4 ms·
The thing about hydrogen as a "transition" fuel is that, while it can be made from carbon-free electricity, doing so is much more expensive than just making it
by pjc50 6y ago
The thing about hydrogen as a "transition" fuel is that, while it can be made from carbon-free electricity, doing so is much more expensive than just making it from natural gas. And when it's made from natural gas, the spare carbon dioxide is nearly always dumped into the atmosphere anyway.
So, for "hydrogen" think "natural gas". Then realise that natural gas is much easier to store, and if you're prepared to "pay" the carbon cost (not a real cost in most places, more of a .. moral cost), you should just use natural gas. And you can already buy LNG/CNG vehicles.
If you want a hydrogen vehicle on zero-carbon hydrogen only, how much is that fuel going to cost you?
- m12k 6y agoWhenever someone says that something is too expensive because it costs X, I can't help but think they have too static a view of the world. Solar was too expensive until it wasn't. Batteries in cars were too big and expensive until they weren't. The status quo of fossil fuels has more than a hundred years of research and infrastructure invested in it to drive prices down. New green tech doesn't. That makes the latter more expensive in many situations right now, sure, but it also means it has potentially many more low-hanging fruits to be picked, where the former has long since hit a plateau with diminishing returns, and is ripe for being overtaken. It doesn't mean all investments in green tech will pay off, but using the current prices as an argument against investing in reducing those prices is absurd.