3 ms·
I don’t know what you consider a “serious ISP”, or what serious people do, but I’m confident that 10/10 of the big ISPs have Solarwinds on their corporate netwo
by Spooky23 6y ago
I don’t know what you consider a “serious ISP”, or what serious people do, but I’m confident that 10/10 of the big ISPs have Solarwinds on their corporate network.
The customer facing stuff may be different, but once you own the LAN, you own the company.
Their play was a
cheaper, easier, multi-vendor toolset for enterprise networks. You’d pay half of whatever the Cisco dreck costs, and not need an army of consultants to tend it.
I’d argue that the vast majority of network people do not demonstrate strong Unix skill sets. Windows tools FTW in most enterprises, as dumb as that may be.
- walrus01 6y ago> I don’t know what you consider a “serious ISP” Something that's big enough and has a wide enough enough reach that other network operators with presence at major IX points know its AS number by sight - the same way people will recognize AS174 as Cogent or AS1299 as Telia, for instance. Or an ISP that is big enough that its wholly-owned/controlled fiber network spans most of a state, or several states, and has other major ISPs riding on it (whether as lit 10/100G customers, or dark fiber IRUs, or whatever). Something big enough to have a whole team of guys with bucket trucks and fiber equipment running around building the physical internet, while at the same time there's an office/work-from-home environment with 4 or 5 people whose job title has some form of "network engineer" in it, building the network at OSI layers 2/3. Or for an ISP that is not middle-mile/last-mile focused, and is rather a hosting/colocation company, something with significant datacenter presence at or near major IX points, as measured in square feet of space leased, kW of electrical power and cooling. > I’m confident that 10/10 of the big ISPs Which ASes would those be? If you can find a documented instance of a top-50 (by CAIDA ASRANK size) ISP using solarwinds to run its core stuff, please provide a reference to it... https://asrank.caida.org/asns https://asrank.caida.org/asns
- vitus 6y agoThe most likely source of said claims would be something like SolarWinds's customer list, which they took offline in December. http://web.archive.org/web/20201214030038/https://www.solarwinds.com/company/customers http://web.archive.org/web/20201214030038/https://www.solarw... "Our customer list includes: ... All ten of the top ten US telecommunications companies" I see... AT&T, Sprint, Comcast, Level 3 (now CenturyLink, still AS3356) for US-based ISPs. Telecom Italia made the shortlist, too. (And an honorable mention for Cisco, which was also apparently explicitly targeted: https://tools.cisco.com/security/center/resources/solarwinds_orion_event_response; https://tools.cisco.com/security/center/resources/solarwinds... "While Cisco does not generally use SolarWinds for its enterprise network management or monitoring, we have isolated and removed the Orion installations from a small number of Cisco assets.") That said, it doesn't say anything about _how_ the ISPs were using SolarWinds, just that they were in some capacity. But with any infiltration, it doesn't matter if it's widely used, so long as it's used somewhere that can be used as a launching pad for a follow-up attack. edit: apparently CenturyLink rebranded as Lumen last year. They're still AS3356 (and its subsidiary networks) to me.
- lucb1e 6y ago> I don’t know what you consider a “serious ISP” I understood this as referring to their definition higher up in their answer: > > ISPs that have 50,000+ customers, or are supporting more than that through other smaller ISPs that are downstream of them