4 ms·
Why is hibernation even a thing? I can count the number of times I've wanted it on zero fingers.
by jeffbee 6y ago
Why is hibernation even a thing? I can count the number of times I've wanted it on zero fingers.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoI'd absolutely love to use it on my secondary machine, a desktop PC running Windows 10 – just hibernate and pick up right where I've been a few days later without leaving it in standby blinking its super bright LED aggressively. Sadly if I send it to hibernate the PC will always turn itself back on in the night, so no hibernate for me...
- watermelon0 6y agoYou should check `powercfg lastwake` via PowerShell, and Event Viewer, to determine what wakes up your PC. I had similar issues, and IIRC, I had to disable wakeups for network adapters in Device Manager.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoI've tried lots of things from the first page of google results but I don't think I've tried that. Will give it a shot for sure!
- djs55 6y agoThank you for this -- I've been bothered by my Windows PC not sleeping properly for the best part of a year. `powercfg lastwake` indicated the Ethernet adapter and then disabling the option "Wake on Pattern Match" has allowed the computer to sleep soundly.
- mcv 6y agoI really do not understand Windows 10. It really seems like Windows 10 laptops and PCs are unable to sleep. They keep waking up, and then refuse to sleep. Frequently I find my work laptop in the morning turned on by itself, screen on, fan blowing enthusiastically. Power management in Windows 10 seems to be utterly broken. It certainly doesn't obey any of my settings.
- Karunamon 6y agoLaptops, mostly, to maximize battery life. If I'm going on a flight, I'll charge and hibernate my system at home, bag it, then drive to the airport and get through security. This is about a 2 hours process and entails zero battery drain.
- jeffbee 6y agoBut what's the real value over a cold boot? Wake from hibernate takes a lot longer than a cold boot, and to me it doesn't seem to save any time.
- watermelon0 6y agoYou don't lose open apps, files, tabs, etc., so your work is not interrupted. I've not perceived any time difference between cold boot and wake from hibernation, on a decently fast SSD.
- l3s2d 6y agoWhich OS are you using? I've never noticed a difference between cold boot and hibernate on Linux.
- jeffbee 6y agoAre you sure you're including the amortized lifetime cost of whatever you had to do / whatever you will have to do to troubleshoot Linux resume-from-disk? I kid, but I do use Linux, it's just a Linux that doesn't even offer hibernate and boots cold in one second: ChromeOS.
- bscphil 6y agoAnecdata: back in the days when I was using Ubuntu (pre-Unity) on what was even at the time moderately old hardware, there was an obvious difference. Standard bootup took 20-30 seconds, resuming from hibernation took multiple minutes. Just thinking about it on an abstract level, it's not that unintuitive that resuming from hibernation should be slower than both cold boot and resuming from sleep. When you cold boot you need to load the kernel and startup programs into memory. With hibernation you need to load the whole previous operating state into storage, which is going to mean multiple GBs need to be read from your swap partition into memory. It's not hard to imagine that on many systems the hard drive will be the slowest piece of hardware.
- eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7 6y agoTo prevent a machine with full disk-encryption from having its key in memory while you're not watching it: - With hibernation it is possible to store the hibernation file on the encrypted root partition so you will have to re-enter the password during boot. - With suspend-to-RAM, it would always be in memory.