3 ms·
If something is written pseudonymously, we can't possibly know whether it is a "left-wing case". It's just an argument. If you want that argument to be situate
by wpietri 6y ago
If something is written pseudonymously, we can't possibly know whether it is a "left-wing case". It's just an argument.
If you want that argument to be situated, given context and weight, then you at best need mediated anonymity, where a trusted source like a newspaper verifies pertinent context without exposing an actual identity. But there's good reason that's quite rare. So we end up pretty quickly back at people needing to own their words when they try to influence the public.
That's especially true on a topic like race in America. The most prominent people who wanted to intercede on race anonymously were the KKK. And they make especially clear why there's no broad moral obligation to preserve the anonymity of people trying to act publicly while concealing their identity.