12 ms·
It’s awful. Everything web-based is slower on my 4.5 ghz MacBook Pro than things were on my 300 MHz PII running Windows 98. Every web page causes MacOS to compl
by rayiner 6y ago
It’s awful. Everything web-based is slower on my 4.5 ghz MacBook Pro than things were on my 300 MHz PII running Windows 98. Every web page causes MacOS to complain “Safari is using a lot of power.” I was hunting for a project management web app, and one ate up 10% of the CPU just sitting there doing nothing. This has gotten particularly bad with Microsoft, with Word and Outlook on the Mac, which just kill battery life. (I think they’re using more and more JS under the hood, and I hear Outlook is slated to be replaced with a web app.) Teams is a bloated pig.
The crazy thing is that all these web apps also do a fraction of the things that the native apps used to do. They’ve somehow managed to strip down all the features while making the apps slow and bloated. Watching Microsoft’s To-Do blog is comitragic. Elon Musk will be living on Mars before the Microsoft tools allow you to schedule todos by dragging them to the calendar like Outlook has done since what, 98? (You can drag a todo from the web sidebar to the calendar now—but it somehow doesn’t actually schedule the due or start date in the todo itself or even have any link back to the todo.) And I feel like that’s one thing that’s different now. I also complained that Word 97 was a slow bloated big compared to Word Perfect, etc. But back in the day there was feature bloat. Now, everything is both slow and and non-functional.
I have to assume that it’s a structural thing with the industry. Machine learning, big data, security, etc., has become the hot areas, so all the “A” teams have migrated over there. I hear Apple is having trouble even getting people to do kernel work on MacOS.
- pdimitar 6y agoI have no good theory about why that is except that maybe more and more business people are under the illusion that "software is being increasingly commoditized" which is of course not true.
- mattgreenrocks 6y agoTheir perception sort of perpetuates it. I've seen devs arguing this, though IMO that is more the devs speaking out of resignation and learning to say the right things rather than the truth.
- yourapostasy 6y ago> ..."software is being increasingly commoditized"... I only wish this were true; then value propositions for software could climb a value ladder. The challenge is business' are not standardized beyond some very basic functions, and new standardization comes at a brutally high cost (time and expense). So I see where office productivity has settled on Microsoft Office (though even there, I see huge fragmentation between versions, how people don't use styles, how most people have no idea of pivot tables in Excel, etc.), and we've pretty much just crawled along at a snails pace since then. If anything, judging by how little I can transplant of business processes that emerge around software from one company to another, and how much those processes mutate over time, I would assert software standardization is getting worse, because getting businesses to standardize even when moving to the cloud has been a bigger challenge than I anticipated.
- deburo 6y agoThis is a specific nickpick but you won’t make me miss Outlook desktop. It’s crazy old and big, and for basic email stuff, its web app counterpart is much faster. But anyway in the enterprise sector, it doesn’t matter whether an app is web or native, it will be slow regardless lol.
- jl6 6y agoAnd just to confirm the forces in play here: enterprises care primarily about business outcomes of software, license cost, and support risk, with end-user experience being very far down the priority list except for a very few productivity applications where UI responsiveness actually matters for increasing employee output (fewer than you’d think). In short, the users aren’t the customers.
- tharne 6y agoYup. That's exactly why enterprise software almost universally sucks. This could really be applied to any good or service where the purchaser is not the end user. For example, in the U.S. dealing with your health insurance company is a nightmare, and a lot of that has to do with the fact that it's your employer who's the customer. If the health insurance company treats you badly, you can't go with another provider, so they're free to offer terrible service so long as they don't piss of your company's HR department who decides which health plans to go with.
- branko_d 6y ago> ...except for a very few productivity applications where UI responsiveness actually matters for increasing employee output (fewer than you’d think). If there is UI, UI responsiveness matters for employee output. Research that has been done on this topic suggests that increase in UI latency non-linearly decreases user productivity, whith the ultimate effect on the cost of doing business. And that has been known for decades - take a look at the "The Economic Value of Rapid Response Time" from 1982: https://jlelliotton.blogspot.com/p/the-economic-value-of-rapid-response.html https://jlelliotton.blogspot.com/p/the-economic-value-of-rap... It's puzzling to me why businisses still don't prioritize UI latency, but it's not a rational decision. Perhaps it's just human nature, as hinted in the linked article: "...few executives are aware that such a balance is economically and technically feasible."
- jgalentine007 6y agoIt is awful, but there are some positive tradeoffs like security and flexibility. For example, there have been a zillion vulnerabilities with native Office over the years. Visual Studio is a terrible pain to skin or customize its look and feel compared to VS Code.
- mattgreenrocks 6y agoI'm convinced my retirement gig will be writing nice, native apps for my platform of choice. They won't bring in a ton of cash, but I can continue to make beautiful apps that are fast, focused, and respect the user's time and computing resources.
- waynesonfire 6y agoWhich GUI framework will you use?
- mattgreenrocks 6y agoIf I had to pick right now, I'd choose macOS for a platform. For tech, I'd consider both Cocoa + Swift and SwiftUI as candidates for UI components, on a case-by-case basis. Swift is not my favorite language (feels like I have to use Xcode; have yet to try out the JetBrains IDE), but it gets the results I want. Perhaps in the future, we can use Rust in a more ergonomic fashion to talk with native UIs. Honestly, I'd love an ObjC-like language that interops with ObjC and has strong static typing with a dynamic typing escape hatch for metaprogramming.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoThe JetBrains IDE for it (AppCode) is pretty nice, but you have to use Xcode for storyboards and UI design; other than that, light years ahead of the Xcode experience.
- mattgreenrocks 6y agoGood to know, I'll give it a shot!
- apples_oranges 6y agoIDK, AppCode always seemed so resource hungry.. but yeah it's worth a try I suppose. I believe the Xcode experience isn't too bad however.
- abakker 6y agoOUTLOOK! Jeez has it gotten slow on my mac. I am not a particularly fast typist, but I can routinely out-type outlook by a whole sentence. Moreover in the latest version, if I hit command-R and start typing it will routinely take so long to just start replying to a message that it will drop the first 90 characters I type. I've seen rumors that microsoft will replace it, and I cannot wait until that happens.
- twobitshifter 6y agoI remember Outlook on windows 10 actually adding animation to my typing to smooth out the flow of words. I disabled that immediately and I’m usually pro eye candy, but that was a step too far.
- metalliqaz 6y agosame. it was the dumbest feature i've ever seen.
- cyral 6y agoGlad I'm not the only one experiencing this. I have a brand new i7 Mac and outlook is laggy just switching between emails or inboxes. Also, if I click the "Switch to New Outlook" button, it says that it can't copy over my custom IMAP accounts for work. I would think that supporting things besides exchange or gmail accounts would be something they would do before releasing a new version.
- slaymaker1907 6y agoWeirdly enough it seems like Outlook on the web is somehow faster than the Windows version. It might be because lots of email uses HTML and Outlook is using an ancient version of HTML. I am very impressed with developers who can make things consistent in Outlook as well as actual browsers.
- cambalache 6y agoOutlook web is slow as molasses. In the desktop is literally unusable for me (It never opens my account). Both things were superior experiences in 1999.
- radiator 6y agoIs it possible to use the web only as a platform to deliver the newest version of your native application? - User visits website - downloads binary (preferably small size, use an appropriate language and cross-platform graphics library) - launches it (preferably without installation) - Perhaps creation of a local storage directory on the file system is needed the first time. - and voilà! What would be the main obstacles to such a workflow? Are there projects who try work like this?
- rayiner 6y agoZoom?