11 ms·
> School Committee member Lorna Rivera said at a January meeting that she was disturbed by the findings, noting that nearly 60 percent of fourth graders in the
by rayiner 6y ago
> School Committee member Lorna Rivera said at a January meeting that she was disturbed by the findings, noting that nearly 60 percent of fourth graders in the program at the Ohrenberger school in West Roxbury are white even though most third graders enrolled at the school are Black and Hispanic.
> "This is just not acceptable," Rivera said at a recent school committee meeting. "I've never heard these statistics before, and I'm very very disturbed by them."
I’m not sold on gifted education to begin with. It’s a complicated issue for sure, with pluses and minuses. But suspending gifted education programs expressly based on the racial makeup of the kids in the program is illegal discrimination, plain and simple.
- threatofrain 6y ago> But suspending gifted education programs expressly based on the racial makeup of the kids in the program is illegal discrimination, plain and simple. Just running the program is a legal risk.
- loveistheanswer 6y agoWere the students selected for the advanced program selected based on the color of their skin, or their academic ability?
- superflit 6y agoYou can't ask it in 2021. It is wrong think and hate speech. Please go back to re-education camp.
- snicksnak 6y agoNo that's essentially the core of the issue. If they were selected based on their race, it's racial discrimination. If the classes were suspended based on the student's race, it's racial discrimination, plain and simple.
- ttt0 6y ago> plain and simple Unfortunately it's not in 2021.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into ideological flamewar. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- _-david-_ 6y agoIt would only be a legal risk if they were putting kids in the program based on race. This does not seem to be the case. It just so happens to be that a disproportionate amount of whites and Asians made it into the program.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoWhy do you conclude that it doesn’t seem to be the case? There are a ton of known second-order causes of education inequality like redlining, tax disparities, etc. It’s highly likely that the disparities in this program happen because of racism, even if no one sat down and said “we should admit mostly white and Asian kids”.
- _-david-_ 6y agoThere is no evidence that there was any racism involved. I wouldn't say with 100% certainty there was no racism, but until anyone can show any evidence of racism I will not jump to that conclusion. There is a perfectly logical (and non-racist) reason for blacks and Hispanics to not make it into the gifted program as frequently as their white and Asian peers and that is they, in average, have lower grades. People see the outcome is disproportionate and assume racism. Instead of looking at the evidence to see why it happened they look at the outcome and try to fit their preferred narrative into it. If there is racism which causes students to have a difficult life which then causes them to do worse in school and doing worse in school means the student won't be accepted into the gifted program then I do not consider the gifted program admission to be racist. The solution should be to help those in a bad situation (regardless if it was caused by racism or something else) so anybody who is disadvantaged can be on an equal playing field and meet the requirements. There are a lot of poor white students. They likely struggle in school because of that. I don't think the solution would be to make it easier for those poor whites to make it into the gifted program just because they are poor. And yet many people would make that argument for blacks and Hispanics. Removing the gifted program because you don't like the races who make it in is racist.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago
- 762236 6y agoI'm sold on gifted education.
- softwaredoug 6y agoI’m not sold. It can at least sound like a statement the school will invest more in some kids than others. At least that what it can sound like outside the gifted bubble. Probably the solution is to have high standards for all students and classes they all can participate in.
- bko 6y agoI think its more about segmenting based on aptitude and interest. The gifted classes consist of children that can move at a quicker pace with less distraction. I don't think its about giving more resources to that set of children, but be able to alter the curriculum to challenge them more.
- sgeisenh 6y agoDifferent students have different needs. It doesn't make sense to provide the same experience to every student. Homogenizing the experience is a disservice to all students, not just the gifted.
- rendall 6y ago> "It can at least sound like a statement the school will invest more in some kids than others." Which side of the bell curve do you think gets more investment dollars? Left or right?
- Anon1096 6y ago>It can at least sound like a statement the school will invest more in some kids than others. Schools already do this ever since No Child Left Behind. It's just in the opposite direction. Kids below the average get far far more money than the median student. Why not have gifted classes as well to support those who excel?
- 6y ago
- chickenfries 6y agoI was with you initially, but after thinking about it could be argued that creating classes that are overwhelmingly white in an overwhelmingly non white district are something approaching segregation. In the end, all that is being done to the “advanced” students is that they’re being offered the same education that their peers are getting. Resources spent on the advanced learning program could have been spent on offering a better quality of education for the entire school. I’m sympathetic to both sides of this issue but I don’t find it simple.
- rayiner 6y agoIt’s not segregation because the school doesn’t place students in these classes based on their skin color. Oftentimes these disparities arise from communities being economically mixed along racial lines. It’s not even the case that these economic disparities arise from what’s called “systemic racism.” In urban school districts many kids are immigrants or children of immigrants, and have lesser economic circumstances because of recent migration. Treating them differently based on skin color doesn’t help erase some historical injustice. For example, Bangladeshi Americans, a group I belong to, have a household income in New York City much lower than whites. Indian Americans, by contrast, have incomes much higher than whites. These disparities aren’t due to differing effects of “racism” but recency of immigration and characteristics of the immigrants. This is true for Latinos as well. They have lower incomes now because a large number are recent economic migrants. But their incomes are converging with those of white people over time: https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353 https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/135/2/711/5687353. (In fact, after three generations, half of Latinos don’t even identify as such.) The data shows that, apart from Black and Native American people, other ethnic groups in the US are similarly situated to how Polish people, Italians, etc., were during the early 20th century. Or how Cubans or Vietnamese were in the later 20th century. They’re in the process of economic integration. It’s not a situation where government discrimination is required now to erase the effects of past government discrimination. For similar reasons, it makes no sense to discriminate between kids based on race to address present (rather than systemic) economic disparities. For purposes of dismantling gifted programs and test-based admissions, whites and Asians are typically lumped together. But in NYC, for example, most Asian kids in the gifted programs are actually fairly poor, because they’re the children of recent immigrants. It’s irrational to lump them together with whites in the “advantaged” group.
- axaxs 6y agoI can only speak for myself, and my experience as a rather low income kid in the public school system. Without advanced learning, I'd have learned at a much slower pace and felt held back and bored. I started in regular classes, and the amount of disruptors and time teachers spent babysitting was absolutely absurd. Luckily I was able to be placed in advanced classes, and all that disappeared. As for curriculum, we were doing calc 2 while the standard classes ended at about an intro to trig, for example. I don't know how to fix the disparity, and unfairness, if it exists. But please don't throw out the whole program.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwawaysea 6y agoThese days no one is ready to talk about cultural and behavioral differences that lead to different outcomes, but it is the most obvious cause of disparities in education and career success between ethnicities. The reason policies like affirmative action or gutting gifted education are discrimination to me, is that students from certain backgrounds are being punished for their cultural and behavioral differences. For example, most Asian cultures emphasize a focus on hard work, academic success, respect for your elders, etc. Anyone who has spent any time in the American schooling system knows that Asian students have remarkably different behavioral patterns from white or black American students. They make choices that lead to their success, and now they’re being discriminated against by those claiming there are “too many” successful Asians. A similar argument can be constructed for other groups. Heather Mac Donald wrote about behavioral contributors to disparities and other issues stemming from a societal overfocus on diversity in The Diversity Delusion (https://us.macmillan.com/thediversitydelusion/heathermacdonald/9781250200914 https://us.macmillan.com/thediversitydelusion/heathermacdona...). You can read a brief contribution from her regarding behavioral drivers of socioeconomic disparities (like crime rates) at https://www.newsweek.com/if-systemic-racism-real-why-does-biden-want-bring-immigrants-here-opinion-1565688 https://www.newsweek.com/if-systemic-racism-real-why-does-bi....
- ipnon 6y agoThe 30% of black and Hispanic students who were already in Boston's gifted program by virtue of their intelligence are now also going to be discriminated against in order to pack the advanced classes with their less intelligent peers. This will push the black and Hispanic students already qualified for the program out.
- paleotrope 6y agoAnd the white and asian parents will probably pay for alternatives while the black and hispanic kids probably won't have that option. It really is the worse outcome here.