing it. And interest rates are stupid low. If you are already in the stock market there is not really anywhere else to go with your money if you want big growth. To me it makes sense to have at least some of your investments in crpyo. Especially if you are young.
- erwinh 6y agoSo basically coinbase needs competitors on transaction fee prices
- Tenoke 6y agoIt has a competitor, it's just sadly afraid of being in the US so it pulled out most of its offerings from there recently. Only Coinbase gets the preferential treatment. Binance has 9x the volume of Coinbase, 5-10 times less fees, much more offerings and its 'stock' is at least an actual cryptocurrency rather than a US IPO. >I was wrong, spending about $1,200 on those trades at a commission rate of 1.49%. Anyway, the author could've had 0.50% fees even on Coinbase (still 5x higher than the lowest Binance fees) by switching to Pro which is free. The author for some reason thinks "it wasn't worth the effort". Well, if you don't want to spend the 10 minutes to use the market rather than the 1click solution, I dont see how its the exchange's fault.
- bradstewart 6y agoYea I really don't understand this. Coinbase makes it extremely easy to setup Pro and transfer/share funds from your non-Pro accounts.
- ur-whale 6y ago>It has a competitor, it's just sadly afraid of being in the US Protectionism at its finest.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rglullis 6y agoIt has. One of them is called Coinbase Pro.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoThis article is all over the place. It takes an obviously negative stance right from the start by complaining that Coinbase has frequent outages and poor customer support (that hasn’t been my experience as a long time happy Coinbase customer), then it switches completely to the author complaining about how they didn’t research the fees, and got surprised by high fees that earnestly reflect the cost of operating the business. This is somehow better than the way brokerages fund zero fee retail investing transactions, but also somehow vaguely dishonest and predatory at the same time? It’s a very weak, meandering article with no significant point. I usually expect better from Bloomberg on financial topics, but I guess it’s just the usual trendy anti-cryptocurrency drivel.
- the-dude 6y agoMaybe. But Bloomberg is not to be trusted anymore ( The Phony Hack ), especially on subjects which may partially compete with its own core business.
- dls2016 6y agoyou dont think coinbase can be a cult and a mafia? https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-27/coinbase-mafia-shows-how-tight-a-circle-holds-sway-over-bitcoin https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-27/coinbase-...
- mschuster91 6y ago> Bitcoin is an investment cult, but at some point you have to leave the cult, making you an apostate. Bitcoin is more than a cult, for what it's worth. Bitcoin has value for rich Chinese to circumvent yuan capital export restrictions (https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3098981/cryptocurrencies-help-chinese-evade-capital-and-currency https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3098981/c...), for Iran to sort-of bypass international sanctions (https://observers.france24.com/en/middle-east/20210203-in-iran-power-outages-reveal-the-secret-business-of-chinese-bitcoin-farms https://observers.france24.com/en/middle-east/20210203-in-ir...) and for North Korea to fund their nuke program (https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/un-says-north-korea-funded-nuclear-weapons-with-crypto-hacks-in-2020%3A-report-2021-02-09 https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/un-says-north-korea-funded-n...). In addition to that, it is a perfect tool for Western people to buy drugs, weapons and other contraband (Silk Road and its countless successors), for sending large sums of money across borders, and soon-ish to buy Tesla cars. Basically, there are many people and governments with massive stakes in keeping Bitcoin operable and its dollar value somewhat high-ish.
- Tenoke 6y ago>In addition to that, it is a perfect tool for Western people to buy drugs, weapons and other contraband (Silk Road and its countless successors), for sending large sums of money across borders, and soon-ish to buy Tesla cars. Cryptocurrencies are. Bitcoin is outclassed by e.g. Monero in that niche and sadly, the constant international busts of DNMs have made buying drugs online an ordeal with markets having very short lifespans currently.
- asah 6y agoAlso, bitcoin is highly traceable by law enforcement, e.g. chainalysis
- ccsnags 6y agoI use cash dollars to buy drugs. There is a massive push to keep dollars operable. Dollars must be a cult.
- pferdone 6y agoIf Bitcoin showed one thing, it's that we can have a way to transact ownership of bytes from one address/wallet to another with a shared network without intermediaries and implicit trust of parties. IMHO it's a very big PoC and the number of people participating over the years makes it a success to me.
- bujak300 6y agoAlso, it's an ecological disaster
- __alexs 6y agoBut at least it's an interesting ecological disaster!
- fallat 6y agoPeople say Bitcoin, but really they mean the success of cryptocurrency. There are more mechanisms than just proof of work.
- LittlePeter 6y agoIf by more you mean one then I agree: proof of work and proof of stake. The other ones are too fringe.
- trident5000 6y agoMuch energy usage would be an "ecological disaster" if you categorized it as unnecessary, which most things are. Do you REALLY need AC? Do you really need to watch dumb rendered internet videos?
- darkcha0s 6y agoAC has a real world use of cooling down a house; Bitcoin doesn't. That is a horrible comparison. TikTok or Youtube videos might be more akin, but even then people are creating content which others are willing to consume. BTC is literally just a transfer of value, which could be done with much less power spent.
- bhouston 6y agoCoinbase’s fees are ridiculously high. By this is a symptom of a lack of competition and immaturity of the cryptocurrency space. The second issue is that cryptocurrency is akin to a religion. This is also true. Most people buy and hold Bitcoin on the belief it will go up but there isn’t much of a reason for it to go up except a lot of people continuing to buy in and hold. As Peter Shiff and others have made clear Bitcoin is a naturally occurring Ponzi scheme.
- mjfl 6y agobut lack of competition is good for an investor :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asah 6y agoYou're looking at retail - their much bigger "wholesale" business has to compete on tighter margins. For example, when Tesla bought $1B via Coinbase, off market. Competitors are showing up fast. New opportunities are opening up in altcoins, staking and more.
- Tenoke 6y agoLack of competition? Outside of the US you get 5+ times lower fees with an exchange with 9x the volume and offerings (Binance). Even in the US you can use e.g. Kraken which has lower fees. This author in particular didn't think it 'was worth the effort' to even use the actual market which offers 0.50% fees on Coinbase and went with the 1click solution that charges 1.49% for the convenience.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI also have an account on Kraken and for a layperson, it's really difficult to find out how much of what I have. For example. I can't get along with its UI. Coinbase however makes things super trivial / easy. It's a convenience fee.
- mavhc 6y ago
- ccsnags 6y agoHaving your company being compared to a cult is a good sign. That’s just good branding.
- 3np 6y agoQue WeWork
- float4 6y agoAren't people getting tired of the asset bubble by now? I understand that in the past year it has enabled people to easily make a lot of money. I personally made a lot of money (relatively speaking that is, as I'm a student) in the past year. But it's just so tiresome to read about it all the time. Asset X goes up, asset Y comes back down. Rinse and repeat. It wears me out. My emotional state of mind is not great at the moment, because of lockdown & loneliness, but I think this long lasting asset bubble would've made me tired regardless of my state of mind. Maybe I'll just do ETFs, maybe I'll just quit for the year. Any people here who feel the same?
- superbcarrot 6y agoPrices are still high so it's safe to say that people aren't tired. It's also hard to determine how much of what's going on is a bubble and how much is just the new normal. There's a lot of money floating around and it has to go somewhere - stocks, crypto, property etc. If you aren't feeling great mentally, it might be good to not get emotionally involved in daytrading, speculation or anything related to crypto. Just park the money in a fund, don't touch it, don't check prices, and make sure that the rest of your life is okay.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoDo you even know what you mean when you say “asset bubble”?
- 3np 6y agoI feel you. I started feeling "can we not have a crazy bull run now please" when it was clear 20k was broken for this cycle. I completely quit trading after the 2017 bubble, though. If I had placed bet on the promising small-caps (defi projects) I worked with through work over the past couple of years, I would have been wealthy now. But I have no regrets, it has allowed me to detach mentally and emotionally from the price swings and I find my mental health worth more than the chance to get dirty rich (or lose it all). I see the prices of a lot of assets I hold during my daily work, but they're just numbers now. I still have significant (to me) crypto holdings, but I take a longer-term perspective now and am fine with the fact that their market price may very well crash to 10% of now during the year. But yeah, the goddamn media. Can we stop talking about price please? It's just so uninteresting.
- cslarson 6y agoIf you are dismissing crypto because you don't like bitcoin or proof of work (mining) then it may worth trying to look past that and reevaluate. Immutable ledgers, namely Ethereum, are transforming finance and that is just the low hanging fruit for this technology.
- regularjack 6y agoCould you elaborate on how Ethereum is transforming finance?
- deweller 6y agoHere's a starting point for more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decentralized_finance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decentralized_finance
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- celticninja 6y agoIsn't Google just a $100b advertising cult?
- wtf_is_up 6y agoNo, it's a $1.4T advertising cult.
- anon112122551 6y agoRight... I was thinking the other day, crypto ain't no solution for everything, so is no gold and fiat is just bad in long-term. The entiry economy is so broken, corrupt and one big scam and only the rich get richer and the poorer get poorer. I'm in crypto since 2015, so with gold and stocks. Made tons of money and yet I still think that the economy is one big scam. I don't trust money, I don't trust gold and neither do I trust crypto, and whilst we can say that these resources are very secure, they can be manipulated with very badly. Crypto would possibly be great, not until the big players got in and now it no longer is money but rather investement thing. (Hold for 5 years get rich!) wtf? Right, I also hold bags, but it has just taken very different approach.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]