3 ms·
Well, we also have 5 million/billion years to deal with those problems. Our descendents, if they are still using nuclear power, will be no dumber and less capab
by jerf 15y ago
Well, we also have 5 million/billion years to deal with those problems. Our descendents, if they are still using nuclear power, will be no dumber and less capable than we are of solving problems, and probably a great deal more so. If nothing else, "blast it into space" is likely to be feasible within our lifetimes. (And not just "leave it in orbit", but drop it somewhere where it won't be a problem anymore. Space is full of such places; space arguably is nothing but such places. Space is big.)
Besides, what massive problems are you worried about? On that timescale, radioactive waste just dissipates. It doesn't build up over millions of years. If it could build up over that time scale, it wouldn't be "radioactive" in the first place.
- brudgers 15y ago>"Our descendents" One of the potential issues which accompanies nuclear power is the "what descendents?" issue. Sterility and infertility and death are known side effects of exposure to common fissionable materials and their byproducts. One need not even consider the potential consequences of deliberate human activities designed to harm people or fulfill religious prophesy. In other words, it's not so much the last 4.99999 billion years that's a concern as the 1000 years which must precede them.
- pjscott 15y agoEr, that's why you don't go around exposing people to high-level radioactive waste. You stick it in a cooling pool to let the really nasty isotopes decay, then store it with radiation shielding. If you want to get really fancy, and have enough excess neutrons, you can even get rid of worst of the waste by turning it into something else. On the list of existential threats, mass radiation poisoning really doesn't rate very high in likelihood.
- brudgers 15y agoPU-239 has a half life of 24k years. Or to put it in perspective, if the Neanderthals had been using it, we would be running the risk of stumbling over cooling pools where significant quantities of nasty isotopes were still decaying - assuming anyone could build a cooling pool with a 24,000 year service life. The half lives of U235 and U233 are significantly longer (approx. an order of magnitude).
- pjscott 15y agoWait, what? Pu-239, U-235, and U-233 are not waste. They are fuel. Those are all fissile isotopes that we burn in conventional nuclear reactors. The isotopes you get rid of in cooling pools are the highly radioactive ones with short half-lives.
- jerf 15y agoI'm sorry, but that's so stupid I don't even know where to start. Radiation isn't a magical malevolent force. Your fears are so disconnected from the real world, you might as well be worried about aliens eating you for breakfast.
- brudgers 15y agoOf course radiation isn't magical - however the lack of political will is real. Among nations generating high level nuclear waste, there is an almost complete lack of progress toward long term storage - the politics around Yucca Mountain are typical, not the exception. As for the potential use of high-level nuclear waste for purposes other than the benevolent generation of energy, it is hardly necessary to point to the current level of security which nuclear nations strive to maintain around facilities storing such material. Your entire argument rests upon the premise that the people of the future (aka "our descendents") will discover and implement some technofix - my fear is that they will also have to discover and implement a different political system to do so. I will admit that, perhaps, Heinlein's vision of a technocratic government upon whose creation your argument depends is logically possible, no matter how unlikely it appears given the current state of the world. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-level_radioactive_waste_management http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-level_radioactive_waste_ma...]
- jerf 15y agoTechnofix? It's based on physics. On long time scales, radioactive waste doesn't build up. It decays. It's what it does. It is literally impossible to have a hundred-thousand-year-old pile of nuclear waste. We are also stipulating that they are still using nuclear power if we are talking about continuing to generate waste for that long. The window where they manage to use nuclear power for five million years, along with maintaining all of the associated infrastructure for mining, extracting, purifying, etc, and all the associated economic activity necessary to support any society that has that ability, but are somehow too stupid to solve the problem after many centuries, is an awfully narrow one. You're the one expecting civilization to fly through a bizarrely small window, not me.