4 ms·
That would give the browser owners control over ad blocking behaviours, while they rely on funding from companies which sell ads. That's not a great situation f
by viraptor 6y ago
That would give the browser owners control over ad blocking behaviours, while they rely on funding from companies which sell ads. That's not a great situation for the users. The authors providing an unopinionated API for plugins is much safer.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoYou're absolutely right. Though the problem is the conflict of interest, not the idea that these things should be browser features. The truth is everyone trusta these particular extensions and so they should have more privileges and deeper integration. For example, Google's new extension APIs actually make a lot of sense: they allow extensions to do useful things without actually looking at user data. This is a big improvement and it should be imposed on all extensions on their store. It's just that uBlock Origin is so important that it shouldn't be subjected to these limitations. That's why I say it might as well become a browser feature.
- pseudalopex 6y agoManifest v3 doesn't stop extensions observing requests. Just blocking them.
- taneq 6y agoThat tell you a bit about priorities then.
- jimmydorry 6y agoManifest v3 still had loopholes that allowed looking at data, but it was very clear what this was a step change toward.
- crummy 6y agoIsn't this whole thread in response to Firefox blocking tracking from an ad company?
- e_proxus 6y agoOr they can just cripple the APIs so extensions don’t work as effectively anymore. Kind of what happened in practice with Safari (although this was not malicious).
- GekkePrutser 6y agoIndeed, it also raises the question: Why do we pay for something like MS Office but not for a browser? I think I'd pay 50/year or so for Firefox.. Even if Chrome is free. In fact I already donate about half that. But the point of course is getting a lot of people to do that so they can achieve independence from Google.
- africanboy 6y agobut if they are already taking money from Google, why should I donate to Firefox? IMO companies that aren't getting direct money from ad businesses deserve my donations more. There's no guarantee that reaching independence from Google will stop Firefox from getting Google money, disabling features that made Firefox different or cutting jobs.
- blacklight 6y agoMost of their revenue comes from Google (for providing it as the default search engine in the browser) because they can't get enough revenue from donations to pay for their work. If they got enough money from donations, they wouldn't need to rely on Google's spare change.
- labawi 6y agoDo you realize that 0 donations go to Firefox development? Firefox development is done by Mozilla Corporation (that doesn't accept any donations, AFAIK). A part of their earnings are given to their owner, Mozilla Foundation, that you are suggested to donate to, and it may not be a bad idea, but it does not finance Firefox development in any way.
- chokeartist 6y ago> That would give the browser owners control over ad blocking behaviours, while they rely on funding from companies which sell ads. Then they have a shit business model and should fold. Stop making shitty excuses for bad behavior. Technology should enhance the human experience, not enslave it.