7 ms·
In particular, I suspect science only "works" to the extent that a certain amount of heterodoxy is tolerated. If "science" as an institution becomes very confor
by throwaway894345 6y ago
In particular, I suspect science only "works" to the extent that a certain amount of heterodoxy is tolerated. If "science" as an institution becomes very conformist, then you'll only get science that reinforces the biases of the prevailing ideology. The quality of the output that the institution produces depends on the health of the institution, where "health" means something like "ideological diversity" as it does with natural ecosystems.
A lot of pro-conformists make the argue that tolerating ideological diversity means regarding creationism and evolution as equally valid; of course this is untrue--science can (and indeed did) find that evolution is the more valid idea without explicitly persecuting creationists. In other words, normal heterodox science would already prefer evolution to creationism--not only is there no need to (for example) write open letters demanding various creationists' resignation/termination/excommunication/etc, but that sort of persecution actually harms the health (heterodoxy) of science (not because science needs creationists, but because science needs heterodoxy to be able to decide that creationism is the invalid idea in the first place).
- 13415 6y agoCreationism has nothing to do with science, neither has ideology any place in science, and you've really got to draw the limit somewhere more reasonable. I don't want my taxes to pay "research" in creationism, morphogenetic fields, astrology, or divining rods. There is plenty of heterodoxy in science as is - or do you really believe everyone agrees about almost everything in almost every discipline? Pretty much the opposite is the case. Pick any discipline you like and there will be plenty of disagreement about the respective issues in the forefront of scientific research.