5 ms·
I think what's more likely than any kind of legal injunction is that FB and Apple will come to a "mutual understanding". Maybe Facebook will license Apple Maps
by rchaud 6y ago
I think what's more likely than any kind of legal injunction is that FB and Apple will come to a "mutual understanding". Maybe Facebook will license Apple Maps (for a princely sum) and make some symbolic compromise on data collection that lets Apple water down the permission dialogs.
- stingraycharles 6y agoI’d argue that Apple executives realize that privacy is one of the unique USPs of Apple compared to their main competitor, since the value exchange between Apple and their customers is simpler (customer pays Apple money, Apple delivers hardware/software). Now that so much news has spread about these privacy additions, Apple selling out will actively hurt this image they have spent a lot of time building. It’s going to have to be an extremely lucrative agreement between them and Facebook for it to be worth it.
- rorykoehler 6y agoI thought that until I realised Apple also have a billion dollar ads business
- sodality2 6y agoThe problem is Apple relies on hardware sales. FB's entire business from the top down is ad money. And source for a billion dollar ad business? That sounds way higher than my initial impression. (And google paying to be the default SE is not advertising imo)
- rorykoehler 6y agohttps://9to5mac.com/2019/11/15/apple-ad-revenue/ https://9to5mac.com/2019/11/15/apple-ad-revenue/
- whynaut 6y agoWell.. > Apple’s most recent earnings report revealed that it earned $12.51B from Services in calendar Q3/fiscal Q4, though there is no breakdown on how much of this comes from ad revenue. Notice the 'could's: > Samik Chatterjee argued the company could leverage the millions of users who search its App Store and Safari browser daily to generate the stellar growth seen by Facebook and Google in recent years. > he launch of Apple TV+, coupled with Apple Inc’s foray into digital services, could help the company increase its income from advertising by more than five fold to $11 billion annually This article is literally just speculation. Actually, it's quoting someone's speculation. > The report seems highly speculative…
- kergonath 6y agoThere’s a lot of guesswork there. It’s even worse than that actually, they assume that their advertising operation will grow as Facebook’s. It is extremely implausible under current conditions (no tracking and ads limited to the stores). So yeah, if Apple were Facebook, ads would be important to them. And even the wildest estimates put it far short on the actual money maker, which is hardware sales. When push comes to shove, if they have to choose between ad and devices, they won’t hesitate long.
- rorykoehler 6y agoI saw a few articles when I searched from the previous year which also projected growth to the $2b number the next year but as Apple bundles it all in services who knows?
- katbyte 6y agoAt 2 billion it’s < 1% their revenue (265b)
- rorykoehler 6y agoYes I'm hoping that should be enough to dampen their ambitions
- somjeed 6y agoHere's a nice source of revenue from google ($9 billion/year): https://finance.yahoo.com/news/google-reportedly-pays-apple-9-billion-remain-iphone-000053314.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/google-reportedly-pays-apple-...
- nicoburns 6y agoDoes Apple's ad business track users though? It seems to me that an ad business shouldn't need to in order to be effective.
- mektrik 6y agoIt does - it provides advertisers data on which users have downloaded their app after seeing specific adverts.
- newscracker 6y agoPlease provide links or citations showing what information about a user is shared with advertiser.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThis is honestly pretty reasonable. Apple already knows which apps I download and this is made fairly clear (you're logged into the App Store and your account lists all apps you obtained). Apple also knows which App Store ads I saw given that their server sent them to me in the first place. The ads are (at least for now) limited to the App Store and don't carry over across the web or other Apple apps. Thus I don't see the problem with Apple using the data they've already got to provide anonymized conversion metrics to app developers.
- zepto 6y ago> advertisers data on which users have downloaded their app after seeing specific adverts. No it doesn’t. It provides aggregate statistics on downloads, just like any analytics server. No data on users is shared.
- singhrac 6y agoI see what you mean, but iPhone says are something like 150x that. If privacy concerns weaken even 1%, that wouldn't be worth it. Maybe that's unlikely, I'm not sure.
- zepto 6y agoAn ad business that doesn’t rely on accumulating user data for targeting. Ads do not always mean user tracking.
- throw_away892 6y agoThis looks like simply naive thinking. Without evidence to backup your statement about Apple, everything about it breaks the cardinal rule of the ads business.
- zepto 6y agoNot really. Google built a super successful ad business on search terms alone, long before they got into user tracking. Do you have any evidence that Apple tracks users for their ad business - which only sells ads for apps when users search for them?
- throw_away892 6y agoCheck their ad business brief - https://searchads.apple.com/ https://searchads.apple.com/ As requested, evidence of tracking in iPhones - https://www.forbes.com/sites/kateoflahertyuk/2020/11/16/apple-iphone-tracking-heres-how-to-turn-it-off/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kateoflahertyuk/2020/11/16/appl...
- zepto 6y ago> As requested, evidence of tracking in iPhones That isn’t evidence of Apple tracking anything. IDFA is used by Facebook and ad-tech companies. Apple are switching IDFA to be Opt-In rather than opt out. That’s what Facebook is complaining about.
- throw_away892 6y ago> IDFA The mechanism for tracking users is already present. What more proof do you need? Even if you manage to toggle 3rd parties out of your phone. You cannot toggle the Apple out of it.
- purpmint008 6y ago> (customer pays Apple money, Apple delivers hardware/software). Pretty soon, this'll turn into: customer has to keep paying Apple because of vendor lock-in.
- tbrock 6y agoI don’t think Apple would bat an eye if Facebook decided to not publish their software on their platform.
- brokencode 6y agoI think they would. Facebook products are a huge part of any app ecosystem, and without them, Apple customers would be pissed. Ecosystem concerns aren’t as relevant today, since both Android and iOS have everything you’d want, but in the olden days of Blackberry, Microsoft, and many other mobile operating system vendors trying to compete, they were always seriously hampered by their lack of ecosystem.
- sebasvisser 6y agoYou’d be surprised how many fb users (mostly less technical) just use a browser to access fb.. They don’t need an app in the App Store to do so.. So this might actually be a fight against the strange people working at Facebook that will get them to rethink what it is they do everyday..
- artificial 6y agoI think this is a good case for what Apps bring to the table and highlighting what the cost is privacy wise. As a developer I think apps are cool, the way they're leaking data is awful. This is something the platforms need to step up control over and I think that because this isn't the case there's an incentive to keep things as they are. Like automotive and the iterative improvements.
- r00fus 6y agoI tell my mom she needs to use FF containers for FB. I set it up so she can't do anything else. She's happy & gets to see her extended family pics/updates.
- Hallucinaut 6y agoIsn't this done automatically now in Firefox? As in, you don't need to even install the containers add-on as Facebook and related properties are automatically opened in a default Facebook container?