4 ms·
Is beyond meat actually healthier than meat? If you search my question you’ll see the results are hardly conclusive. What’s everyone’s take?
by endisneigh 6y ago
Is beyond meat actually healthier than meat? If you search my question you’ll see the results are hardly conclusive.
What’s everyone’s take?
- nepeckman 6y agoCompared to what meat? Which animal, which cuts, which quality? Is it healthier than a really high quality meat, prepared well? Maybe not. Is it healthier than fast food "beef"? Yeah probably. Either way, environmental and moral concerns are just as relevant as health concerns when considering diet.
- kilroy123 6y agoI personally don't think so. I'm no scientist. I have, however, done a LOT of studying about food because I have some serious stomach issues. What has finally worked for me? Intermittent fasting for 15-16 hours a day — eating a low-carb diet filled with veggies. I feel a night and day difference eating like this. Btw I was mostly vegan and vegetarian for half a decade before this. Take it as you will.
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoI think it tastes pretty good, but I would be surprised if it were any healthier.
- therealmarv 6y agoI think it's more unhealthy because it contains too much mineral oil (search my other comment) according to various tests of a German magazine.
- throwaway5752 6y agoYes, you've posted this elsewhere. Your sourcing is very poor on this, and you don't make it clear that it's residue, rather than an ingredient (further, you exaggerate the hazard substantially, this is something that is consumed in large quantities for treating constipation). To be clear, it is not an ingredient, and it is Generally Recognized as Safe in multiple applications (https://www.fda.gov/food/food-additives-petitions/food-additive-status-list#ftnM https://www.fda.gov/food/food-additives-petitions/food-addit...) and it's pretty obvious from the product this is food equipment lubrication.
- therealmarv 6y agoBetter a poor sourcing than no sourcing. Yes I don't got it 100% right, sorry for my English. It was never meant to be a scientific thesis. But people should be aware that Beyond Meat are doing things not good enough (at least in Europe) and knowledge transfer and awareness are the only things that matter here.
- mft_ 6y agoThis is a reasonable look at exactly this question: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMGV_dBTE-k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMGV_dBTE-k (no affiliation, just a subscriber)
- mpalczewski 6y agoA completely natural product eaten by humans for millenia, vs a new factory produced goo. I prefer real food over fake.
- dilap 6y agoPersonally, I very much doubt it. Meat is an ancient food. We've evolved as hunter-gatheres, with most of our calories coming from hunting. It would be very surprising if we were not well-adapted to eating a lot of meat. Modern hunter-gatherer tribes which eat a lot of meat, like the Hadza, have excellent health. Something like Beyond Meat is novel; it may well be OK, but I'd certainly exercise a lot of caution before trusting it. Another way to look at the question, while incomplete, is just to look at the breakdown of the nutrients. Per cronometer.com, here's specimen A: https://imgur.com/a/uEWhL7E https://imgur.com/a/uEWhL7E and specimen B: https://imgur.com/a/zcAXeya https://imgur.com/a/zcAXeya Which of those looks healthier to you? To me, they look pretty similar, except for A has a lot more PUFA, and a lot less vitamin B. There is a lot of controversy about PUFA, but my belief is too much of it is one of the main causes of disease in people eating "Western-style" diets. So I'd guess specimen B is healthier; that's the cow burger. (Tangentially, is there a good website to easily share pngs? Imgur compression is pretty brutal for text stuff.)
- throwaway5752 6y ago"Hunter-Gatherers" There is a great deal of misinformation about hunter-gather diets: https://globalhealth.duke.edu/news/what-can-hunter-gatherers-teach-us-about-staying-healthy https://globalhealth.duke.edu/news/what-can-hunter-gatherers... or https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-paleo-diet-half-baked-how-hunter-gatherer-really-eat/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-paleo-diet-ha... (I didn't invest much effort in finding illustrative links, there are many more, and academic research). Walking around constantly and digging up/harvesting edible plants, insects, fungi, possibly carrion, and the occasional meat (including organs) is much more likely. Most of our ancestors' calories didn't come from hunting in most areas. Those that did had lifestyles so different from a modern one that it makes no sense to compare them.
- dilap 6y agoThose articles seem to be advocating against the idea (popular in the paleo community) that carbs are unhealthy or wouldn't have been part of our ancestral diets. I agree that idea seems mistaken, and agree that fruit, tubers, and honey are all foods we've likely been eating since aproximately forever. But I don't think it's true we weren't also eating a lot of animals, and in many cases, getting most of our calories from animals. Separately, the existence of modern hunter-gatherer groups like the Hadza that eat a lot of meat and are healthy suggests eating meat is healthy. (Of course, you have to be careful, since there are potentially large differences between the Hadza's nose-to-tail fresh, wild kills, and what you might get at the supermarket. Meat is a broad category.)