4 ms·
> Electric batteries are getting better faster Are they? Any sources on that? Besides, the issue with batteries is that you carry dead weight all the time reg
by mrtksn 6y ago
> Electric batteries are getting better faster
Are they? Any sources on that?
Besides, the issue with batteries is that you carry dead weight all the time regardless of how much energy they have stored in and that weight is very high, making the driving experience "not for everyone". I guess, the weight also would mean higher asphalt and tire consumption, which as I read recently is the prime polluter of the driving activity.
I don't know if fuel cells actually have a promising feature or not, but I like seeing people working on alternatives to batteries. Light vehicle propulsion is something to be desired, it opens up possibility for aviation too.
- nickik 6y agoStructural battery, where the battery is part of the structure is actually making the weight very competitive. We are only in the start of how batteries are integrated and eventually all manufactures will move to structural packs. The driving experience is already really good, a heavier feeling is actually prefer by most people.
- mrtksn 6y ago>heavier feeling is actually prefer by most people Any sources on that? Is this coming from a poll or questionnaire or is it your opinion(because Tesla?)? Some people like pineapple on their pizza, others eat marmite at breakfast but the heavy car likers is a first for me.
- pjc50 6y agoPeople keep buying heavier cars and the average weight goes up over time. It's the market version of "preference"; people might say they prefer it but they choose more features most of the time.
- mrtksn 6y agoThis claim also needs sources but even if true Are they buying heavier cars because of the weight or they are accepting a trade off in exchange for more features like larger carrying capacity? Are there instances of people installing ballast to their light cars in order to make them heavier?
- ianai 6y agoThere’s been a long term trend toward bigger vehicles for decades. When gas prices locally went above 3.5-4$/gallon the trend reversed quickly. But it’s since returned. It’s an arms race. It’s hard to feel particularly safe if there are significant fractions of mobile homes barreling down the road toward you. Owning the larger vehicles isn’t fun when you need to park for that matter.
- mrtksn 6y agoI know about that trend in the US but I don't think that it's fuelled by the desire of having heavier cars. Cars getting heavier is a byproduct of cars getting larger. Heavy batteries don't bring that benefit.
- ianai 6y agoThat’s my point. People probably aren’t looking at curb weight directly but they’ve been buying vehicles with characteristics which increase weight.
- WorldMaker 6y agoThough some are looking at curb weight. On the consumer side, it's part of the marketing of vehicles like the Hummer. (On the production side, it's precisely why some vehicles have gone as close to the "commercial truck line" as they can get away with to avoid extra taxes, street restrictions, and license requirements.)
- corty 6y agoCars getting larger and heavier is a byproduct of environmental and safety regulations coupled with the consumers' desire for a constant amount of usable space and payload. More exhaust cleaning and more complex motors cost weight. Sturdier frames are also heavier. Compare e.g. the door thickness of a modern car with one from the 1990s. You can also compare the door's weight. The door will be heavier for the modern car and the thickness will cut away more from the interior space provided (since exterior dimensions are somwhat "fixed" in perception per class of car). Sit in a 1990 era Golf1 and compare to a modern Golf7. The modern version is more cramped on the inside despite being larger on the outside. And it is a good deal heavier. So yes, larger exterior will get you a heavier car, but it isn't really consumers wanting ever larger exterior dimensions. It is consumers wanting a constant interior usable space.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoA heavier car feels more planted in relaxed everyday driving, less affected by NVH, more isolated from road imperfections and wind. The suspension will also be designed for a larger mass, so the added mass of people and freight changes the feel of the car less, as it is a smaller percentage of the car's own mass. A heavy car is objectively worse when looking at handling, fuel economy, road wear, general pollution and crash safety, but greater mass feels safer and sturdier. If an object is very light, it subjectively feels less strong, even though it may not be. Car purchases are very emotionally driven and buyers choose what feels best to them, even if it is objectively worse on many parameters. For a non-car example, I prefer riding my relatively heavy 3-speed Dutch-style bicycle to my old aluminum-framed 8-speed sporty citybike, even though the latter is objectively faster, turns more crisply and has a better gear range. Simply because the heavier bike is less perturbed over bumps and the wider tires soak up imperfections better.
- disiplus 6y ago> heavier feeling is actually prefer by most people. what ? nobody prefers it. there are people that tolerate it and those that don't know better. weight kills driving dynamics, everybody that claims otherwise does not care or did not drive a lightweight car.
- dandellion 6y agoI haven't heard that either, but I have read that the batteries at the bottom give the car a lower center of mass which can be a good thing in curves from my understanding, but that's different from just a "heavier feeling" which I don't see why anyone would prefer that.
- buran77 6y ago> I haven't heard that either Of course because it's absolute nonsense. We spent the last several decades trying to make vehicles lighter for their size, and nobody loads their car with bricks and sandbags to get that "heavier feeling". Lower center of gravity is great but completely decoupled from the overall mass of the vehicle. The fact that the comment came back from downvote graveyard is a testament that not only will people say anything to support even a ludicrous claim, many others will support it without batting an eye.
- dragonwriter 6y agoPeople would prefer it because it counteracts body lift, which reduces traction. Even if people don't understand the physics of why it works, the handling impacts are pretty apparent, especially out of low-speed city or heavy-traffic driving.
- NathanielK 6y agoThe heavier feel may not be preferred, but it makes having a flexible, cheap suspension design much easier. For example small carthat weighs 1000kg may be be expected to carrier 4-5 adults, an additional ~350kg. To do this the suspension must be overly sprung (and possibly under damped) for a single driver. A 2000kg Tesla means that even without air suspension or adaptive shocks, it will ride much better with a single driver while still being a capable of a high payload. Having a large battery also moves the unsprung:sprung mass ratio favourably. Specialty vehicles like sports cars and offroad trucksand where payload rating is not a concern function much better the lighter they are though.
- Tade0 6y ago> Are they? Any sources on that? https://pushevs.com/2021/01/10/guoxuan-unveils-a-cobalt-free-lfp-pouch-battery-cell-with-212-wh-kg/ https://pushevs.com/2021/01/10/guoxuan-unveils-a-cobalt-free... FTA: 2009: 95 Wh/kg 2015: 140 Wh/kg 2019: 190 Wh/kg 2020: 212 Wh/kg (191 Wh/kg at pack level with JTM) Context: this chemistry, while inexpensive and durable, was always thought as something that didn't stand a chance against other, denser ones in applications such as EVs. Currently it seems that it crossed the threshold of having all the parameters - price, durability and energy/power density - good enough to essentially replace NMC/NCA long term. Especially given that it uses no cobalt or other high-demand materials. Tesla already uses LiFePO4 in some of its Chinese-made Model 3s, without much of a weight penalty.
- Shivetya 6y agowell there are many more weight sensitive applications that would benefit by a better solution than dead weight battery methods; I own a TM3 and enjoy the EV experience but do realize there need to be alternatives to eight hundred to thousand pound packs. From planes to motorcycles and so on. Both are more sensitive to weight than any four wheel vehicle. plus portability may be an issue for some uses that battery packs will never overcome. Even the trucking industry has to worry about weight and it may take an excessive amount of weight to get similar ranges to the diesel trucks we have even after swapping fuel and motor for batteries and its motor. Regardless, all solutions being offered end fossil fuels and that should be the primary concern.
- buran77 6y agoThere are studies that suggest it's not the absolute range per charge of an electric vehicle that matters, it's how quickly you can extend that range. If you look at ICE cars nobody worries about range despite some of them having abysmal fuel consumption and range. But with a refill taking minutes, and gas pumps being ubiquitous and able to serve a large amount of customers simultaneously without interfering with the capacity of nearby stations, this is never a real issue. Battery energy density is increasing and that's great. But if I were to venture a guess this mostly benefits people who can spend several hours to fully charge them, like at home. A battery that can add 200-300Km of range in 10-15 minutes would probably do a lot for the people who can't charge at home. But this also introduces the next issue: large scale quick charging. Being able to quick charge a substantial number of cars simultaneously takes a lot of power. Having quick charge and a big battery on the car doesn't help at scale unless all charging stations are prepared to deliver the same (maybe giant banks of batteries taking the role of the underground fuel tank). There's no silver bullet when it comes to clean driving. It's a lot of incremental advancements mixed in with some revolutionary ones which need both time and investment. And perhaps a bit of change in human psychology.
- zeropoint46 6y agoI'm actually not asking this tongue and cheek but do fuel cells weigh significantly less when they are empty? I would think that a hydrogen fuel cell would functionally weigh the same empty or full, so itd be the same issue as batteries, no?
- dragonwriter 6y agoThe new version of the Mirai has a fuel cell that weighs 25.5kg for the fuel cell and power converter and a 5.6kg hydrogen capacity, so proportional to the weight of the cell the fuel is significant, but proportional the weight of the vehicle, not really.