9 ms·
A single cell slime mold makes decisions without a central nervous system
- Barrin92 6y agoGreat book on the topic is Wetware: A Computer in Every Living Cell. It really does a lot to show the complexity and amount of work that is done within every-single cell purely at a mechanical or chemical level, and has made me a lot more skeptical about the reductionism that is common today in a lot of AI related fields.
- lisper 6y agoMeh. A thermostat makes decisions without a central nervous system too. But the title of the article is actually, "A memory without a brain", which is actually much more interesting. A better rewrite of the title would be "A single-cell slime mold can remember the locations of food sources", which is actually pretty cool.
- robotresearcher 6y agoAn alternate stance is that a thermostat is, or takes the role of, a central nervous system in the system it regulates.
- iujjkfjdkkdkf 6y agoPour water into a maze (or create a potential difference across a conductor) and you'll see that as new current flows in, it doesnt explore every pathway but takes the correct path through. This intelligent behavior arises from the simple compulsions things to reach equal potential. The slime mold experiments are cool because they connect simple compulsions with emergent intelligent behavior in an organism. I have wondered if it's the same for us, if conciousness is really just the sum of all our simple compulsions, arising from basic rules - like is water "conscious" of wanting to seek it's own level, ions conscious of wanting to react, etc, and together that makes up what human conciousness is?
- mrmonkeyman 6y agoYou call it equal potential, like it is some obvious thing, but what if that is intelligence?
- sidpatil 6y agoI think it's something interesting to consider. I'd describe it more as computation than as intelligence, but I also do keep in mind that there is no single universally-agreed-upon definition of intelligence, so the goalposts can shift. For an example, consider the AI effect [1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect
- asimpletune 6y agoWait, um, can you explain this more or tell me what to search for to learn more about this? I googled “simple compulsions” already
- sidpatil 6y agoEmergence [1] is what I thought of at first. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence
- cercatrova 6y agoI don't understand the point about the water, why wouldn't it cover uniformly the entire maze? Assuming the maze is level with the ground. Edit: thanks for the clarification all, I didn't realize it was an entrance exit maze, I was thinking of one sealed on a ll sides where the water can't get out.
- jfoutz 6y agoI think if a maze has an entrance and and exit, and there's some surface tension at the leading edge, when you pour water into the entrance, it'll fill the maze like a breadth first search. as soon as the water can flow freely at the exit it'll drain because there's less resistance at the exit. pour a little water on a counter and you'll get a round area with little walls at the edge, if it's not clean it'll kinda break down where it's dirty (surface tension doesn't hold up) once it hits the edge of the counter, the surface tension pushes all the water over the edge. if it's a perfectly flat clean surface it'll make a perfect circle till it hits the edge. so the water won't fill every nook and cranny of the maze, it'll start a new circle at every decision point, till one of those circles goes over the edge.
- AndrewKemendo 6y agoWith few exceptions, the AI research community completely overlooks the "rest of the body" when it comes to thinking about intelligent systems and focuses too much on the brain. The amount of computing going on in the peripheral nervous system is staggering - and when you look at HOW and WHERE this computing works with effectors and sensors you realize how much of intelligence is reliant on those systems being there. Brains are interesting - but they actually don't do all that much when it comes to the majority of how people interact with the real world, and frankly you don't need that much (physical mass of) brain to be intelligent.
- patmorgan23 6y agoThis. Mind vs body is a false dicotomy. Your mind is fully integrated through out your body. Physical and mental health are so heavily intertwined.
- avaldeso 6y ago[Citation needed]
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoI think the second sentence is opinion, not something that could be objectively tested. Last sentence is mostly true. Sick people are much less happy than when they are healthy.
- tiborsaas 6y agoYou can cite your body. Before you get offended, really, just examine it as a system, and try to explain how can you have a conscious experience without any sensory input. Even with a lame comparison to computers, the machines also need a lot of stuff to put a CPU to work.
- SkyPuncher 6y ago> You can cite your body. At best, this is an anecdote.
- tapoxi 6y agoHighly recommend this episode of Nova: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/secret-mind-of-slime/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/secret-mind-of-slime/
- majkinetor 6y agohttps://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7z6ycz https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x7z6ycz
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fiftyfifty 6y agoPrevious studies were already zeroing in on the cytoskeleton (made of microtubules) as the likely place where slime molds stored their memories: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4594612/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4594612/ The break through here is that they've found the memories are encapsulated in the diameter of the microtubules: “Past feeding events are embedded in the hierarchy of tube diameters, specifically in the arrangement of thick and thin tubes in the network.”
- rhyn00 6y agoThis sort of reminds me of the book "Vehicles: Experiments in Synthetic Psychology" by Valentino Braitenberg. In this book the author starts a series of thought experiments by constructing small "vehicles" which drive around on a table top. The vehicles start with very simple behaviors, then he applies evolution (by vehicles falling off, or being selectively removed) while adding more complex behaviors until the vehicles eventually become intelligent. In a way the slim mold is a analogous to one of the simple vehicles that ends up becoming more intelligent through the simple mechanisms and evolution. Book link: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/vehicles https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/vehicles
- peignoir 6y agoReminds me of the book wetware discribing a similar behavior
- szhu 6y agoThis doesn't feel as shocking or startling to me as it probably does for many. A slime mold is a collection of adjacent cells without a hierarchy that can act together to make decisions. Our brain is also a collection of adjacent cells that can act together to make decisions. They're fundamentally the same thing. It seems like people are shocked primarily because we arbitrarily defined a notion of certain collections of cells being an "organism", and a slime mold doesn't fit within this ontology.
- dangerbird2 6y agoWhen slime molds are in the plasmodial life stage (when they become macroscopic and "smart" according to the paper), it is not a collection of cells, but a single cytoplasm sharing multiple nuclei, making it a technically single-celled organism. Of course, because it contains so many nuclei over such a large area, it ends up behaving like a multicellular colonial organism.
- imvetri 6y agoA single slime mold cell is a neuron cell, A neuron is capable of learning without central nervous system. Don't compare leaf to a forest.
- emrah 6y agoWithout the "How" in the title, the meaning changes a bit and made it sound to me like scientists were shocked that a single called organism could be intelligent without a nervous system, when of course a nervous system is not an absolute requirement to behave intelligently