3 ms·
> Bizarrely, the buyer doesn’t leave empty-handed, because the scammer then actually sends them a much cheaper and nastier alternative handlebar bag – complete
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Bizarrely, the buyer doesn’t leave empty-handed, because the scammer then actually sends them a much cheaper and nastier alternative handlebar bag – complete with tracking details and proof of delivery. This isn’t out of benevolence: it fulfils their contractual obligations, and removes the ammunition for buyers to dispute the transaction with PayPal or their bank.
I don't understand how it removes ammunition at all.
I show eBay or my bank a photo of what was advertised, a photo of what I received, the charge gets reversed, and if this happens too many times to the company they lose the ability to take credit cards or to list on eBay at all.
What am I missing? Is this specifically a bank account - PayPal - AliExpress combo or something? Marketplaces don't usually exist very long if they provide zero buyer protection from fraudulent/deceptive sellers.
- Nextgrid 6y agoNeither eBay nor PayPal care enough to even have a human review the disputes most of the time. A valid tracking number (even if the package is empty) is often enough to lose a dispute. If you’re lucky, you’re going to get a monkey reviewing it which isn’t paid enough nor is competent enough to evaluate the quality of the item received based on the pictures. Your bank will indeed care more but most people don’t bother or value access to PayPal more than the scam money (since PayPal will often close your account if you file a chargeback with the bank).
- crazygringo 6y agoI don't even know how to file a dispute without a human involved. Customer service handles it. When you deal with them over the phone it's usually pretty reasonable. They're not evaluating the cut of a diamond. All the photos in the article would obviously be settled in favor of the buyer. Also why would PayPal close a buyer's account after a chargeback? They'll just debit the seller. Why would PayPal even care? I searched online and can't find a single instance of anyone complaining about that having happened.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> Customer service handles it Customer service is not always the one actually making the decision. They might be some early-stage filter to guard against obvious mistakes/misunderstandings, but after that it can very well go into a queue where either a automation or an underpaid human handles it. That's the only reason I can think of for the various horror stories where people have been left out of pocked by PayPal despite evidence that would convince any reasonable person. > Also why would PayPal close a buyer's account after a chargeback It's common in "big tech" to close entire accounts in retaliation after a chargeback (I've heard of Google doing it, and maybe others) so I'm assuming PayPal would do the same. Chargebacks also cost them a fee (in addition to the disputed amount) so there is a business case for discouraging chargebacks. And when a huge chunk of your business is based on screwing people and the margins are already razor-thin, do you really want to keep customers who demonstrated their ability to fight back?
- crazygringo 6y agoSorry, but sounds to me like all you have are assumptions rather than facts. I don't know why you think chargebacks are handled by an "automaton" (not true) or "underpaid" (irrelevant) human. And you're admitting you're extrapolating from the behavior of consumer companies to PayPal. But PayPal is different because it's not eating the cost of anything. It passes it onto the seller. It has zero business motivation to block such a buyer if they buyer is in the right. And since it's not easy to find any complaints of them doing so... it looks like they're not.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> you think chargebacks are handled by an "automaton" (not true) or "underpaid" (irrelevant) human I am talking about PayPal disputes (within the PayPal platform), not disputes/chargebacks from your bank. There are plenty of stories out there (both as a seller and as a buyer) where PayPal sides with the wrong side despite ample amounts of evidence. The only explanation could be (bad) automation or idiots. Edit: Indeed, I have mostly assumptions. I have not personally used PayPal enough to get into any trouble (because I didn't trust them for anything high-value in the first place), though the possibility of said trouble (and other nasty stuff they're doing, like their data sharing processes) was enough for me to completely stop doing business with them. I have however worked at a business that used PayPal to broker payments (we weren't the seller - just a marketplace linking up sellers and buyers) and the dispute process was hit and miss. Some disputes were completely legitimate and had plenty of evidence and yet PayPal sided with the wrong party. I have also read stories online about how scammers are abusing the PayPal dispute process to steal goods by sending back empty/bogus returns (which PayPal considers legitimate because of the tracking number). I also know people whose PayPal accounts were closed because they were processing payments that PayPal didn't "like" for some reason (despite being totally legal), and the process was to close the account had hold the funds hostage for about a year before the seller can finally withdraw them. This does not take as long with any legitimate bank. As a reason I have more than enough evidence to conclude that the company is scummy and use this to base my assumptions upon.
- teddyh 6y agoOff topic, but might I suggest being careful using the word “monkey”? It’s probably not what you meant, but an unsympathetic reader might interpret it like you meant to call the actual people reviewers “monkeys”. And “monkey” is a known racial slur when applied to people.
- Nextgrid 6y agoI am intending to use it to refer to people, without any kind of racial connotations though. Maybe "idiots" would be a better word.
- URSpider94 6y agoThe point is to confuse the situation just enough to give them some cover to get their money out. If the ship nothing, then they’ll get shut down immediately. If they ship a thing, and in fact it is a handlebar bag, then they can report back to the card companies that it’s an ordinary customer dispute over quality of the goods, and they’ll likely win some of the chargebacks, and more importantly keep them in play while they continue to collect money. The majority of customers probably will just keep the piece of junk and be bitter about it. They aren’t aiming to stay in business for a long time. Just long enough to collect money from a few thousand customers.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> What am I missing? You're missing that 'nothing arrived' is clear cut, while 'it's not quite what I was expecting' is extremely subjective. I know the products are clearly not what was advertised, but even answering the question 'did your package arrive' with 'yes' probably makes the dispute go from an immediate refund to a long protracted process. Someone has to look at the photo, they may not know about the product domain and not be able to tell... etc.
- 55555 6y agoThe vast majority of consumers will file a chargeback under the wrong reason, or give insufficient evidence, or will lose the chargeback due to an automated system siding with the merchant because there is a tracking number present. For example, someone who receives such a crappy knock off bag may tell their bank that they "didnt receive" what they bought. Then the merchant provides the bank with a tracking number and wins the case. Disputing product quality or claiming deceptive advertising are less likely to work out for the buyer. If you want to win a chargeback as a buyer, file it as a fraudulent charge (implying your card details were stolen).