8 ms·
Population crisis, peak oil, 'kids these days', rando 'not enough people believe in my ideology' driven crisis, 'Rome fell because people did a thing I don't li
by duxup 6y ago
Population crisis, peak oil, 'kids these days', rando 'not enough people believe in my ideology' driven crisis, 'Rome fell because people did a thing I don't like'...
It's funny to watch, a lot of these have seen before and will again.
- reader_mode 6y agoClimate change ? I don't doubt it's happening but the doom scenarios seem in line with all those predictions
- duxup 6y agoAny prediction being right doesn't really have much to do with all the wrong predictions IMO.
- Enginerrrd 6y agoIt does if taken in the context of all the wrong ones being taken as a bayesian prior, and that strategy will have predictive value.
- xyzzyz 6y agoClimate change definitely is the next one. It is most surely happening, and probably faster than we want or expect, but if you listen to scientific consensus (eg. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report), it is pretty clear that, while serious and troublesome issue, it most definitely is not an existential threat.
- eloff 6y agoProbably not directly. It will cause mass migration and refugee crises as coastal cities and low lying areas slowly flood. That seems inevitable at this point. That could maybe lead to wars, and nuclear war is still an existential threat. If the changes somehow disrupt the ability to support cereal crops in the northern hemisphere (which actually is also the biggest risk from nuclear winter), that could lead to widespread starvation and more wars. Not an existential crises necessarily, but not pretty.
- OrbitRock 6y agoWhat worries me most is the patterns of precipitation shifting. If we saw significant changes to where is wet and where is dry, we’d be scrambling to catch up and the fallout could be pretty large.
- Izkata 6y agoRelated to that, destabilizing weather patterns in general - a few weeks ago the polar vortex dipped further south in the US than ever before and Texas was caught really off-guard.
- xyzzyz 6y agoNo large coastal city will become flooded on a permanent basis. Building levees is just too easy and cheap relative to cost of giving up on a city, just ask medieval Dutchmen. By the way, the scientific consensus for predicted sea level rise in the worst temperature growth scenario is still less than 1 meter by 2100. That’s less than the difference between low and high tide. Some areas will get flooded (eg large parts of Florida Everglades), but 1 meter is really not a big deal. Similarly, there is no reason to be very concerned about crops: we already are able to grow crops in a very wide variety of climates, and we have cultivars specially selected for local climate conditions. While climate change is very fast on geological scale, it’s rather slow on human scale, which gives us plenty of time to adjust our crops and farming patterns. This is the biggest reason why climate change is not an existential threat: we are not going to sit on our thumbs, and watch the steamroller slowly ride over us, at speed of 1 cm per day. That’s not going to happen: mitigating the problems associated with climate change is rather simple, relative to other problems our societies solve on a regular basis, and we have a lot of time for it.
- tzs 6y ago> No large coastal city will become flooded on a permanent basis. Building levees is just too easy and cheap relative to cost of giving up on a city, just ask medieval Dutchmen. Levees don't work in south Florida. Well, they work to stop water that comes in horizontally above ground level, but in south Florida floods usually come in by bubbling up through the porous ground.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tharkun__ 6y ago"Kids these days": > The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households. They no longer rise when elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up dainties at the table, cross their legs, and tyrannize their teachers. ― Socrates (~470BC - 399BC)
- dmm 6y agoSocrates probably didn't say that and if he did so what? What argument are you actually making? "Two thousand years ago someone complained about X and people also complain about X now. So X is no big deal!"? Hippocrates complained about malaria. Does that mean contemporary concerns about malaria are invalid?
- tharkun__ 6y agoFair enough though not the point I was trying to make :) The parent mentioned "kids these days" and also "It's funny to watch, a lot of these have seen before and will again.". Whether Socrates actually said this (or some other famous or not so famous guy from over 2000 years ago), it does show that that assessment is probably very very correct. And very funny to read indeed. Even if you don't agree with all of the parts of the statement (I don't) you will most probably find some you'd agree with. YMMV if you don't have kids :)
- foolmeonce 6y agoOTOH, Socrates lived through the rise of Athens to prominence (their great generation?) and the generation he complains about would have been the ones to stop it's decline (our boomers -millenials.) (So his observations could be of a cultural cycle rather than what every generation experiences from each perspective.)
- Nasrudith 6y agoMalaria is largely the same - we have better treatment options but it is still the same disease. Society is very much not the same - for one pedastry is a severe crime instead of an accepted institution. Insensitivity to changing circumstances hints at a fixed belief. If your compass always points to the same place on the dial as north it is broken. Not to mention that nearly everybody loves luxury - that is partially why it is expensive above and beyond production price!