2 ms·
>> to distribute pornographic content without the subjects’ consent. Fine wording issue: To distribute pornographic content made without the subjects' consen
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> to distribute pornographic content without the subjects’ consent.
Fine wording issue: To distribute pornographic content made without the subjects' consent. Actors cannot remove consent post-production, they cannot make the R-rated movie and then turn around and say it cannot be distributed because they no longer like the sex scenes in it. No doubt countless celebs would love to delete scenes they did in their early careers. That it is simply pornographic is not enough. The must prove that it was made without consent (eg a hidden camera or long range lens through an open window).
Where this mattered very recently: What about a "sex pic" taken by the celeb themselves? Say a selfie taken using their own phone pointed at a mirror? That happened a few years ago to lots of very famous female celebs. Or, going back more years, the infamous Paris Hilton tapes. She made those herself. She lost control of them much later. She consented to their creation at the time, only removing her consent to their distribution after someone purchased the originals legally at auction.
- yunohn 6y agoThe quote was from the article. Regardless, I’m not fully aware of the applicable laws here. But, I would hope that consent to be filmed/photographed and consent to have said content distributed should always be two very different things. Further, just like other forms of art, the latter should always be retractable. One can write a book and have it published and distributed, but also cancel/fulfill the contract to prevent further distribution. I think this is even more relevant for private content such as sex-tapes, which are not the same as commercial pornography.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Fine wording issue: To distribute pornographic content made without the subjects' consent. It's actually illegal to distribute pornographic video content without a chain of documentation that is virtually impossible to have without both consent at time of creation and a valid chain of business directly addressing the documentation between the creator and distributor. This is important in sex tape cases, because while it may not violate state consent laws, it invariably violates federal record-keeping laws that apply to producers and distributors of pornographic content. If there isn't a chain of business with explicit agreements on rights (purchase of media containing content will not suffice) between the creator and the distributor there are probably also copyright issues (and if not between the subject and the distributor, especially for celebrities, often state “image and likeness” rights issues) as well.
- sandworm101 6y agoTo get to those rules the content must first be "pornographic". Nudity does not necessarily constitute pornography, else any R-rated movie would qualify. The "image and likeness" standard applies if there is some form of apparent endorsement. If I see Paris Hilton at the gas station I am allowed to snap her picture and sell it to the tabloids. I might blur out the gas station's logo before her face. Copyright attaches to the creator, not the subject. This came up in iPhone hacking cases. You cannot demand a takedown of a picture just because you are in it. If you are in it then you didn't take it and so do not own it. The person with copyright is the person holding the camera. You need to purchase that copyright from them before sending your takedowns. There are ways to acquire copyrights without the owner's consent, but they are not cheap. (Default judgements against owners then foreclosing on the copyright as an assets etc.)
- dragonwriter 6y ago> To get to those rules the content must first be "pornographic". Yes, the discussion I was responding to was literally and explictly about pornographic content. > Copyright attaches to the creator, not the subject. That's what I said. I also said that likeness rights flow from the subject, and that both were potential issues depending on where the chain of permissions do and do not reach. > You cannot demand a takedown of a picture just because you are in it You cannot issue a DMCA takedown based on copyright on that basis, but, likewise, the DMCA safe harbor which applies only to copyright claims does not apply to violations of likeness rights at all. (Section 230 protections might apply to an independent host, but that has no bearing on the legality of the content simply who is liable for the illegality.)
- alisonkisk 6y agoYou are conflating multiple issues here, including whether consent is revokable (generally not), and copyright protections.