3 ms·
> Accessing the file system is a constant hassle. Why so hard? Apple prioritise the user at the expense of the developer. I think this is the right balance. >
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> Accessing the file system is a constant hassle. Why so hard?
Apple prioritise the user at the expense of the developer. I think this is the right balance.
> I cannot install emacs on my Mac.
What's stopping you?
> Software that is free (as in GNU) is charged for in the App store.
I don't think this is in conflict with the spirit of the GNU project? Paying for software distribution is fine in the eyes of the GNU project and their licence. What's your problem with it?
> I am amazed that they care so little for those who are not quite the most important.
Apple think normal users are the most important, not developers. I think they're probably right.
- smoldesu 6y agoLast month I heard people saying that Apple thinks normal users are more important than graphic designers, and the month before that I heard people claiming that we shouldn't worry about Parallels support because "normal users" don't need it. At this point, I'm not even convinced there is a normal user.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIf you prioritised developers over everyone else... who do you think the developers would be developing for?
- _qulr 6y agoIt's ironic that Apple is also preaching "Everyone Can Code". In other words, everyone is or can be a power user. Computers are becoming more and more essential to our lives, so deliberately dumbing them down is a disservice to everyone, who should be learning more not less about how computers work. My dad was in sales. My first exposure to computers was when he bought an Apple II way back in the day. He used VisiCalc, naturally, the "killer app" for the Apple II. Was he a "power user" or a "normal person"? I'd say both!
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhy does a coder have to be a 'power user'? Why can't the applications needed for coding be like any other normal application? You don't need to use esoteric stuff like emacs to be a coder.
- smoldesu 6y agoWhy does a coder have to use Apple's tools? Why can't the applications needed for coding be like any other normal application? You don't need to use proprietary software like xCode to be a coder.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Why does a coder have to use Apple's tools? A coder doesn't have to do anything. They don't have to use a Mac, they don't have to use Apple's tools. Apple provides an ecosystem. Coding tools can fit into that ecosystem, or they can whine about it, or they can leave it. > Why can't the applications needed for coding be like any other normal application? They are - install them like a word processor or a graphics editor or whatever. > You don't need to use proprietary software like xCode to be a coder. Who said you did? You also don't need to use emacs. And it's Xcode, not 'xCode'. The point is - Apple make it easy to code - the provide XCode. Saying 'but why not emacs' is entirely missing the point on what they're trying to do.
- smoldesu 6y agoSeems we're in agreement then. My point wasn't that you shouldn't develop on MacOS, but that it won't fit my needs or workflow. If Apple is disinterested in supporting that, then I'm not interested in supporting them. Why would I pay a premium to use an operating system that can't run software my free OS can?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Why would I pay a premium to use an operating system that can't run software my free OS can? Because you don't need all that software if your goal is to 'code'. If your goal is to run some specific ancient text editor then yeah you may struggle. If you want to code and get something done it's the right platform. And because the 'normal' things are 10x better - power management, touchpad, display driving, etc. Do you want to spend your time creating, or time trying to make basic display scaling work on Linux? And why are they better? Because Apple integrates.
- smoldesu 6y agoI'd like to propose an amendment to their catchphrase, maybe you all can offer some feedback? "Everyone Can Code* *Unless you have a 128gb SSD."
- andrekandre 6y ago> At this point, I'm not even convinced there is a normal user. i think the right word is maybe "consumers" instead of "users"... the thing is, ipad and ios are fine for those use cases (super locked down, "safe", limited capabilities, better revenue funnel etc), dumbing down macos to get those users just hurts the macs value proposition imo
- skynet-9000 6y ago> Apple prioritise the user at the expense of the developer. I think this is the right balance. Not for the developer.
- craftinator 6y ago> Apple prioritise the user at the expense of the developer. I think this is the right balance. This assumes the user does no development, which is becoming less and less true over time. Computers are tools, people use them for stuff, and as the generations that didn't grow up with them die off, the ones that did are actually using them for more than just cat videos. Also, nerfing the development experience means LESS development, which means less software and fewer bug fixes, which means a worse user experience. Gotta bootstrap starting from the boots.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]