5 ms·
We're comparing two neighbourhoods. One has less deaths and less robberies. It is the one with nuclear power. Chernobyl has done less damage and had less impac
by roenxi 6y ago
We're comparing two neighbourhoods. One has less deaths and less robberies. It is the one with nuclear power.
Chernobyl has done less damage and had less impact on those millions of people than the totally routine burning of coal. I grew up in a coal mining region; I fully expect more people suffer negative health outcomes when coal works as expected than in a Class 7 nuclear catastrophe. We just don't count the health impacts properly because it is too hard to prove cause and effect.
The overwhelming safety of the nuclear process makes the failures look bad, because we aren't used to nuclear plants producing detectable levels of ambient pollution.
- paganel 6y ago> We just don't count the health impacts properly because it is too hard to prove cause and effect. This also goes for nuclear.
- MagnumOpus 6y agoThe "too hard to prove cause" is for attributing individual cases. In any particularly case - just like with the link of smoking and lung cancer - it is impossible to say if lung problems were caused by coal plants. Statistical estimates of the amounts of deaths and lung problems coal power plants cause, however, can be much more accurate. And they bespeak hundreds of thousands gruesome deaths from coal every year.
- _nalply 6y agoAccidents are bad but left-overs are even worse. I wish people would think more about long-term problems with spent fuel rods. I don't think that burying them is a viable solution as the Asse mine in Germany shows. https://www.dw.com/en/nuclear-waste-in-disused-german-mine-leaves-a-bitter-legacy/a-47420382 https://www.dw.com/en/nuclear-waste-in-disused-german-mine-l... The salt mine was deemed to be safe for thousands of years. But then people discovered ingress of water. And salt water is corrosive. I am sure that we will experience very expensive disasters with nuclear storage the next few thousand years. We should never have used nuclear power in large scale. Edit: And we should shut down coal, too. It's not about nuclear vs coal but nuclear vs renewables.
- beowulfey 6y agobut, if coal burning continues to pump out carbon dioxide into our atmosphere and eventually completely upend any semblance of stable environment... wouldn’t it be preferred to make not doing that a priority?
- _nalply 6y agoIt's not about nuclear vs coal but about nuclear vs renewables. Just shut down both coal and nuclear!
- sofixa 6y agoAnd what happens when there's a storm? Renewables alone can't provide all the power needed over extended periods of time without very significant storage, for which there is no large scale cost effective solution actually implemented.
- _nalply 6y agoNuclear power also shuts down when there's significant disruption from nature. Nuclear power even might do something even worse than shutting down.
- ohgodplsno 6y agoIt took a tsunami on an unmaintained nuclear power plant to cause Fukushima. It took the russians lifting off _every single security mechanism_ to cause Chernobyl. The ojer major incidents like Three Mile Island are just "well, security measures have failed, we didn't have enough fallbacks. It's broken now. Light irradiation around but nothing major". So, no, nuclear power doesn't stop for anything but the absolute worst conditions. As for the "doing even worse" part, two can play that game: hydro is renewable and yet killed hundreds of thousands. Oh no, stop hydro!
- _nalply 6y ago
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe WHO estimates that 4,200,000 people die every year from ambient air pollution. That’s one death every 7.5 seconds. That’s one Chernobyl death toll every 18 to 125 hours (depending on which estimate you’re looking at). The argument about land being uninhabitable is equally silly, because land permanently submerged in the ocean tends to be uninhabitable as well. The perception of the risks associated with nuclear is so dramatically misaligned with reality. The only conclusion I can possibly draw is that anybody who is anti-nuclear can’t possibly be taking climate change seriously.
- legulere 6y agoI’m not saying that nuclear is worse than coal (I don’t think so), but only that there are negative effects beyond death and that we should take them into account. The things we compare are nuclear and renewables. The consensus is already pretty clear that coal is on its way out. Which I think we all can agree on is a good thing.