3 ms·
> Except, small businesses can still advertise to their customers. They can still use all of the information Facebook knows about its users--like their gender,
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
> Except, small businesses can still advertise to their customers. They can still use all of the information Facebook knows about its users--like their gender, age, location, and interests, to show ads. If you're a small business, none of that changes. The only person that really stands to lose seems to be Facebook.
I'm not sure that is true:
Facebook would argue that with tracking users interests are better understood. A small model railway business can advertise to people who aren't just members of facebook railway groups and visit railway pages on facebook but also those who are visiting model railway websites outside of facebook too (that have FB tracking pixels). When people are visiting websites reviewing a new engine and start clicking on that businesses adverts for the engine, FB will show the ad to more of people who have visited those webpages too, making the ad more cheaper as you're not competing with other ad purchasers.
[EDIT] I'll still be saying no to facebook tracking.
- chokeartist 6y ago> When people are visiting websites reviewing a new engine and start clicking on that businesses adverts for the engine, FB will show the ad to more of people who have visited those webpages too, making the ad more cheaper as you're not competing with other ad purchasers. I don't care. They can take their entire immoral business model and fuck themselves to the graveyard. Next.
- mgreg 6y agoWhy couldn't facebook instead facilitate that same small model railway business advertising on the railway group pages, and non-facebook pages about model railways? Why not just tie the ads to the content of the page visited? With targeting you're correct that facebook (and others) can instead follow the user around the internet and show them (perhaps) relevant ads on sites that may be cheaper to advertise on (e.g. some crappy link-bait / SEO built site) which may be more effective than an ad otherwise shown on _that_ click-bait site but perhaps less effective than a railway ad shown on a railway related website. Facebook can transfer revenue from the higher quality site on railway topics to lower quality sites that may just be click-bait and capture nearly all that difference for themselves. Bottom line is you de-fund high quality sites (railway hobbyist sites in this example) and encourage surveilling individuals for only facebook's benefit.
- kapp_in_life 6y ago> Why couldn't facebook instead facilitate that same small model railway business advertising on the railway group pages, and non-facebook pages about model railways? Why not just tie the ads to the content of the page visited? Because google adsense has already effectively captured that market.
- mgreg 6y agoThis is a bit of a red herring but I'll reply anyway. Agreed that adsense serves ads to 'open web' properties already. However they do this with user tracking, just like facebook already does. The suggestion above is to instead use contextual ad targeting. Secondly - adsnese has no access to facebook's walled garden hence facebook could exclusively served contextually relevant ads on its own highly trafficked sites free from competition. Thirdly - what's wrong with competition? facebook has the scale, relationships with publishers and advertisers, and technology. They could, if they wanted to, take a page from Apple and compete on the concept of privacy if their brand wasn't so tarnished by their insistence that they surveil their users. Back to the core point - facebook and others facilitate transfer revenue from high quality sites (railway hobbyist sites in this example) and encourage surveilling individuals for only facebook's benefit.
- addicted 6y agoGoogle Adsense didn’t always used to do with user tracking. Adsenses original business model, heck, Google’s original business model, had nothing to do with user tracking. In fact, it was possible to share links with people (at least locally) by simply telling someone to search for a specific keyword and look halfway down the results on the 2nd page. It’s kind of amazing to me that it’s now become ingrained that advertising must involve user tracking when even 15 years ago companies like Google did almost no tracking at all.
- jefftk 6y ago>* adsense serves ads to 'open web' properties already. However they do this with user tracking, just like facebook already does.* nit: AdSense does both contextual and personalized advertising. It launched as contextual only, and that is still part of what it's doing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_AdSense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_AdSense (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)
- bluesign 6y agoProblem with targeted advertisement is not tracking part, problem is abusing with this tracking. All ad networks are showing you ads that are more like likely to profit them, not what you are most likely to be click. So basically it is some Expected Value from the impression. if I am 1% chance to click some ad, but they are paying 20x more than the ad with 10% chance, you will see this low quality ad first. Why they would pay same guy's impression 20x more? Cause they are trying to target some vulnerability there. Things are worse than you can imagine, with targeted advertisement you can: - advertise some weight loss scam to be people who are not confident about their body ( or you can even advertise them candies ) - advertise them dropshipping items with huge margins ( cause you can afford to bid 10x for their impressions ) - advertise your partner about interest area before xmas with inflated prices ( if you have motorbike, they can advertise your SO with "best accessories for bikers" with inflated prices ) Basically targeted advertisement is not about showing us the most relevant ad, it is about making the profit from the impression.
- nojito 6y agoThat type of targeting doesn’t even work. A study showed that it was barely 40% accurate for some breakouts. https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/pdf/10.1287/mksc.2019.1188 https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/pdf/10.1287/mksc.2019.118...