3 ms·
This is something that is pushed by some people. With many journals I review for however, I am able to see otger reviewers reviews and I suppose they would be a
by ta988 6y ago
This is something that is pushed by some people. With many journals I review for however, I am able to see otger reviewers reviews and I suppose they would be ashamed to have their names to be associated with them (extremely short and with generoc sentences that looks like they didnt even read the paper or just plainly agressive). I've heard many arguments against open review, but the most common is that people are afraid of retaliations if they criticize a work. I understand that people have retaliated to me after comments on PubPeer. But I still think we should do open reviews, that doesnt mean that journals that make people pay for publishing or reading should pay reviewers. We work for free get 0 reward... It is a bit like asking a designer to work for you, and tell them that it is to help the world of design and thank you no you can't sign...