6 ms·
I hadn't heard of this before, so maybe I am missing some context here, but something seems fishy: > Steam is one of the listed platforms of commercialization
by legitster 6y ago
I hadn't heard of this before, so maybe I am missing some context here, but something seems fishy:
> Steam is one of the listed platforms of commercialization in the contract between Frogwares and Nacon. But since the release of the game, Nacon’s unlawful actions have forced Frogwares to defend its property and react in front of the French Justice for lack of payments, attempts to steal our IPs, etc which we made a public letter about back in August 2020.
Here's the previous statement from Nacon:
https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/750130/view/3058478454630446188 https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/750130/view/30584784...
I can't find any of the details about Nacon's unlawful actions, and it seems Frogware is being intentionally vague. Doing some digging, it seems like this is almost a complete retread of a legal battle they had before:
https://twinfinite.net/2019/09/frogwares-games-delisted-alleged-dispute-focus-home-interactive/ https://twinfinite.net/2019/09/frogwares-games-delisted-alle...
It seems like they may have a history of playing a copyright game with publishers - take their money to develop a game, then use legal trickery to take back the property outright.
In this case Nacon may have felt they had a "mechanic's lien" on the code and felt justified stealing it back outright (probably a bad choice in the long run). But regardless, I don't get the sense that Frogwares is completely being on the up and up about the relationship with their exes.
Update: Frogwares has a much more detailed list of grievances here: https://frogwares.com/the-sinking-city-is-being-delisted-heres-why/ https://frogwares.com/the-sinking-city-is-being-delisted-her... Some seem petty and some seem serious. But it still leaves questions. How much did Nacon already pay Frogwares? Does Frogwares plan on paying it back?
> The agreement is, therefore, terminated without further formality. Moreover, on July 17, 2020, Nacon attempted to oppose the termination in court, but the judge rejected the demand, and the contract is now terminated in the eyes of the law.
Maybe French law is much weirder than ours, but this phrasing would be highly suspect in the US. You would get a really affirmative ruling that you are still bound by contract or not.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoThat doesn't seem like a retread at all. Sherlock Holmes vs Jack the Ripper, for instance, was released in '09, and the dispute happened in 2019. A ten year period of exclusivity would not be uncommon, and neither would a publisher dragging their heels on handling it at the end. It's very possible that the producers, lawyers and business development people involved in the original deal had all moved on. NOLF is famously not getting a remaster because nobody can figure out who owns it! Maybe Frogwares is a bad actor, I don't know. But game publishers are notorious for trying to get away with all sorts of shit with studios that cannot afford to fight back, so there's another possibility: Frogwares is prepared to litigate to defend what is legitimately theirs.
- legitster 6y agoAbsolutely fair. I just want to make sure we don't rush to white knight someone in what from a distance could very well be a domestic squabble. I don't doubt for a second that the publishers are crappy actors. But on the same token, you wouldn't expect them to do something so brazenly awful unless they had a legal leg to stand on.
- mym1990 6y agoMore like a peg to stand on. Yarrr.
- toyg 6y ago> NOLF is famously not getting a remaster because nobody can figure out who owns it! Yet another way the games industry is just "movie industry 2.0". The web of production and distribution deals in the movie biz is notoriously hairy, prone to end up in situations where IP ownership is contested. Which is a shame, really.
- fnordsensei 6y ago> I can't find any of the details about Nacon's unlawful actions, and it seems Frogware is being intentionally vague. They are not. They’ve written about it before: https://frogwares.com/the-sinking-city-is-being-delisted-heres-why/ https://frogwares.com/the-sinking-city-is-being-delisted-her... In short, - They have withheld payments owed Frogwares. - They have been behind on payments made by on average 40 days. - They have incorrectly claimed to own the IP to third parties, including in their IPO.
- legitster 6y agoYes! I updated my post when I saw this. I can't imagine it will be so simple for Frogwares to rip up their contract and walk away with the money they were paid already. But I imagine their publisher openly ripping off their game will make upcoming settlements really easy for them.
- batmansmk 6y agoThe court ordered Frogwares to deliver the sources in October with 50k euros of penalty per day not shipping them. Frogwares did not deliver anything. As an Irish company with offices in Ukraine having to settle against a french publisher paying taxes in France, low standing in court (several lawsuits) and not having executed previous court orders, it sounds harder from my point of view. I can imagine a world where they even end up having to pay for the hacking cost as well.
- avereveard 6y agowas the original contract ever produced or available? > to deliver the sources this seems weird, since one party is telling the world from their blog the source transfer was never part of the agreement
- grumple 6y agoSeems kinda weird. I wonder if Frogwares could sue in a US court? Both companies probably do the bulk of their business in the US and are selling through US-based stores.
- ernesth 6y ago> Maybe French law is much weirder than ours, but this phrasing would be highly suspect in the US. You would get a really affirmative ruling that you are still bound by contract or not. French law is not that strange :). But the decision was appealed and it seems Nacon won in appeal (in october 2020), which allowed them to pursue the contract and to publish the game another time. The decision: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:DwqXp6UGNU8J:https://www.doctrine.fr/d/CA/Paris/2020/CB9E50FD5D01D28E6DFA2+ https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:DwqXp6...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- legitster 6y agoThis seems like exactly what is missing from their story. Unless something more recent was issued, they were flagrantly ignoring a direct court order.
- strogonoff 6y agoSummary of the timeline, based on a previous post by Frogwares[0]: In 2019: — Publisher paid for game development, though usually not on time. Per contract, IP remained with the game dev, and there was no obligation to hand over the source. — Publisher hired another studio to work on a similar game, and started demanding source code from game dev. — Game dev delivered the game (not the source). (Not clear whether on time or not.) — Publisher released the game, and immediately withheld profits from sales (with some mechanism referred to as retroactive milestone cancellation). — Publisher was also found to remove game dev’s logo, buying domain names reflecting game dev’s brand, mislead the public as to who had the rights to the game, and do other shady things. — Game dev sued, with unknown outcome. In 2020: — Attempt to pirate the game by the publisher was discovered (February). (Note: this is alleged to have happened long before publisher won on appeal, so it’s not as if the publisher decided to pirate the game after the court determined they are owed the source.) — Game dev terminated the now-breached contract and notified the publisher. Publisher claimed French COVID regulations precluding contract termination (?!). — Publisher sued and lost (July). — Publisher appealed and won (October). (This happened after the publication of the post I referenced.) This obviously presents game dev’s perspective only. It seems exhaustive enough though, and so far I’m inclined to think they aren’t distorting facts and may have been taken advantage of by a larger business (the publisher). Violating a court order is bad, and if game dev was ordered to hand over the source they should probably have complied. That aside, it’s unclear whether the courts ultimately sided with the good guy here. Sadly, if game dev’s the victim here, appealing cross-border may be infeasible for them. [0] https://frogwares.com/the-sinking-city-is-being-delisted-heres-why/ https://frogwares.com/the-sinking-city-is-being-delisted-her...