3 ms·
> Real options improve expected outcomes! And sometimes they don't. The biggest problem with ALL of these advocates for the "non-trial protocols" is that they
by bsder 6y ago
> Real options improve expected outcomes!
And sometimes they don't.
The biggest problem with ALL of these advocates for the "non-trial protocols" is that they want to violate the protocol but nobody wants to put the processes in place to keep an eye out for if something goes wrong.
Read that again: None of the "first doses first" are considering that they might be wrong. And, correspondingly, they have no signals or systems to watch for that.
Okay, this is one thing that ALL the trials did that you want to short circuit. And that's not cool.
For example, what happens if the single dose effects allow a subgroup of people to carry the virus asymptomatically? Oops. You created an immune variant that will evolve to evade all the vaccines as well as lots of spreaders who don't know it.
The human body is stupidly unique and you can get really weird effects. This is why we have trials.
Derek Lowe (https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/ https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/) pointed this out earlier: "first doses first" vs "cache for second doses" has no medical justification--but you're going to have to make a choice anyway. And it's a shitty choice to have to make.
But that's okay. Such is life, you sometimes go with what you have and not what you want--just don't cloak it as a medical decision because you aren't backed by the data. And you have to understand that you might be wrong and you have to have something in place to watch for that.
- maxerickson 6y agoMany of the earliest voices were calling for single dose trials in December, not just going off trial and doing one dose. I guess you can elide them from your "first doses first" group, but that kind of undermines the whole criticism.
- bsder 6y agoSure. But that trial takes time and money to run. And you know that the results are going to be inferior. So, the trial is of limited value once you have enough vaccine. This is the kind of thing that the federal government should have stepped in and funded (one-off, unprofitable, time-limited). But, in the US, you had a boorish asshat and his seditious bootlickers in charge who promulgated that Covid was a hoax. You were not going to get something so useful funded by them.