3 ms·
It's a good point. My uni's Master's level security coursework was surprisingly very math heavy. A typical class started with about 60 people and ended with abo
by bane 15y ago
It's a good point. My uni's Master's level security coursework was surprisingly very math heavy. A typical class started with about 60 people and ended with about 10 very exhausted students.
Folks without a strong math background, expecting to learn how to tweak file permissions or domain controllers or something were in for a rude surprise when we cracked open a textbook that consisted of mostly greek letters and pages of proofs and lemmas.
But having studied some hard maths in my undergrad, I walked away with a feeling I couldn't shake that much of it was form over function. We spent weeks showing proofs of very simple security circumstances "atomic changes to an access control list are provable secure" and then summed it up with "anything more complex than this, like nonatomic changes to an ACL are provably insecure".
And that was that. I came away very disappointed in the field as a whole, that instead of spending time pragmatically finding ways of improving security in an applied sense, we were spending an inordinate amount of time cranking through higher level maths that just showed the whole thing was hopeless in the end anyways.
Depressing.
- omaranto 15y agoIt may be disappointing that many things are provably insecure, but if they are, isn't it good to know that?
- bane 15y agoAbsolutely. It's totally not an area I plan on working in, but it was a fascinating insight into the field. I ended up respecting it quite a bit more, there was a lot more thought in the field than I had expected.
- marshray 15y agoBut now you have really good ammunition when you need to explain to someone else why his race-condition laden system of nonatomic asynchronous updates is insecure.