3 ms·
Have you discussed this with Bill Gosper?
by gumby 6y ago
Have you discussed this with Bill Gosper?
- kragen 6y agoWhat the fuck is wrong with HN that this question, coming from a personal friend of Gosper's, gets downvoted into negative territory? Fuck this place.
- qzw 6y agoTake it easy there. It's only internet points, and it looks like gumby has plenty to spare. I didn't downvote, but to be fair to those who did, this item wasn't submitted by the blog author, so the question could come across as misdirected.
- gumby 6y agoIt’s interesting that HN discourages discussion of this topic. On one hand i suppose it can lead to whining by people whose posts didn’t do well (but does that ever actually happen on other fora?) OTOH this kind of meta discussion (in any context, online and real space) helps direct conversation in a coherent fashion.
- dang 6y agoIt's just stochastic. A few raindrops always fall in weird places. Short comments in particular admit many (mis)interpretations simply because they contain less information and leave more degrees of freedom for the interpreter to fill in. For a sufficiently wide spectrum of readers, lots of these different (mis)interpretations will get activated as the same comment lands with different receivers. Some will lead to downvotes. Some of those downvotes will seem perverse and inexplicable. Different readers have completely different priors. You happened to know that gumby is a friend of Gosper—that naturally collapsed the space of meanings down to a narrow and obvious range of interpretation. But it's not hard to see how a totally different range might (wrongly) occur to someone with different priors. For all we know they thought the comment was putting down Gosper while they were trying to defend him...one thing I've learned from moderating is that it's impossible to predict all interpretations. It's astonishing how unpredictably the same comment can land with different readers. Yet all of this is exactly what one would expect from a stochastic process and enough datapoints. Usually, fair-minded users see that a comment has been unfairly downvoted and give a corrective upvote (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=corrective%20upvote https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...), and it is is usually enough to fix the problem. That happened here.