2 ms·
The regulations around radios exist because the spectrum is limited and emissions propagate over a wide area. You and I (assuming you're in the US) have the sam
by giantrobot 6y ago
The regulations around radios exist because the spectrum is limited and emissions propagate over a wide area. You and I (assuming you're in the US) have the same standing to use radio spectrum. If I go and modify my phone's firmware to increase the power output I could literally jam communications from your phone.
It's very different than if I modified the firmware on my hard drive or UEFI on a PC. I might fuck up my stuff but it doesn't affect you. I can fiddle with my hard drive firmware all day but I'm not going to block a 911 call you're trying to make.
Also a company giving out modem firmware is an exception and not a rule. It re-classes the device as a hobbyist/experimental device and if they go traipsing around with it they could potentially face fines (unlikely but possible).
Again it's not about lobbying it's about a limited spectrum and people being stupid/assholes not realizing or caring their pocket radio affects others. You live in a world where shitheads try to make their cars louder on purpose and you can pick up dozens of WAPs because everyone sets the power to the highest number the interface allows.
- fsflover 6y agoUsing wrong spectrum and jamming communications of others can be illegal without forcing proprietary firmware. It's like making all cars illegal, because someone blocks access roads for a fire brigade.
- giantrobot 6y agoIt's not forcing proprietary firmware. The firmware could be entirely open so long as end users couldn't freely modify it on their devices. Competition between baseband manufacturers drives them to keep firmwares proprietary.
- fsflover 6y agoPreventing modification of the firmware is like making your car unrepairable and unopenable, so you couldn't mess with it.