3 ms·
I think this is a perfect example of the difference, in fact. The first, corect, example could be either, but the second example shows a kind of mistake that co
by tsimionescu 6y ago
I think this is a perfect example of the difference, in fact. The first, corect, example could be either, but the second example shows a kind of mistake that couldn't really be made by a language model. Your son used (faulty) inference to deduce (1) silence:sound as clear:color, (2) distance => silence, therefore (3) distance => transparency. Premises 1 and 2 may be in the language training corpus, but conclusion 3 is definitely not, but still he produced this sentence.
Another example is that human language use is clearly related to non-verbal situations. You can show me two fruit and I can say which is bigger without any language prompting.
It may be true that our language faculty is in fact acting similarly to these LMs, but the overall human mind must somehow include a component that translates from our senses to language and back to motor control. There may or may not be other components as well, but this part is definitely required, and highly non-trivial.