4 ms·
Rationing bread would increase the number of people who have some bread. Regulating the price to a point well below the free market supply/demand driven price
by sokoloff 6y ago
Rationing bread would increase the number of people who have some bread.
Regulating the price to a point well below the free market supply/demand driven price causes a decrease in the amount of bread supplied to the market (and probably increase hoarding/decrease the breadth of distribution).
Think back to toilet paper shortages last spring. Rationing was arguably the best move (and was what local markets around me did).
- Mediterraneo10 6y ago> Regulating the price to a point well below the free market supply/demand driven price causes a decrease in the amount of bread supplied to the market. In some countries like Egypt, bread (or another basic staple) is heavily subsidized below the free market price, but that doesn’t seem to meaningfully impact the market’s supply: any consumer able to pay that artificially low price can still eat all the bread he or she wants.
- HDMI_Cable 6y agoWell it seems more that the supply is sufficiently high to prevent a shortage from the demand (I guess we can thank modern farming techniques).
- sokoloff 6y agoI agree that subsidies perturb the free market, but in this case to the side of increasing supply. (You can model it as the supply curve being shifted downward by the amount of the government subsidy.)
- nickff 6y agoSubsidies are different from price ceilings; subsidies often spur over-production along with over-consumption (think HFCS), whereas price ceilings discourage production and encourage hoarding (arguably a form of over-consumption). Price ceilings also foster a domestic black market, whereas subsidies foster an export black market.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- codeflo 6y agoI agree, although the toilet paper situation was a bit different IMO because the shortage wasn't in the supply chain -- it was absolutely clear that inventories would restock sooner or later. In that situation, higher prices wouldn't have incentivized more production. Still, supermarkets could have temporarily raised prices 10x and still sold their inventory. Why didn't more of them do it? Presumably, they made the rational calculation that the bad reputation they'd get from such a move would outweigh any short-term profits.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf the shortage of consumer form-factor toilet paper wasn't in the supply chain, where was it?
- codeflo 6y agoI don't like "gotcha" style discussions, but I admit I could have worded that more precisely. What I meant is: There was no reduction in overall toilet paper production, and people didn't suddenly start to shit more. The shortage was mostly a distribution/packaging issue in the form of "not available in packaging X at location Y". Markets tend to solve that kind of problem incredibly quickly.
- sokoloff 6y agoI wasn't trying to "getcha", but I do think this genuinely is a supply chain issue. Consumer form factor toilet paper is still being rationed for me right now (in Cambridge, MA-max 1). That's a year after the start of this.
- codeflo 6y agoVery interesting, I guess my experience here in Germany was very different. No toilet paper anywhere for 2-3 weeks last March/April, and then suddenly supermarkets drowned in it. Do you know if these are really meaningful shortages, or if businesses have just kept the signs up to make people feel taken care of?
- nonsince 6y agoRental properties are inherently rationed by the fact that there is no reason to rent more than one flat in the same city.
- arebop 6y ago15% of the units in my building are subleased by tenants who may well lease additional rent-controlled flats in the same city.
- sokoloff 6y agoThat part is true, but the decision to take roommates vs not affects the demand on rental properties. The decision to rent a 2 or 3 BR instead of a 1 BR as a single person working from home affects the demand as well. In a rent-control environment, people have incentive to hoard their rent-controlled apartment as well, especially if rents reset on turnover. If I have a rent-controlled apartment that's well below its replacement cost to me, I'm going to be more inclined to keep it when I initially move in with a significant other. If that relationship fails, I can move back. If it were a market rate apartment, I'd have much less to almost no incentive to do that.
- ericd 6y agoYep, I know at least one family that’s pretty well off that held onto their rent controlled place for years after no longer living in it, and then essentially passed it down to their kids. They basically own that apartment for less than it’d cost to maintain if they actually owned it, in terms of HOA/property tax, since the rent is stuck where it was like 30 years ago. And when I was looking for a place, I came across a couple people playing landlord and trying to sublet out their rent controlled place for more than they were paying the landlord. It’s pretty broken, at least in NYC.
- leetcrew 6y agoI don't think this is a very useful way of looking at it. it's uncommon, but not unheard of, for people to rent more than one apartment in the same city. especially if it's a large city, someone with a lot of money might find it attractive to rent a small studio by the office and a larger space in a nice residential area. if rent were really cheap, I might lease a second unit in my building for out-of-town visitors. it would probably be more practical to just rent a 2BR instead, but in some sense this is the same thing. renting two 600 sqft apartments takes roughly as much living space off the market as renting one 1200 sq ft apartment. if rent were way cheaper, you would probably see developers start building much larger units and people renting them. indeed, this is often what you see when you compare housing stock in the city vs. the surrounding suburbs.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI think this is something that is often overlooked in progressive circles. Markets treat high prices as signal to increase supply. When supplies cannot be increased you get market inequities. Rationing for goods like bread, paper, milk, gasoline, etc. Can be a stand-in while the problem that is preventing the market from responding by increasing supply is fixed.
- kmeisthax 6y agoThe problem is that usually supply isn't the problem, it's demand. For example, America's main problem with agricultural products is finding enough people to buy and eat them. That's why the government spends lots of money on agricultural supports. Hell, even welfare programs, as inadequate as they are, help stabilize prices by basically injecting a minimum amount of demand into the system. So, usually, supply shocks are temporary and resolvable without needing to resort to price gouging. The producers know that prices of a particular commodity aren't going to collapse if they invest money in switching over to produce it. Instead of getting a 10x jump in the price of, say, bread; it gets a little hard to find at first and then goes up 5%. Housing is almost completely the opposite; supply of the underlying land is fixed and most cities cap density. We can, of course, uncap density; but that still requires we basically displace everyone living in the city eventually to make way for larger buildings that can house more people. The thing that really grinds my gears is that the solutions to housing scarcity effectively amount to building a wall around a city and making foreigners pay for it - and they're often championed by exactly the same kinds of people who otherwise are rightly opposed to immigration formalities.
- neilparikh 6y ago> we basically displace everyone living in the city eventually to make way for larger buildings that can house more people In theory, this is true. In practicality, at least in America there's enough land with very little density, that a new building could be constructed while displacing basically no one (because the previous occupant of the land is already willing to move, it's just that the new seller isn't allowed to build anything). Eventually, yes, we'll get to point where displacement is an issue, but right now it's not worth worrying about. Building dense really is a "free lunch" so to speak. I probably agree with you overall, I just bring this up because a lot of NIMBY arguments use displacement as the boogeyman, and I'd rather not give them more support. > The thing that really grinds my gears is that the solutions to housing scarcity effectively amount to building a wall around a city and making foreigners pay for it - and they're often championed by exactly the same kinds of people who otherwise are rightly opposed to immigration formalities. Many of the arguments even go beyond that and sound like anti-immigration arguments: I've heard a lot of people say that techies/yuppies in SF should go back to the cities they came from.
- WalterBright 6y agoRationing does nothing to increase the supply, and distributes the existing supply to people who don't need it. Rationing assumes everyone has exactly the same need, which is nonsense and leads to gross inefficiencies. Rationing inevitably leads to hoarding and a black market.
- bluGill 6y ago> Rationing does nothing to increase the supply, Maybe, maybe not. Depends on how you handle prices (or subsidies) along with the rationing. >distributes the existing supply to people who don't need it. A bit, but in the case of housing and food you can safely assume people all need it in about the same amounts. You will be wrong, but close enough. The black market might even by your friend in correcting some of your mistakes. > Rationing assumes everyone has exactly the same need, which is nonsense and leads to gross inefficiencies. yes and no. You don't have to assume the same needs. You can figure out rules. Families need more space - which can be used to encourage/discourage having kids depending on your goals. Overall it leads to inefficiencies I agree. > Rationing inevitably leads to hoarding and a black market. True or not based on how much trust there is in the ration plan. If people agree with the reasons and means there will be a lot less than if people disagree, or find they can't get even the minimum. WWII rationing in the US mostly worked from what I understand - people were proud to not use their entire ration of sugar, but there was overall enough food (including gardens) so it wasn't hard. That is probably the exception (and even then there was a black market!), but it does make the point.
- WalterBright 6y ago> WWII rationing in the US mostly worked from what I understand It suffered from all the faults I mentioned. The black market in gas was extensive, and even included drive by shootings. In public, people proudly supported rationing, in private, they sold their extra gas to people who needed it at black market prices. Yes, the government did try in their blundering manner to give different rations based on need, but it inevitably grossly mismatched supply with demand. I've talked to people who lived through it, and there was certainly two economies going on - the ration one, and the black market one. For example, one lived on a farm that wasn't doing much, but got a big gas allocation because "farm". They made a mint selling it under the table. > You can figure out rules. Yeah, like the byzantine vaccine rules, along with the confusion and fights over it. Politicians moved themselves to the front of the line, naturally. Just like in WW2, politicians got all the gas they wanted.