5 ms·
It's only speculative, right? I'm happy artists get paid but I still don't get why you would pay to be the "owner" of a digital art piece. Anyone can see and do
by dgellow 6y ago
It's only speculative, right? I'm happy artists get paid but I still don't get why you would pay to be the "owner" of a digital art piece. Anyone can see and download the art. Who cares who is registered as the owner it if it's free to have an exact copy?
- redm 6y ago"A true fan is defined as a fan that will buy anything you produce. These diehard fans will drive 200 miles to see you sing; they will buy the hardback and paperback and audible versions of your book; they will purchase your next figurine sight unseen; they will pay for the “best-of” DVD version of your free YouTube channel; they will come to your chef’s table once a month." I think the point is, people are fans so they want to collect and have a pride of ownership.
- koonsolo 6y agoI think baseball cards is the best comparison. People pay this much because it's official, it's a collectors item. You could make a nice color copy, but it will not be the same, even if the copy is hard to distinguish. The world is moving to digital. Kids play with digital things more than with physical. So how can you own a digital collectors item? Best solution seems NFT.
- bastawhiz 6y agoIf the actual collector's item is freely available and all you get is your name listed as having paid for it, you're not really "collecting" so much as showing that you paid money for each item. If I collect stamps, it's fun to show off your stamp collection because you have those stamps. It's different if everyone can also have all of those stamps, and the hobby is reduced down to "I have these stamps and also my name is on the blockchain next to each of them". There's no physical scarcity for the stamps, there's scarcity for your name being listed as a buyer in a ledger. Call me old fashioned, but that seems to suck the fun out of it.
- seibelj 6y agoThe physical world collectibles will have NFTs associated, allowing the best of both worlds.
- bastawhiz 6y agoWhy would they? It seems to defeat the purpose. You can sell the item in the real world without the NFT. The uniqueness of the item is implicit in its physical form. If you did sell the item again with an NFT, there's nothing really mandating that you actually turn the item over to the new owner. The NFT has no material connection to the item, so it doesn't even provide verifiable provenance.
- CodeShmode 6y agoYou could also sell a certificate of authenticity without an artwork, but why would you?
- bastawhiz 6y agoMaybe I lost the physical artwork and I'm selling it to a forger. Exactly nothing ties an NFT to the real world object it is associated with.
- amorriscode 6y agoYou do have it like you have any other digital clout (likes on an Instagram post for example). Perhaps with younger generations spending more and more time on digital devices, proving you have something in a digital wallet is just as good as owning the physical thing. Maybe it's even better. I struggle to see the value (some CryptoPunks are going for outrageous prices). That being said, I think we are early days. I find these types of innovations to be interesting and want to see where it goes.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoYou're missing the social component. Even if you don't have a tangible good, you can still signal that you are apart of a group by buying an NFT. NFTs are basically about buying status in a community.
- baby 6y agoI like the baseball card analogy because it's not an analogy, it's a concept. Baseball cards were never a thing around me, but Pokemon cards were, and people would pay true money for these useless things, so why not NFTs?
- jsemrau 6y agoNothing says decentralizing finance like artificially restricting the existence of digital object. Of course, this statement is a bit smug, but while I caved in to the FOMO and bought some Ada could before the Mary Hard Fork, I have yet a real world use case for any of the coins. If there would be a wallet filled with credits where I can gift / tip creators for their work independent of their bank | location | currency, this would be an amazing use case.
- jcfrei 6y agoThen why do people buy paintings? They could just own a photograph. Don't tell me it's because they appreciate the subtle brush strokes or the smell of the oil paint. It's because they want their name to be associated with a great artist. Because in the halls of MoMA in New York it will say painting by Jackson Pollock on permanent loan by <insert name of your foundation>.
- paul_f 6y agoComparing an original painting to a photograph of the painting is the exact issue the OP is making. They are asking why people would pay for a photo, when anyone could have the same photo. There is no original, scarce painting to own. Just all identical copies.
- pxue 6y ago"Original" doesn't really exist in the digital native world. Data is literally copied when it gets distributed. Maybe think of NFT as a pointer to the head of a link list, the start of the data distribution chain. And we assign some arbitrary monetary value to that pointer, because, well, there's only 1 head of a link list.
- Qworg 6y agoYes! Currently, NFTs lack a stage - I can't imagine deriving the same level of MoMA association with "Owned by jcfrei (0x859128479178571823784)" when I got to a webpage.
- vmception 6y agoI can. And that already happens. When prestigious institutions are involved you'll be able to check their addresses and signatures too. It is more about the transfer and hypothecation of value, which this scarcity and transparency allows. If it doesn't catch on it doesn't catch on. Right now people are clamoring for this future.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoThe stage is the community which the NFT is related to.
- vmception 6y agoit is the same as any collectible, there is a market of people that like originals, except now there is a greater assurance of it being the original, primarily because of the earlier block/timestamp compared to a duplicate NFT which would therefore not hold its value, and the non-NFT versions of the art has no transaction so they do not store value. This assurance is accessible to any creator or collector. a whole industry of appraisers and committees now gone. yay. automatic ability to pay royalties to the artist upon resale just built in, no contracts or enforcement of contracts necessary. no trust involved for lower value works where everyone is unfamiliar with contracts and lawyers. more efficient market available to all.
- africanboy 6y ago> there is a market of people that like originals, except now there is a greater assurance of it being the original for it to have some value there must be consensus around it. if I have the same exact copy of the digital art and I am selling it in a market that does not recognize NFT as proof (think about China that doesn't even recognize patents) what value does this hold? or if two competing entities are both claiming to have emitted the one true token, which one do I trust? we are thinking today: the artist can tell which one is the good one, but what if is the future and the artist is dead? do we need a token that identifies the artist statement? and who verifies that the content of the email was not forged? isn't a piece of paper with a signature in a closet inside a notary office a simple mechanism? What makes NFT special, except that probably collector are actually paying to collect NFTs and not the item attached to them? I know many collectors, I don't see them collecting digital fingerprints
- dorkwood 6y agoI think the real answer is "because it boosts the economy and gets more artists involved".
- GauntletWizard 6y agoI pay real money to have artists endorse my association with digital artworks they have created on my behalf. For all intents and purposes, these are not works for hire - The artist retains the rights, I have just sponsored their creation. Doing so post-facto isn't insane, either. The artist gets paid, I get warm fuzzies. The blockchain is nice in that it takes control of that endorsement out of the artist's hands, so they can't "take it back" and stop supporting that endorsement. I'm certain that has happened to people. I'm also certain that this cure is worse than the disease.
- debbiedowner 6y agoMaybe if you buy an NFT of an image you own 1/2000th of the rights and then can sue people for 1/2000th of the royalties when they tweet or blog it? I could get behind that. One interesting dilemma for prestigious artists is as their work resells at auction at higher prices they don't get any of the money, except when they go create a new artwork for their higher priced market. A way to fix this could be by the artist always being able to make genesis blocks for past artwork NFTs. NFTs with image rights would be great for news photographers and paparazzi for starters. Or rather it would be good for lawyers representing them?
- throwaway_kufu 6y agoThe ongoing commission to artists for future sales already exists in many NFTs
- meheleventyone 6y agoFrom an IP perspective aren’t NFTs the perfect sale? Basically you can let people squabble over ownership of the NFT without having to give up any IP rights over the work itself. At least when you buy a physical painting you can do what you want with it.