3 ms·
Where would that person in that rent controlled apartment be otherwise? Chances are, on the street. Moving requires upfront capital. It requires promise of a jo
by asdff 6y ago
Where would that person in that rent controlled apartment be otherwise? Chances are, on the street. Moving requires upfront capital. It requires promise of a job at the other end. If you are in a high cost of living area like NYC or CA, you might have to quit your job if you want to find a more affordable apartment; there might be absolutely nothing affordable within a three hour drive of your job of cleaning up a downtown office or working a bar, and there may be absolutely no jobs in areas that are affordable. Throw in multiple earners, as is the case of many working poor in overcrowded rent controlled apartments, and you've complicated the problem further and make it even more difficult to wind down your life in one location and wind up in another.
And let's be reasonable here, rent control is not some handout. It's not a subsidy or a tax. The price you pay on your first year in a rent controlled apartment is market rate. Rent control simply says rents cannot go up say, beyond 4% a year. Perfectly reasonable in a world where wages for the working poor rarely go up beyond 4% a year. If landlords want to make more rental income per year, they should instead lobby their city council members to allow them to build more units per parcel, rather than lobby to artificially constrain housing supply with zoning and/or red tape in effort to raise real estate values.
- rayiner 6y ago> Where would that person in that rent controlled apartment be otherwise? Or, you know, New Jersey. Or some suburb. The same place younger people have to go because rent control destroyed the housing market in the city.
- asdff 6y agoAnd that will work fine for 1 person or 10 people but not 100 people or the 1000 in that rent controlled building in NYC, because you don't have a Manhattan's worth of jobs for working people in some suburb in New Jersey. Sure, some people can afford the car, the insurance, the gas, the parking, the hours a day commuting, but for those that can't, they end up on the street. In some areas, like in CA, you really don't save very much at all going out to the suburbs. A house like this one (1) would be literally 1/10th the price if not less somewhere else, but such is the housing market for some metropolitan areas in the US these days. 1. https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/20722-Pioneer-Blvd-Lakewood-CA-90715/21129045_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/20722-Pioneer-Blvd-Lakewo...
- rayiner 6y ago> And that will work fine for 1 person or 10 people but not 100 people or the 1000 in that rent controlled building in NYC, because you don't have a Manhattan's worth of jobs for working people in some suburb in New Jersey. Sure, some people can afford the car, the insurance, the gas, the parking, the hours a day commuting, but for those that can't, they end up on the street. You’ve got it backwards. There’s not enough jobs in Manhattan for all the people who want to live there. The unemployment rate in NYC this time two years ago (before pandemic) was 4.2%. In Iowa it was 2.7%. In December 2020 NYC unemployment was over 11%. In the rest of NY it was 5.9%. In Iowa it was 3.1%. Cities like NYC are a Mecca for yuppie jobs. For the most part, they are shitty places for normal people to find work. > In some areas, like in CA, you really don't save very much at all going out to the suburbs. That’s because California is the epicenter of bad ideas about housing policy: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-broughel-hamilton-overregulation-housing-california-20190703-story.html https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-broughel-hamilto.... I live an hour outside DC and you can buy a 3BR family home for 3x median family income in the county. In CA it’s like 7-8x even in the suburbs.
- skedaddle 6y agoEveryone gets rent control, whether they'd be "on the street" otherwise or not. My brother lived in SF and drove down the peninsula to Google (an hours long commute) while living in a rent controlled apartment for 10+ years while rent was shooting through the roof. He's not the only one. There's obviously a lot of people living on the street in sf -- rent control has failed to stop that.