6 ms·
The reason I will never touch day trading is, that it is basically the same thing HF traders do. Only 1000 times slower. So I will loose against these guys ever
by hef19898 6y ago
The reason I will never touch day trading is, that it is basically the same thing HF traders do. Only 1000 times slower. So I will loose against these guys every single time. And even HF traders loose money.
The only single stock investments I have came from employment, either through RSUs or employer sponsored stock buying programs. RSUs are just coming to you, and why would I not take stock at 50% discount?
The only exception would be money I don't need. So gambling, as I don't care if I loose it or not. But usually I do other stuff with that money.
- DSingularity 6y agoYou are wrong. HF traders front run to profit off individual trades by beating them to better prices. Day traders try to get an edge and exploit it to profit intraday by simply selling higher than they bought.
- andi999 6y agoAnd why would that be sustainably possible?
- DSingularity 6y agoHF firms? Or pattern traders? I’m not sure if my answer is good enough but the volatility is always there to exploit.
- BasedInfra 6y agoFront running is illegal. Its payment for order flow which is earning off the spread while also keep it tight and liquidity in the market.
- DSingularity 6y agoSo... basically front running ?? That’s what it seems like you are describing. They make money when they manage to get ahead and provide the liquidity needed to fill the orders. What am I missing?
- seabird 6y agoIt is not front running, and can only be conflated with it if you don't know what front running actually is, don't know what PFOF actually is, or both. Firms that pay for order flow are paying to be the counterparty to transactions that have razor-thin arbitrage opportunities. They are not placing orders with advance knowledge of upcoming orders; they are reacting extremely quickly to fraction-of-a-cent spreads in the price of a security and pocketing the difference.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoNothing. I can’t believe it’s legal. And yes, I know about the free trading it has supposedly provided. Maybe free trades are dangerous to to most retail traders?
- porb121 6y agoa market maker by law has to provide prices better than offered by the current market. frontrunning does not do that.
- ubercow13 6y agoSo you would rather your liquidity was provided by someone slower and more expensive?
- sweetheart 6y agoDay trading is difficult and requires a lot of practice, knowledge, and patience, but saying you’ll lose every time isn’t always true. There are many many profitable retail day traders. HFT don’t really compete too much because they look to scalp differently.
- swader999 6y agoA three to five percent success rate applied to a large population will produce "many many" winners. This is true.
- dannyw 6y agoThe people who make money tend to put in more money.
- bidirectional 6y agoYou can apply the same logic to suggest no one should start a business.
- swader999 6y agoYes, if it's business is day trading. The success rates of other kinds of businesses vary.
- WJW 6y agoThat would be appropriate advice for a large slice of the population, so I don't see the problem there.
- Spivak 6y agoBusiness is a field where we know for sure that being better at it increases your chances to the point where your expected profit is positive. Individual day trading is less clear. Sure, you can get better at it to increase your odds but it seems like that isn’t enough to make those skilled people in aggregate make money. The analogy in a casino is that perfect play means you’ll do better but there’s still house advantage and so on average perfect players will still lose money.
- NOTaCODERR 6y agoI guess you mean High Frequency Trading, but I don't understand your reasoning. I'm an old school day trader as I execute my trades by hand.
- waynesonfire 6y agoAnother way that I like to think about this is that if you think of a stock price as following brownian motion (e.g. follows a random, well defined process), then it follows that the stock price has a scaling-invariance property. In other words, the stock prices follows the same process regardless of the time window.. e.g. a day for day traders, milliseconds for HF, or years for long term value holders. Now, brownian motion is just a model for a stock price so YMMV, but still an interesting idea. An investor can pick whatever time horizon interests them and that they're most suitable to take advantage of; e.g. HF traders take advantage of low latencies, technical analysis for day traders, and macro / micro economic analysis for value. As the OP said, there are these three ways to look at this and at the end of the day, all are gambling with different time-horizons and this is possible because of this scale-invariance property.
- papito 6y agoHF traders DO NOT lose money. They see the trading world a few milliseconds into the future. The whole game is rigged in a way where they cannot lose. They only lose if someone screws up, human error, all that.
- bidirectional 6y agoHow do you explain all of the HFT firms that have gone out of business over the years? They're competing with each other, it's a very competitive space that doesn't even capture that much value compared to the people they replaced.
- yummypaint 6y agoTo win at HFT you have to have lower latency than your competitors. The NYSE rents server space in their building for this very purpose and makes alot of money doing so. If you don't have hardware there you will go out of business trying to compete with those who do. From a broad perspective it kind of looks like companies being allowed to skim freely from the market so long as the right people get their cut.
- kortilla 6y agoGetting early views of an order book and trades does not allow you to skim. No matter how close you are to the servers, you’re still seeing the data after the order has gone in and has either been matched or entered into the order book. There is no way for them to beat the order.
- necrotic_comp 6y agoThis is 100% not true. As mentioned below, HFT competes against itself, and there are measures to protect against latency manipulation.
- papito 6y agoI go from the account of Flash Boys where an HFT firm manager claimed they lose only once in four years - due to a human error.
- bidirectional 6y agoThat's really not true. Most HFT firms are running strategies which are completely unrelated to anything a day trader would do, and most of the time they're helping you by being market makers rather than competing with you. If what you said was true, no bank or hedge fund would run a trading desk. HFT captures just a slice of overall trading profits.
- auxym 6y agoI'd argue that the reason why HFTs don't do day trading strategies, is because it's not profitable in the long run (ie, negative expected value). Which backs GPs point.
- Anon1096 6y agoHedge funds engage in day trading, and there's many successful hedge funds. So the expected value can be positive if you're sufficiently skilled.
- yomly 6y agoI always find these kinds of thought processes interesting "day trading always leads to losses". As with poker, anything which is predictable can lead to meta strategy which can be gamed: this is why GTO players can be outplayed by player-focused players, at least on occasion. But occasion matters! Life isn't a nice continuous stream, it's lumpy. Circumstantial performance makes a difference - and that's why Greece could win the Euros despite probably not being a good football team. Day trading is probably quite a hard discipline to follow, but that doesn't mean that everyone who does it is destined to fail. Anecdotally 50% of marriages end in divorce but that apparently doesn't stop most people getting married...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CuriouslyC 6y agoThere are a number of different "day trading" strategies, some are easier and more reliable than others. Different strategies will work for different stocks, so it's really just a matter of getting to know the stock. Big institutional traders are limited by risk, the fact that they are market makers for stocks in many cases, and the returns required need to be high, since their salaries are pretty ridiculous. Because of this, the fact that you're generally worse than them isn't a dealbreaker, just find a mid volume niche and learn it really well, then trade around general market volatility.
- chasebank 6y agoI'm only correcting you because I'd want to be corrected. Loose = Not firmly fixed into place. Lose = Cease to retain. Lose is the verb you want to use here.
- bonestamp2 6y ago> I will lose against these guys every single time It's true that you will not outperform HFTs consistently. But that's fine, you don't have to outperform them to make money. That's because the stock market is not just you and the HFTs, there are hundreds of thousands of other traders. If there's enough liquidity, you and the HFT can make the exact same trade and have the exact same profit (percentage). The HFT is not necessarily against you. You might buy low and sell high to an HFT, and the HFT might sell even higher and make additional profit. Again, you both made money and weren't against each other.