5 ms·
> In this new broken up set of companies, what's stopping them from remerging like Bell? Continued antitrust enforcement. Nobody should ever have approved thos
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> In this new broken up set of companies, what's stopping them from remerging like Bell?
Continued antitrust enforcement. Nobody should ever have approved those mergers. We can learn from our mistakes.
> Also, what's stopping them from giving each other favorable partnerships?
Why would they want to do that once they have separate owners?
> just create some sort of progressive taxation as a function of users.
How does this solve the monopoly problem at all? It has nothing to do with taxation.
- endisneigh 6y ago> Continued antitrust enforcement. Nobody should ever have approved those mergers. We can learn from our mistakes. That’s a nice thought but clearly doesn’t work in practice. I could be wrong though, are there any examples you can cite of monopolies being broken and staying that way in the USA? > Why would they want to do that once they have separate owners? They’re already familiar with each other. > How does this solve the monopoly problem at all? It has nothing to do with taxation. You don’t think a unavoidable tax that goes into smaller companies won’t hurt monopolies?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> That’s a nice thought but clearly doesn’t work in practice. It doesn't work if there is regulatory capture. But if the government is captured then you can't have your tax either, so then what are you proposing as a solution? > They’re already familiar with each other. Google and Oracle are familiar with each other. Apple and Intel are familiar with each other. Amazon and Netflix are familiar with each other. > You don’t think a unavoidable tax that goes into smaller companies won’t hurt monopolies? If they can keep abusing their monopolies to prevent there from being any competitors? There still won't be any competitors.
- endisneigh 6y agoI don’t see the connection between regulatory capture and what I’m describing. > If they can keep abusing their monopolies to prevent there from being any competitors? There still won't be any competitors. Which monopolies are you referring to have zero competitors? > Google and Oracle are familiar with each other. Apple and Intel are familiar with each other. Amazon and Netflix are familiar with each other. I don’t understand your point here, you’re listing pairs of competitors. Are you really not aware of large companies helping each other out?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> I don’t see the connection between regulatory capture and what I’m describing. In order to pass some kind of tax, you need regulators to pass some kind of tax. If the government is captured by the companies, they don't pass any kind of anything the company doesn't want, so you lose. If it isn't captured by the companies, you can do antitrust enforcement. > Which monopolies are you referring to have zero competitors? Apple and Google each have a monopoly on app stores for their respective platforms, for example. Note that "monopoly" for antitrust doesn't mean that there are exactly zero competitors. It only means that one of them dominates the market and has market power. > I don’t understand your point here, you’re listing pairs of competitors. Are you really not aware of large companies helping each other out? Google and Oracle hate each other and are constantly embroiled in bitter litigation. Apple just jettisoned Intel's processors in favor of their own. Netflix has used Amazon (AWS) for hosting and it didn't stop Amazon from going into competition with them for content production (Amazon Prime Video). Companies do what they like. What they like is to make money. One of the best ways to do that is to go make the money that some other company is currently making, or "commiditize your complement."[1] It isn't to altruistically help out competitors for no reason. [1] https://www.gwern.net/Complement https://www.gwern.net/Complement
- Retric 6y agoThe bells merging was really quite reasonable as the market is vastly different. Breaking AT&T into local monopolies plus long distance backbone still left local monopolies in place. Today however VOIP, cellphones, and even internet has brought real competition to the local phone companies. And fiber has largely gutted the long distance call pricing. Long distance calls where crazy expensive. During weekdays in 1980 AT&T charged $2.17 ($6 in today's money) for a five minute call from NYC to LA. Nights and weekends the same call cost $0.87 ($2.40). Today you can get unlimited nationwide for 34$ per month or pay 3$/month for service and get 10c/minute long distance calls anytime. https://www.att.com/home-phone/landline/long-distance.html https://www.att.com/home-phone/landline/long-distance.html
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe real problem with the Bell breakup is that last mile telephone service is actually a natural monopoly. The theory was supposed to be that the operators in neighboring states would expand to compete with each other. But that's just iterated prisoner's dilemma where nobody moves first because they don't want the competitor to respond in kind. Breakups across verticals make a lot more sense. So separating last mile from long distance, and separating Unix from AT&T, those were actually successes.
- galangalalgol 6y agoI have fiber and cable run for data. When an introductory offer ends, I call them up to cancel and if they won't make me a deal, I call the other provider and move an rj45 from one jack to the one next to it until that introductory offer ends. Last mile doesn't have to be a monopoly.
- toast0 6y agoLast mile doesn't have to be a monopoly, but there's a clear limit to how many overbuilt networks can be supported. Very few organizations are willing to build a third network when an area is already covered by two networks; the cost to build is too high, and the number of customers you'll attract is too low; and the profit margins are too slim, given how quickly incumbent networks can be made competitive when there's a will. Vanishingly few would overbuild a fourth network. Often two, sometimes three, and almost never four competitors is not a healthy marketplace. There's no way for a regular person to say 'my ISP stinks, I'm going to go out and do a better job', like you could in the dial-up days by getting a T1 for data, and a T1 for users to call in on. Yes, T1s were expensive, but they weren't as expensive as wiring up to every customer. If we want competition in ISPs, we need local loop unbundling, but for realsies; the companies owning and operating last mile networks should be strictly separate from the companies providing Internet Protocol services on those networks.
- nova22033 6y agoContinued antitrust enforcement. how would you demonstrate consumer harm when youtube was giving away the product for free?...or instagram...or whatsapp..
- mmcconnell1618 6y agoThe enforcement of antitrust changed from market share to consumer harm. There is nothing stopping a court from changing the definition back. NPR has a really good 3 part podcast on the history of this and future implications: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/03/20/704426033/antitrust-in-america https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2019/03/20/704426033/anti...
- nitrogen 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) (the wiki article is [currently] written about foreign markets, but the concept applies equally to domestic competition)
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt's not free. "You're not the customer, you're the product," right? So the cost is the terms under which the product is offered, e.g. the conditions under which you can be excluded at the behest of advertiser sensibilities. If those conditions aren't that nobody is ever banned for any reason then the cost is higher than it could be in a more competitive market. You also have similar costs as a result of algorithmic recommendation algorithms that promote things that aren't you over things that are you at the behest of the monopolist, and the amount content providers get paid by the platform (it could be higher or you could be not demonetized for nonsense reasons) etc.
- stiray 6y agoLet me add the little detail as no one ever finished the sentence and I believe a lot of people are struggling with. "You are not the customer, you're the product. The customers are advertisers, that are buying YOUR data from the google." That should make it clearer, right?
- brainwad 6y ago> Why would they want to do that once they have separate owners? Why or how would they end up with separate owners? The current owners of Alphabet would get equal shares in all demerged companies, I would hope. And presumably with the same 3-class stock system, so they would all be controlled by the same people, too.
- peteretep 6y agoAlphabet is listed, isn't it? So on day 1 after the split, I buy a single share in Alphabet-Search but not in Alphabet-Video, and then sue Alphabet-Search for giving Alphabet-Video a sweetheart deal that's not in my interests as a shareholder?
- pid_0 6y agoBut it would be in your interest as it would help both products.
- bagacrap 6y agoSeems likely they'd ink deals that are long term and hard to break (both legally and technically), like switching cloud service providers can be.
- summerlight 6y ago> Why would they want to do that once they have separate owners? Because the established business model is proven to be super effective and all the organizations and infrastructures are already optimized for the such model? The real question is, why would they deviate from the existing anti-competitive behavior if reforming the "Google cartel" with business partnership will give them a roughly same level of functionality? You gotta understand that their incentive functions are already tightly aligned with each other because that's what network effect is precisely supposed to do, so it will naturally head toward anti-competitive regardless of whether they are separate entities or not. The only meaningful action to prevent that would be highly targeted and specific antitrust remedies.