5 ms·
> Two weeks after the Cotton controversy, the Times published an essay by Wesley Lowery, a Pulitzer Prize–winning black reporter, titled “A Reckoning over Objec
by rayiner 6y ago
> Two weeks after the Cotton controversy, the Times published an essay by Wesley Lowery, a Pulitzer Prize–winning black reporter, titled “A Reckoning over Objectivity, Led by Black Journalists.” Equating objectivity with “whiteness,” Lowery called for “moral clarity, which will require both editors and reporters to stop doing things like reflexively hiding behind euphemisms to obfuscate the truth.” The Trump administration and the Republican Party, Lowery urged, should be labeled as what they are: a “refuge to white supremacist rhetoric and policies.” In the post-Bennet moment of post-journalism, editors at the paper were inclined to agree.
Traditional liberals that think it’s just Republican ideas that will be denounced as pernicious “whiteness” are in for a rude surprise. I saw this quite starkly this summer. Liberal city dwellers in Chicago and Philadelphia discretely texting me pictures of cars on fire outside their neighborhoods, but being too afraid to say anything openly. It seems to have passed, but for a spell, near-universal beliefs about the necessity for order in a civil society became something many were too afraid to support for fear of being lumped together with Trump supporters.
- mc32 6y agoMuch of the rhetoric and power plays echo of the tactics used by socialists (communists) to divide populations (rural vs urban, intellectual vs illiterate, landed vs serf, etc) but to their credit they had a clear objective (to win at all costs) BUT they also had an endgame. They didn’t let this eat themselves (Mao did play with fire here). And once they won, all that nonsense went out the window, the dumb idealist ideologues got the hard boot and everyone else followed or pretended to follow the new realideology to survive. It’s like they don't read history.
- nerdponx 6y agoI'd encourage you to read my sibling post. It's common knowledge that the "objectivity" practiced by reporters is anything but; but as soon as someone dares to specify that the so-called objective perspective also happens to be white, all of a sudden they're being equated with Mao†. If that's not "white fragility", I don't know what is. †You're saying Mao played with fire, but you're not acknowledging the other differences between Mao (slaughtered millions of people) and these so-called socialists (who just want racism to end).
- nerdponx 6y agoPlease read the essay [0] before reacting to some out-of-context quotes. The essay is about the problem wherein "objectivity" is itself not an objective thing, but wherein the hegemony opinion is taken as fact. Let me extract a relevant passage for you: > Since American journalism’s pivot many decades ago from an openly partisan press to a model of professed objectivity, the mainstream has allowed what it considers objective truth to be decided almost exclusively by white reporters and their mostly white bosses. And those selective truths have been calibrated to avoid offending the sensibilities of white readers. On opinion pages, the contours of acceptable public debate have largely been determined through the gaze of white editors. > The views and inclinations of whiteness are accepted as the objective neutral. When black and brown reporters and editors challenge those conventions, it’s not uncommon for them to be pushed out, reprimanded or robbed of new opportunities. Another passage: > For years, I’ve been among a chorus of mainstream journalists who have called for our industry to abandon the appearance of objectivity as the aspirational journalistic standard, and for reporters instead to focus on being fair and telling the truth, as best as one can, based on the given context and available facts. And: > And so, instead of promising our readers that we will never, on any platform, betray a single personal bias — submitting ourselves to a life sentence of public thoughtlessness — a better pledge would be an assurance that we will devote ourselves to accuracy, that we will diligently seek out the perspectives of those with whom we personally may be inclined to disagree and that we will be just as sure to ask hard questions of those with whom we’re inclined to agree. > The best of our profession already does this. But we need to be honest about the gulf that lies between the best and the bulk. And: > It’s been more than 50 years since the first black journalists appeared in mainstream American newsrooms. For all of that time, black journalists have made meager demands: Please hire some more of us. Please pay us the way you do our colleagues. Please allow us to ascend to leadership roles. Please consider our opinions about how accurate and fair coverage of all communities, especially our own, can be achieved. > Collectively, the industry has responded to generations of black journalists with indifference at best and open hostility at its frequent worst. Finally, as for the claim that the Republican party is a "refuge to white supremacist rhetoric and policies"... well, it is. Does that mean Republicans are all inherently racist? Of course not. But since the 00s, the % of racist Republicans has increased compared to the % of racist Democrats [1], although racism seems to be generally declining under both parties. Anecdotally, Republicans tend to favor non-interventionist domestic policy, which in turn tends to allow the end products of racism (urban poverty, discrimination) to continue. Also anecdotally, the people I know who are the least interested in undoing the evils caused by slavery and segregation are also the most Republican. It's not overtly "white supremacist", but it is absolutely a failure to acknowledge just how evil and harmful the historical white supremacism of the USA really was... and that's just talking about the evils levied on the descendants of African slaves. We'll have to discuss the overt genocide of Native Americans another time. Edit: the author goes into detail about the Cotton editorial situation as well. You might be surprised to learn that there can be multiple perspectives on a situation. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/23/opinion/objectivity-black-journalists-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/23/opinion/objectivity-black... [1]: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/are-white-republicans-more-racist-than-white-democrats/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/are-white-republicans-m...
- coolgeek 6y ago> Liberal city dwellers in Chicago and Philadelphia discretely texting me pictures of cars on fire outside their neighborhoods I'm a long-time urban Philadelphia resident who spent almost the entirety of the unrest this past summer listening to police scanners on Broadcastify (except when they were blocked). I also consumed almost all available (edit: local) media coverage. I read r/philadelphia at least daily. The only automobile arsons I am at all aware of during these periods were of police cars. There were indeed several of them, over an extended period of time. But I am not aware of any private vehicle arsons. Even building arsons weren't very common. They were almost always done in a moronic attempt to hide evidence of other crimes (e.g. looting). So how many people in Philadelphia texted you pictures of cars on fire? Whose cars were they? What neighborhoods were they outside of? When did these acts of arson occur?
- rayiner 6y agoThe cars on fire were in Chicago. Arsons were up 65% in Chicago in 2020: https://chicago.suntimes.com/2021/2/26/22300843/chicago-burned-arson-fires-insurance-fraud https://chicago.suntimes.com/2021/2/26/22300843/chicago-burn.... I don't know why you think police vehicles don't count. 8 government vehicles were set on fire in just one day in Chicago last summer. And it wasn't just cars (which I'm just using as an example): > Dozens of convenience stores and retail shops were hit by arsonists, along with five department stores, five groceries, two churches, a currency exchange, a car dealership, a bank, a bar, a barbershop, a carwash and a drugstore. Most of those fires were set on May 31 and June 1.
- coolgeek 6y agoWhy are you answering my questions about Philadelphia with a link and a quote about Chicago? I directly quoted your comment. You said "Liberal city dwellers in ... Philadelphia discretely texting me pictures of cars on fire outside their neighborhoods" That quote can only be read as suggesting that multiple random vehicles were set on fire. If you meant police cars, why didn't you say that? Why would anyone anywhere have to "discretely" text you photos of a burning cop car? It was widely covered - live, in real time - by local and national media!