2 ms·
A good rejoinder to that is from theories of procedural democracy. A press that is neutral as to partisanship is perceived within the overall political framewor
by rayiner 6y ago
A good rejoinder to that is from theories of procedural democracy. A press that is neutral as to partisanship is perceived within the overall political framework as being fair, which has the very positive effect of engendering trust in the institution. It’s the same reason why judges and courts strive to avoid the perception of substantive bias.
Politics must be divorced from “its real-world effects” because people of different political persuasions disagree about what real-world effects policies will have (or whether some effects outweigh other effects). A liberal reporting neutral facts about say a proposed immigration policy is still useful to a conservative. A liberal’s take on what they think will be “the real-world effects” of a proposed policy (at least, the ones they care about) will not be useful.
- lazulicurio 6y ago> It’s the same reason why judges and courts strive to avoid the perception of substantive bias. I see the point that you're trying to make, but I'll also turn it on it's head: when a judge makes a ruling does that mean that they were "biased" in favor of the winning party? > Politics must be divorced from “its real-world effects” Does a judge ignore the "real-world effects" of their orders and only consider the behavior of the lawyers? > A liberal’s take on what they think will be “the real-world effects” of a proposed policy (at least, the ones they care about) will not be useful. Is a liberal judge's reasoning in an opinion not valuable to a conservative judge?