4 ms·
But that was exactly why he was so wrong - he thought that the limits to resources was static, and they are not always.
by refurb 6y ago
But that was exactly why he was so wrong - he thought that the limits to resources was static, and they are not always.
- lupire 6y agoIn computing we say that all problems are O(1) in the limit, because there is a practical limit to the available resources. The devil is in the details, and escaping the trap once isn't a permanent solution. Feeding us more efficiently now by poisoning our environment isn't a long term solution.
- refurb 6y agoBut he was wrong about the growth and therefore wrong about the consequences. Population is expected to peak and decline.
- corty 6y agoThe problem with that refutation is, population growth is O(2^n), available space is O(1) and available food is limited by available space and energy. Maybe there will be advances in science, increasing food production. However, to keep up with O(2^n) we need to double food production in constant time intervals, around 40 years. Otherwise, there will be overpopulation. There is no escaping it, except if exponential population growth is stopped and prevented in the future. And food production following an O(2^n) curve is highly improbable, the best we can imho do is something polynomial or linear. That's why Malthuus might have been a little wrong back then, but basic mathematics or computer science knowledge instantly proves him right, just not back then, because humanity got lucky.
- saddlerustle 6y ago> And food production following an O(2^n) curve is highly improbable, the best we can imho do is something polynomial or linear. Why? All technology has so far outpaced population growth.
- corty 6y agoMoore's law was famously exponential, until it wasn't, because there are physical limits. Grain per hectare made some noticeable jumps, but no growth or even negative growth due to organics. Limit now is probably what the ecosystem will bear, and that is something linear or constant. The reason why I think a polynomial is the best we can do is that some very special processes generate exponential behaviour, mostly stuff that is self-replicating. I don't see those in technology. Technology doesn't reproduce all by itself, it needs to be invented, financed, etc. Those are limits that force it subexponential.
- throwaway316943 6y ago> The problem with that refutation is, population growth is O(2^n) WTF, no it isn’t. Human population increased exponentially for a period of time while we adjusted to lower infant mortality but fertility rates quickly altered to account for the new situation. Humans aren’t rabbits, we don’t give birth in large litters and we can reason about and control the number of children we have. As the last few places on earth finish their journey through industrialization we’re going to see population stabilize and then decline. Set a reminder for 2050 when we’ll all be panicking about there not being enough young people to fund our social security.
- simplicio 6y agoPeople always say this, but it isn't true. Malthus lived in a time of quickly increasing productivity, he of course knew crop yields, etc. would likely increase. But he also knew there were eventual limits to that increase, the Earth only gets so many watts of solar energy, only has so much land area to cultivate, etc. So he thought that the exponential growth of human pop. would necessarily eventually hit those limits. Indeed, Malthus actually ages better then he's given credit for. His solution to the problem he poses is pretty close to the modern one, that a more educated and well-off population will decrease their fertility, so that eventually population growth will level off. (Malthus's actual view of the mechanism here is pretty Victorian, he talks a lot about "Public Morality" and I don't think he mentions "birth-control" in any form, but his basic idea is correct)