3 ms·
> As a political move to advance the cause of memory-safe languages, as Alex Gaynor clearly intends†, this is obviously kind of a fiasco. On the contrary, I th
by lmm 6y ago
> As a political move to advance the cause of memory-safe languages, as Alex Gaynor clearly intends†, this is obviously kind of a fiasco.
On the contrary, I think this is a brilliant move; it's pulled C fans into a blatantly unreasonable position, making it clear how untenable their position is.
> As for Rust not supporting "weird architectures", are y'all serious about being the new contender or not? C isn't going to give up the title without an epic fight. Love it or hate it, to a first approximation C is programming.
Nonsense. Serious programmers (e.g. those doing it professionally) have already mostly moved on from C. Open-source is bound up with Linux and C for historical reasons, and also because the top mainstream languages were not open-source until recently, and so is disproportionately behind the times.
- WoodenChair 6y ago> Open-source is bound up with Linux and C for historical reasons, and also because the top mainstream languages were not open-source until recently, and so is disproportionately behind the times. The top mainstream languages (C, C++, Java, JavaScript, Python, C#, etc.) have all had at least one open source implementation for at least a decade. A decade is not a long time in the life of programming languages but it’s also not “recently.”
- lmm 6y agoI'll admit that GPLed Java is much older than I thought, but open-source C# was certainly not first-class until 2016, and IMO not really until late last year.
- WoodenChair 6y agoMono (open source implementation of C#) is much older than that.
- lmm 6y agoIndeed, but it was never first-class. A lot of libraries weren't available or didn't behave correctly.
- WoodenChair 6y agoThe original post said languages not “top implementation.”
- lmm 6y agoI said the languages "weren't open-source". The only reasonable interpretation of whether a language "is" open-source is whether it has first-class open-source implementations and tooling. Otherwise we'd say things like "Windows is open-source" because ReactOS exists.
- WoodenChair 6y agoPutting Mono in the same category as ReactOS is disingenuous at best. Mono was such a good open source implementation that Microsoft eventually bought company behind it and canonized it (Xamarin).
- lmm 6y agoMy experience was that you couldn't take a random C# project and run it on Mono and expect it to work. I don't want to diminish the technical effort that went into Mono, but it would be misleading to say that open-source C# worked without further qualifications.
- WoodenChair 6y agoKind of like it would be misleading to say that most popular programming languages were not open source until recently.
- lmm 6y ago
- lmm 6y agoI remembered the issue with Java; it's not really open-source because it's covered by patents that are only licensed for implementations substantially derived from OpenJDK.
- carapace 6y ago> Serious programmers (e.g. those doing it professionally) have already mostly moved on from C. Thank you for the LOL. It's been a rough day and I needed that. > On the contrary, I think this is a brilliant move; It is not. I commend to your attention Tao Te Ching, chapter 17. https://www.egreenway.com/taoism/ttclz17.htm https://www.egreenway.com/taoism/ttclz17.htm