8 ms·
> We’ve developed several anti-spoofing layers to make sure the system is secure. I don't believe this vague blanket claim. How much are you paying somebody wh
by tialaramex 6y ago
> We’ve developed several anti-spoofing layers to make sure the system is secure.
I don't believe this vague blanket claim. How much are you paying somebody who proves you wrong? A million dollars? No? Then I should assume anybody who can spoof this and would like a million dollars might do so unless the total value secured is assured to be less than one million dollars (in which case I expect this project will be gone by summer).
XIX ends up capturing a huge amount of facial recognition data and then storing it somewhere indefinitely in "the cloud" to inevitably get stolen and then no doubt we can expect a PR crafted apology and an insistence you've learned your lesson.
Every single time a person authenticates, video of their face is transmitted over the network. I have no doubt you'll say it's ephemeral and you don't store that video, but of course the users have no way to assure themselves of that, they just know they sent it.
Overall my impression is that this delivers markedly worse real world security than WebAuthn and has terrible privacy issues that can't be fixed.
- emilxix 6y agoSorry, you feel this way, mate, but matters of "believe" are between you and your priest. As for the "overall impressions", It is usually recommended to try something first and then form an impression. Otherwise, it's just an opinion
- sebmellen 6y agoYou know, I was very interested to hear how you’d respond, thinking you’d surely have substantive counterpoints or address the core argument. This is probably the worst response possible, and makes me believe GP is correct, because you don’t have any real response to their critiques.
- SheinhardtWigCo 6y agoThat’s not how this works. You’re claiming an incredible breakthrough: extremely high facial recognition accuracy using 2D input in an adversarial setting. Extraordinary claims require evidence.
- emilxix 6y agoAs I've mentioned earlier, we will be publishing in-depth results soon. Meanwhile, you can read here the review of public datasets https://medium.com/xix-ai/quantifying-the-inherent-bias-in-mainstream-facial-recognition-technology-e910a9b6001a https://medium.com/xix-ai/quantifying-the-inherent-bias-in-m... Overview on adversarial examples is below. The upcoming post will cover the approach, performance and comparison. Stay tuned
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AlotOfReading 6y agoWill this upcoming post address the storage and privacy concerns that were the main point of the GP?
- IgorPartola 6y agoHow can I try out seeing what exactly you store of the videos your receive to form an opinion? Also how can I try out what happens when you get subpoenaed by a government for facial data of specific users or all users?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Grustaf 6y agoThis is not something an individual can just form an impression on by themselves. It would take a large sample of people.
- futhey 6y agoI'm flabbergasted that any founder would respond like this. A lot of people who would have given you the benefit of the doubt just got the opposite impression of your company after reading this response.