4 ms·
True. While it is important for the advancement and validation of treatments, Evidence Based Medicine and the quest for "perfect RCTs" has become the new cult f
by raverbashing 6y ago
True. While it is important for the advancement and validation of treatments, Evidence Based Medicine and the quest for "perfect RCTs" has become the new cult for a lot of people
RCTs are a validating procedure, it doesn't mean that people are having zero protection after one dose (of course it is great if we can quantify that and see if it's worth it or not)
As an example, see how for the AZ vaccine the people that got half a dose accidentally at first got (apparently) more protection than from whoever has gotten a first full dose, however, only the full dose was approved (though on the other hand, the J&J vaccine has more virions than the AZ one)
> Sadly, very few people acknowledged that prudence had a very real cost in additional infections, deaths, risk of mutations, slower economic recovery.
Exactly. Now we just need to convince people that maybe, just maybe, it would be a good idea to not have susceptible populations be Vitamin D deficient during a pandemic. You know, just in case.
- refurb 6y agoThis criticism of “a quest for perfect RCTs” makes me chuckle. There are so many shit trials out there that sponsors do their best to torture desired results out of its kind of embarrassing. Instead of saying “prudence has real costs” it would be more accurate to say “having reliable information take time”
- raverbashing 6y agoThe existence of crap trials does not exclude that people are over-critical sometimes, and people take the crap trials that "validate the null (or preferred) hypothesis" at face value frequently as well.
- refurb 6y agoA big risk I don't see flagged is the risk of losing the public's confidence in the vaccine approval process. People are already skeptical of the safety, despite pretty robust trials. Imagine if they went with one dose and it turned out to be marginally effective? Imagine how many people will just opt out of vaccines entirely?