4 ms·
As a designer, I complain about touch screens from the perspective of their awful usability and ergonomics. When that fails, I take a different tack, and praise
by karaterobot 6y ago
As a designer, I complain about touch screens from the perspective of their awful usability and ergonomics. When that fails, I take a different tack, and praise the tactility, precision, and overall fit-and-finish represented by high quality physical knobs and buttons. So far, automakers have not taken notice, and I am beginning to think they don't much care what I think.
I hope the author of this article gets more traction by being outraged about the accessibility concerns. That might work. Good idea!
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> So far, automakers have not taken notice, and I am beginning to think they don't much care what I think. On the one side, you have improved ergonomics and increased safety for the driver. But that needs to be weighed against: - Lower and more streamlined production costs, because if you stuff the UI into a touchscreen, all the car designers need to worry about is where to place a rectangular slab of glass; all UI design and adjustments can be made in parallel, likely by a contractor, and it has zero impact on manufacturing the car itself. - Better marketability, as you can present touchscreens as high tech (despite buying the cheapest possible ones that can render an image and occasionally register touch events). That other side benefits the vendor much more than user satisfaction.
- unityByFreedom 6y agoNothing wrong with wooing tech enthusiasts, but when that comes at the expense of safety we can take a second look. These screens may contribute to more accidents and if research eventually shows this no one will want one. I don't see how screens reduce cost since software has become an added cost, and tactile buttons have worked at low cost for decades.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> I don't see how screens reduce cost since software has become an added cost, and tactile buttons have worked at low cost for decades. Half of the software is already done (those touchscreens don't get programmed from scratch, there's usually Windows or Android in them). You can outsource making it. But most importantly, this decouples car's UI from the rest of the design work. With physical knobs, you have to design, place and route wiring for panels, which interferes with designing and placing and routing of everything else. You have to mind the BOM and manufacturing - maybe getting the kind of button your designer wants, in a kind of panel they want, is prohibitively expensive? Making any change in controls arrangement involves altering physical elements of the car, which may need coordination with other teams designing other parts of the interior. Touchscreen gives you a nice separation from all of this. From the POV of designing the rest of the car, all you need is to fit a glass slab somewhere, and route wiring to that single place. Then, the UI people can do whatever they want. Change shape, arrangement and color of buttons 20 times a day. They can work on it while the physical desing of the car is already finalized. Hell, they can redesign the UI even after cars have already started to roll off the line. This kind of flexibility and decoupling saves money.
- unityByFreedom 6y ago> You can outsource making it. I don't regard this as cost saving either. If a bug causes a crash you'll spend double time fixing it. > With physical knobs, you have to design Several suitable such designs already exist. We don't need to reinvent the wheel or change for the sake of change.