4 ms·
> Can someone explain to me why Signal is so very bad compared to telegram? The Signal desktop app is Electron, where as Telegram is native. That's why and it'
by rvz 6y ago
> Can someone explain to me why Signal is so very bad compared to telegram?
The Signal desktop app is Electron, where as Telegram is native. That's why and it's that simple.
- dewey 6y agoThere's non-native apps that are not as bad as Signal so that doesn't really explain that.
- metachris 6y agoThat's certainly not the reason. There are many really good Electron applications, Visual Studio Code being one of them.
- fouc 6y agoVisual Studio Code is literally the only good Electron application, the rare exception that proves the rule.
- Griffinsauce 6y agoGitKraken, Insomnia, Postman, Mongo Compass, Mingo, Mockoon, Notion (yes it's slow AF to load, but that's not due to electron), LosslessCut, Gitify
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoNo, it's not that simple at all. The Signal desktop app is bad in ways that have nothing to do with Electron at all. Most importantly, it's bad at protecting my privacy. You can't show any message to anyone on your screen or have someone look over your shoulder unless you want them to see who you recently communicated with in what order as well as the start of the most recent messages.
- primeos 6y ago> unless you want them to see who you recently communicated with in what order as well as the start of the most recent messages. Thanks for mentioning that. I always wondered why there's no option to at least hide the most recent messages and dates (or temporarily hide the whole sidebar). I guess most people are either fine with it or use their phone instead (and using Signal-Desktop in public / when someone's looking is probably uncommon). It seems like at least Telegram-Desktop has this issue as well (not sure if there's an option for it). Anyway, a slight modification to the UI to hide/minimize the sidebar would be something I'd appreciate for those rare situations.
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoI think it's a pretty common situation for someone to come up to your desk to talk about something they sent you earlier. Not rare for me at all.
- Kelteseth 6y agoTelegram desktop is a Qt Widgets application.
- dgellow 6y agoIf you're on macOS you have the choice between a native app and the QT client. Native: https://macos.telegram.org/ https://macos.telegram.org/ Qt client: https://desktop.telegram.org/ https://desktop.telegram.org/
- kitsunesoba 6y agoThere’s also an unofficial native Windows 10 + Xbox client: https://github.com/UnigramDev/Unigram https://github.com/UnigramDev/Unigram In addition, there’s a libpurple plugin should one want to use Telegram with Pidgin, as well as several other clients including one that’s TUI based. The choice of client is a massive boon. It’s unfortunate that one can’t use a alternative Signal clients, because they’d likely solve many of the gripes people have with Signal.